Revisiting the Modifiable Areal Unit Problem in Deep Traffic Prediction with Visual Analytics

TL;DR

This paper presents a visual analytics approach to address the modifiable areal unit problem in deep traffic prediction, enabling experts to explore how spatial aggregation scales affect model performance and stability.

Contribution

It introduces a novel visual analytics system combining spatial and multiscale visualization techniques to investigate the impact of data aggregation on deep traffic prediction models.

Findings

Geographical scale variations significantly affect prediction accuracy.

Interactive visual exploration aids experts in model development.

The approach improves understanding of spatial aggregation effects on deep learning models.

Abstract

Deep learning methods are being increasingly used for urban traffic prediction where spatiotemporal traffic data is aggregated into sequentially organized matrices that are then fed into convolution-based residual neural networks. However, the widely known modifiable areal unit problem within such aggregation processes can lead to perturbations in the network inputs. This issue can significantly destabilize the feature embeddings and the predictions, rendering deep networks much less useful for the experts. This paper approaches this challenge by leveraging unit visualization techniques that enable the investigation of many-to-many relationships between dynamically varied multi-scalar aggregations of urban traffic data and neural network predictions. Through regular exchanges with a domain expert, we design and develop a visual analytics solution that integrates 1) a Bivariate Map equipped with an advanced bivariate colormap to simultaneously depict input traffic and prediction errors across space, 2) a Morans I Scatterplot that provides local indicators of spatial association analysis, and 3) a Multi-scale Attribution View that arranges non-linear dot plots in a tree layout to promote model analysis and comparison across scales. We evaluate our approach through a series of case studies involving a real-world dataset of Shenzhen taxi trips, and through interviews with domain experts. We observe that geographical scale variations have important impact on prediction performances, and interactive visual exploration of dynamically varying inputs and outputs benefit experts in the development of deep traffic prediction models.