Efficient Covariate Balancing for the Local Average Treatment Effect

TL;DR

This paper introduces an empirical balancing method for estimating treatment effects with noncompliance, achieving low bias and variance without functional form assumptions, and applicable in high-dimensional settings.

Contribution

It develops a novel covariate balancing approach for instrumental variable analysis that improves finite sample properties and can incorporate regularization for high-dimensional data.

Findings

Exact finite sample balance across instrument groups

Reduced bias and variance compared to inverse probability weighting

Effective in high-dimensional confounding scenarios

Abstract

This paper develops an empirical balancing approach for the estimation of treatment effects under two-sided noncompliance using a binary conditionally independent instrumental variable. The method weighs both treatment and outcome information with inverse probabilities to produce exact finite sample balance across instrument level groups. It is free of functional form assumptions on the outcome or the treatment selection step. By tailoring the loss function for the instrument propensity scores, the resulting treatment effect estimates exhibit both low bias and a reduced variance in finite samples compared to conventional inverse probability weighting methods. The estimator is automatically weight normalized and has similar bias properties compared to conventional two-stage least squares estimation under constant causal effects for the compliers. We provide conditions for asymptotic normality and semiparametric efficiency and demonstrate how to utilize additional information about the treatment selection step for bias reduction in finite samples. The method can be easily combined with regularization or other statistical learning approaches to deal with a high-dimensional number of observed confounding variables. Monte Carlo simulations suggest that the theoretical advantages translate well to finite samples. The method is illustrated in an empirical example.