Quantum limits for stationary force sensing

TL;DR

This paper develops a unified theory of fundamental quantum limits in stationary force sensing, revealing a phase transition between two regimes and showing that quantum-limited sensitivity can be achieved even with lossy systems.

Contribution

It introduces the Dissipative Quantum Limit (DQL), unifies it with the Quantum Cramér-Rao Bound, and analyzes the phase transition between these regimes in quantum force sensors.

Findings

A phase transition occurs at the boundary between QCRB and DQL regimes.

Quantum-limited sensitivity can be achieved with lossy meter systems.

DQL originates from non-autocommutativity of thermal noise and can be overcome in non-stationary measurements.

Abstract

State-of-the-art sensors of force, motion and magnetic fields have reached the sensitivity where the quantum noise of the meter is significant or even dominant. In particular, the sensitivity of the best optomechanical devices has reached the Standard Quantum Limit (SQL), which directly follows from the Heisenberg uncertainty relation and corresponds to balancing the measurement imprecision and the perturbation of the probe by the quantum back action of the meter. The SQL is not truly fundamental and several methods for its overcoming have been proposed and demonstrated. At the same time, two quantum sensitivity constraints which are more fundamental are known. The first limit arises from the finiteness of the probing strength (in the case of optical interferometers - of the circulating optical power) and is known as the Energetic Quantum Limit or, in a more general context, as the Quantum Cram\'{e}r-Rao Bound (QCRB). The second limit arises from the dissipative dynamics of the probe, which prevents full efficacy of the quantum back action evasion techniques developed for overcoming the SQL. No particular name has been assigned to this limit; we propose the term Dissipative Quantum Limit (DQL) for it. Here we develop a unified theory of these two fundamental limits by deriving the general sensitivity constraint from which they follow as particular cases. Our analysis reveals a phase transition occurring at the boundary between the QCRB-dominated and the DQL regimes, manifested by the discontinuous derivatives of the optimal spectral densities of the meter field quantum noise. This leads to the counter-intuitive (but favorable) finding that quantum-limited sensitivity can be achieved with certain lossy meter systems. Finally, we show that the DQL originates from the non-autocommutativity of the internal thermal noise of the probe and that it can be overcome in non-stationary measurements.