From diffusive mass transfer in Stokes flow to low Reynolds number Marangoni boats

TL;DR

This paper develops a comprehensive theory for the self-propulsion of symmetric Marangoni boats at low Reynolds numbers, analyzing diffusion, advection, and symmetry breaking effects to understand their swimming behavior.

Contribution

It introduces novel analytical and numerical results for concentration profiles and the Nusselt number, and characterizes the relation between Peclet number and swimming velocity, including symmetry breaking conditions.

Findings

Two distinct swimming regimes identified: diffusive and advection-dominated.

Spontaneous symmetry breaking enables propulsion in symmetric boats at a critical Peclet number.

Derived a general expression for Marangoni forces including flow contributions.

Abstract

We present a theory for the self-propulsion of symmetric, half spherical Marangoni boats (soap or camphor boats) at low Reynolds numbers. Propulsion is generated by release (diffusive emission or dissolution) of water-soluble surfactant molecules, which modulate the air-water interfacial tension. Propulsion either requires asymmetric release or spontaneous symmetry breaking by coupling to advection for a perfectly symmetrical swimmer. We study the diffusion-advection problem for a sphere in Stokes flow analytically and numerically both for constant concentration and constant flux boundary conditions. We derive novel results for concentration profiles under constant flux boundary conditions and for the Nusselt number (the dimensionless ratio of total emitted flux and diffusive flux). Based on these results, we analyze the Marangoni boat for small Marangoni propulsion (low Peclet number) and show that two swimming regimes exist, a diffusive regime at low velocities and an advection-dominated regime at high swimmer velocities. We describe both the limit of large Marangoni propulsion (high Peclet number) and the effects from evaporation by approximative analytical theories. The swimming velocity is determined by force balance, and we obtain a general expression for the Marangoni forces, which comprises both direct Marangoni forces from the surface tension gradient and Marangoni flow forces. We unravel, whether the Marangoni flow contribution is exerting a forward or backward force during propulsion. Our main result is the relation between Peclet number and swimming velocity. Spontaneous symmetry breaking and, thus, swimming occurs for a perfectly symmetrical swimmer above a critical Peclet number, which becomes small for large system sizes. We find a supercritical swimming bifurcation for a symmetric swimmer and an avoided bifurcation in the presence of an asymmetry.