Second-order adjoint-based sensitivity for hydrodynamic stability and control

TL;DR

This paper introduces a second-order adjoint sensitivity method to accurately predict flow stability changes due to control, improving upon first-order methods and enabling optimal control design for flow stabilization.

Contribution

The study develops a second-order sensitivity operator for hydrodynamic stability, applied to flow past a cylinder, enhancing prediction accuracy and control optimization without computing controlled base flows.

Findings

Second-order sensitivity improves eigenvalue variation predictions.

Regions with negligible first-order effects are identified where second-order effects dominate.

Optimal control maximizing stabilization is computed via quadratic eigenvalue problem.

Abstract

Adjoint-based sensitivity analysis is routinely used today to assess efficiently the effect of open-loop control on the linear stability properties of unstable flows. Sensitivity maps identify regions where small-amplitude control is the most effective, i.e. yields the largest first-order (linear) eigenvalue variation. In this study an adjoint method is proposed for computing a second-order (quadratic) sensitivity operator, and applied to the flow past a circular cylinder, controlled with a steady body force or a passive device model. Maps of second-order eigenvalue variations are obtained, without computing controlled base flows and eigenmodes. For finite control amplitudes, the second-order analysis improves the accuracy of the first-order prediction, and informs about its range of validity, and whether it underestimates or overestimates the actual eigenvalue variation. Regions are identified where control has little or no first-order effect but a second-order effect. In the cylinder wake, the effect of a control cylinder tends to be underestimated by the first-order sensitivity, and including second-order effects yields larger regions of flow restabilisation. Second-order effects can be decomposed into two mechanisms: second-order base flow modification, and interaction between first-order modifications of the base flow and eigenmode. Both contribute equally in general in sensitive regions of the cylinder wake. Exploiting the second-order sensitivity operator, the optimal control maximising the total second-order stabilisation is computed via a quadratic eigenvalue problem. The approach is applicable to other types of control (e.g. wall blowing/suction and shape deformation) and other eigenvalue problems (e.g. amplification of time-harmonic perturbations, or resolvent gain, in stable flows).