Tristable flow states and reversal of the large-scale circulation in two-dimensional circular convection cells

TL;DR

This study uses numerical simulations to explore flow states and reversals in a 2D circular Rayleigh-Bénard convection cell, revealing a new chaotic state and mapping the conditions for flow reversals.

Contribution

It identifies a new long-lived chaotic flow state and maps the phase diagram of flow states and reversals in the Ra-Pr parameter space.

Findings

Existence of a new chaotic flow state.

Reversal of LSC involves secondary rolls growing and breaking the primary roll.

Flow states depend on Ra and Pr, with reversals limited to certain Pr ranges.

Abstract

We present a numerical study of the flow states and reversals of the large-scale circulation (LSC) in a two-dimensional circular Rayleigh-B\'enard cell. Long-time direct numerical simulations are carried out in the Rayleigh number ($Ra$) range $10^{7} \le Ra \le 10^{8}$ and Prandtl number ($Pr$) range $2.0 \le Pr \le 20.0$. We found that a new, long-lived, chaotic flow state exists, in addition to the commonly observed circulation states (the LSC in the clockwise and counterclockwise directions). The circulation states consist of one primary roll in the middle and two secondary rolls near the top and bottom circular walls. The primary roll becomes stronger and larger, while the two secondary rolls diminish, with increasing $Ra$. Our results suggest that the reversal of the LSC is accompanied by the secondary rolls growing, breaking the primary roll and then connecting to form a new primary roll with reversed direction. We mapped out the phase diagram of the existence of the LSC and the reversal in the $Ra$-$Pr$ space, which reveals that the flow is in the circulation states when $Ra$ is large and $Pr$ is small. The reversal of the LSC can only occur in a limited $Pr$ range. The phase diagram can be understood in terms of competition between the thermal and viscous diffusions. We also found that the internal flow states manifested themselves into global properties such as Nusselt and Reynolds numbers.