NMR Investigation on Honeycomb Iridate Ag$_3$LiIr$_2$O$_6$

TL;DR

This study uses NMR techniques to analyze the magnetic and structural properties of Ag$_3$LiIr$_2$O$_6$, revealing partial magnetic order and the effects of structural disorder, which complicate the identification of a true spin liquid state.

Contribution

It provides detailed NMR analysis of two samples, demonstrating how structural disorder influences magnetic properties and the interpretation of spin liquid behavior.

Findings

Sample A shows magnetic order with a sharp transition at 9 K.

Sample B exhibits disorder-induced weak magnetism without long-range order.

Structural disorder can mimic spin liquid signatures in highly disordered Kitaev materials.

Abstract

We investigate the structural and magnetic properties of a Kitaev spin liquid candidate material Ag$_3$LiIr$_2$O$_6$ based on $^7$Li nuclear magnetic resonance line shape, Knight shift and spin-lattice relaxation rate $1/T_1$. The first sample A shows signatures of magnetically ordered spins, and exhibits one sharp $^7$Li peak with FWHM increasing significantly below 14~K. $1/T_1^{stretch}$ of this sample displays a broad local maximum at 40~K, followed by a very sharp peak at $T_N = 9\pm1$~K due to critical slowing down of Ir spin fluctuations, a typical signature of magnetic long range order. In order to shed light on the position-by-position variation of $1/T_1$ throughout the sample, we use Inverse Laplace Transform $T_1$ analysis based on Tikhonov regularization to deduce the density distribution function $P(1/T_1)$. We demonstrate that $\sim 60\%$ of Ir spins are statically ordered at the NMR measurement timescale but the rest of the sample volume remains paramagnetic even at 4.2~K, presumably because of structural disorder induced primarily by stacking faults. In order to further investigate the influence of structural disorder, we compare these NMR results with those of a second sample B, which has been shown by transmission electron microscope to have domains with unwanted Ag inclusion at Li and Ir sites within the Ir honeycomb planes. The sample B displays an additional NMR peak with relative intensity of $\sim 17\%$. The small Knight shift and $1/T_1$ of these defect-induced $^7$Li sites and the enhancement of bulk susceptibility at low temperatures suggest that these defects generate domains of only weakly magnetic Ir spins accompanied by free spins, leading to a lack of clear signatures of long-range order. The apparent lack of long-range order could be easily misinterpreted as evidence for the realization of a spin liquid ground state in highly disordered Kitaev lattice.