Cost-efficiency trade-offs of the human brain network revealed by a multiobjective evolutionary algorithm

TL;DR

This study uses a multiobjective evolutionary algorithm to explore the cost-efficiency trade-off in human brain networks, providing evidence that their structure is largely shaped by this trade-off and revealing additional influencing factors.

Contribution

It introduces a novel application of multiobjective evolutionary algorithms to model and analyze the cost-efficiency trade-off in human brain networks, linking synthetic and empirical network features.

Findings

Synthetic networks replicate many empirical connections.

Synthetic networks exhibit small-world and modular structures similar to empirical networks.

Empirical and synthetic networks show comparable robustness to random attacks.

Abstract

It is widely believed that the formation of brain network structure is under the pressure of optimal trade-off between reducing wiring cost and promoting communication efficiency. However, the question of whether this trade-off exists in empirical human brain networks and, if so, how it takes effect is still not well understood. Here, we employed a multiobjective evolutionary algorithm to directly and quantitatively explore the cost-efficiency trade-off in human brain networks. Using this algorithm, we generated a population of synthetic networks with optimal but diverse cost-efficiency trade-offs. It was found that these synthetic networks could not only reproduce a large portion of connections in the empirical brain networks but also embed a resembling small-world structure. Moreover, the synthetic and empirical brain networks were found similar in terms of the spatial arrangement of hub regions and the modular structure, which are two important topological features widely assumed to be outcomes of cost-efficiency trade-offs. The synthetic networks had high robustness against random attack as the empirical brain networks did. Additionally, we also revealed some differences of the synthetic networks from the empirical brain networks, including lower segregated processing capacity and weaker robustness against targeted attack. These findings provide direct and quantitative evidence that the structure of human brain networks is indeed largely influenced by optimal cost-efficiency trade-offs. We also suggest that some additional factors (e.g., segregated processing capacity) might jointly determine the network organization with cost and efficiency.