The JAGWAR Prowls LIGO/Virgo O3 Paper I: Radio Search of a Possible Multi-Messenger Counterpart of the Binary Black Hole Merger Candidate S191216ap

TL;DR

This study used the VLA to search for radio signals from a potential multi-messenger counterpart of a binary black hole merger candidate, setting deep upper limits and constraining jet models.

Contribution

It provides the deepest radio upper limits to date on a BBH merger candidate and constrains jet opening angles based on non-detection.

Findings

No definitive radio counterpart was detected.

The radio luminosity upper limit is 5-10 times deeper than previous searches.

Jet models with opening angles less than 20 degrees are ruled out for on-axis jets.

Abstract

We present a sensitive search with the Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array (VLA) for the radio counterpart of the gravitational wave candidate S191216ap, classified as a binary black hole merger, and suggested to be a possible multi-messenger event, based on the detection of a high energy neutrino and a TeV photon. We carried out a blind search at C band (4--8 GHz) over 0.3 deg$^2$ of the gamma-ray counterpart of S191216ap reported by the High-Altitude Water Cherenkov Observatory (HAWC). Our search, spanning three epochs over 130 days post-merger and having mean source-detection threshold of 75$\mu$Jy/beam (4$\sigma$), yielded 5 variable sources associated with AGN activity and no definitive counterpart of S191216ap. We find $<$2\% ($3.0\pm1.3$\%) of the persistent radio sources at 6 GHz to be variable on a timescale of $<$1 week (week--months), consistent with previous radio variability studies. Our 4$\sigma$ radio luminosity upper limit of $\sim$1.2$\times{10}^{28}$ erg s$^{-1}$ Hz$^{-1}$ on the afterglow of S191216ap, within the HAWC error region, is 5--10 times deeper than previous BBH radio afterglow searches. Comparing this upper limit with theoretical expectations given by \citeauthor{Perna2019} for putative jets launched by BBH mergers, for on-axis jets having energy $\simeq10^{49}$ erg, we can rule out jet opening angles $\lesssim$20 degrees (assuming that the counterpart lies within the 1$\sigma$ HAWC region that we observed).