Supergranule aggregation for constant heat flux-driven turbulent convection

TL;DR

This study investigates the formation of supergranules in turbulent Rayleigh-Bénard convection driven by constant heat flux, revealing an inverse cascade process that links pattern formation to turbulence.

Contribution

It demonstrates that supergranule aggregation persists into turbulent regimes and connects weakly nonlinear patterns with fully developed turbulence.

Findings

Supergranules form over long timescales in turbulent convection.

Inverse cascade observed in temperature variance and kinetic energy.

Flow modes at different scales interact to produce larger convection patterns.

Abstract

Turbulent convection processes in nature are often found to be organized in a hierarchy of plume structures and flow patterns. The gradual aggregation of convection cells or granules to a supergranule which eventually fills the whole horizontal layer is reported and analysed in spectral element direct numerical simulations of three-dimensional turbulent Rayleigh-B\'{e}nard convection at an aspect ratio of $60$. The formation proceeds over a time span of more than $10^4$ convective time units for the largest accessible Rayleigh number and occurs only when the turbulence is driven by a constant heat flux which is imposed at the bottom and top planes enclosing the convection layer. The resulting gradual inverse cascade process is observed for both temperature variance and turbulent kinetic energy. An additional analysis of the leading Lyapunov vector field for the full turbulent flow trajectory in its high-dimensional phase space demonstrates that turbulent flow modes at a certain scale continue to give rise locally to modes with longer wavelength in the turbulent case. As a consequence successively larger convection patterns grow until the horizontal extension of the layer is reached. This instability mechanism, which is known to exist near the onset of constant heat flux-driven convection, is shown here to persist into the fully developed turbulent flow regime thus connecting weakly nonlinear pattern formation with the one in fully developed turbulence. We discuss possible implications of our study for observed, but not yet consistently numerically reproducible, solar supergranulation which could lead to improved simulation models of surface convection in the Sun.