Handling Bidirectional Control Flow: Technical Report

TL;DR

This paper introduces bidirectional algebraic effects, a new abstraction for managing complex, bidirectional control flow in programming languages, unifying effect handling with object-oriented programming and ensuring type safety.

Contribution

It formalizes bidirectional effects, develops a core language with semantics and proofs, and demonstrates efficient implementation, advancing control flow management in effectful programming.

Findings

Bidirectional effects enable natural control transfer patterns.

The core language is proven type-safe and abstraction-safe.

Preliminary experiments show efficient implementation.

Abstract

Pressed by the difficulty of writing asynchronous, event-driven code, mainstream languages have recently been building in support for a variety of advanced control-flow features. Meanwhile, experimental language designs have suggested effect handlers as a unifying solution to programmer-defined control effects, subsuming exceptions, generators, and async--await. Despite these trends, complex control flow---in particular, control flow exhibiting a bidirectional pattern---remains challenging to manage. We introduce bidirectional algebraic effects, a new programming abstraction that supports bidirectional control transfer in a more natural way. Handlers of bidirectional effects can raise further effects to transfer control back to the site where the initiating effect was raised, and can use themselves to handle their own effects. We present applications of this expressive power, which falls out naturally as we push toward the unification of effectful programming with object-oriented programming. We pin down the mechanism and the unification formally using a core language that generalizes to effect operations and effect handlers. The usual propagation semantics of control effects such as exceptions conflicts with modular reasoning in the presence of effect polymorphism---it breaks parametricity. Bidirectionality exacerbates the problem. Hence, we set out to show the core language, which builds on the existing tunneling semantics for algebraic effects, is not only type-safe (no effects go unhandled), but also abstraction-safe (no effects are accidentally handled). We devise a step-indexed logical-relations model, and construct its parametricity and soundness proofs. These core results are fully mechanized in Coq. Preliminary experiments show that as a first-class language feature, bidirectional handlers can be implemented efficiently.