Early dark energy is not excluded by current large-scale structure data

TL;DR

This paper shows that early dark energy cannot be ruled out by current large-scale structure data due to prior choices, and it remains a viable solution to the Hubble tension, warranting further investigation.

Contribution

It demonstrates that previous constraints on early dark energy are influenced by prior assumptions, and EDE remains compatible with current data, challenging earlier conclusions.

Findings

EDE and ΛCDM models fit data equally well with large EDE fraction.

Current data do not exclude EDE as a solution to the Hubble tension.

Potential tension exists between BOSS and Planck power-spectrum amplitudes.

Abstract

We revisit the impact of early dark energy (EDE) on galaxy clustering using BOSS galaxy power spectra, analyzed using the effective field theory (EFT) of large-scale structure (LSS), and anisotropies of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) from Planck. Recent studies found that these data place stringent constraints on the maximum abundance of EDE allowed in the Universe. We argue here that their conclusions are a consequence of their choice of priors on the EDE parameter space, rather than any disagreement between the data and the model. For example, when considering EFT-LSS, CMB, and high-redshift supernovae data we find the EDE and $\Lambda$CDM models can provide statistically indistinguishable fits ($\Delta \chi^2 = 0.12$) with a relatively large value for the maximum fraction of energy density in the EDE ($f_{\rm ede} = 0.09$) and Hubble constant ($H_0 = 71$ km/s/Mpc) in the EDE model. Moreover, we demonstrate that the constraining power added from the inclusion of EFT-LSS traces to the potential tension between the power-spectrum amplitudes $A_s$ derived from BOSS and from Planck that arises even within the context of $\Lambda$CDM. Until this is better understood, caution should be used when interpreting EFT-BOSS+Planck constraints to models beyond $\Lambda$CDM. These findings suggest that EDE still provides a potential resolution to the Hubble tension and that it is worthwhile to test the predictions of EDE with future data-sets and further study its theoretical possibilities.