Tight Bounds for Online Graph Partitioning

TL;DR

This paper introduces a nearly optimal randomized online algorithm for graph partitioning that minimizes vertex moves while respecting server capacities, achieving a competitive ratio of O(log l + log k).

Contribution

It presents a polynomial-time randomized algorithm with optimal competitive ratio bounds and resolves the deterministic ratio open problem, introducing a novel ILP-based technique.

Findings

Achieves an upper bound of O(log l + log k) on competitive ratio.

Proves a lower bound of Ω(log l + log k) for randomized algorithms.

Provides a deterministic algorithm with a competitive ratio of Θ(l log k).

Abstract

We consider the following online optimization problem. We are given a graph $G$ and each vertex of the graph is assigned to one of $\ell$ servers, where servers have capacity $k$ and we assume that the graph has $\ell \cdot k$ vertices. Initially, $G$ does not contain any edges and then the edges of $G$ are revealed one-by-one. The goal is to design an online algorithm $\operatorname{ONL}$, which always places the connected components induced by the revealed edges on the same server and never exceeds the server capacities by more than $\varepsilon k$ for constant $\varepsilon>0$. Whenever $\operatorname{ONL}$ learns about a new edge, the algorithm is allowed to move vertices from one server to another. Its objective is to minimize the number of vertex moves. More specifically, $\operatorname{ONL}$ should minimize the competitive ratio: the total cost $\operatorname{ONL}$ incurs compared to an optimal offline algorithm $\operatorname{OPT}$. Our main contribution is a polynomial-time randomized algorithm, that is asymptotically optimal: we derive an upper bound of $O(\log \ell + \log k)$ on its competitive ratio and show that no randomized online algorithm can achieve a competitive ratio of less than $\Omega(\log \ell + \log k)$. We also settle the open problem of the achievable competitive ratio by deterministic online algorithms, by deriving a competitive ratio of $\Theta(\ell \lg k)$; to this end, we present an improved lower bound as well as a deterministic polynomial-time online algorithm. Our algorithms rely on a novel technique which combines efficient integer programming with a combinatorial approach for maintaining ILP solutions. We believe this technique is of independent interest and will find further applications in the future.