Lower Bounds for XOR of Forrelations

TL;DR

This paper establishes lower bounds on classical protocols for XOR of Forrelation functions, demonstrating quantum advantages in computing certain partial Boolean functions with significantly less resources.

Contribution

It provides the first lower bounds for classical advantage in XOR of Forrelation functions and constructs functions with quantum protocols vastly outperforming classical ones.

Findings

Classical advantage for XOR of Forrelation functions is tightly bounded.

Quantum protocols can compute certain functions with polylogarithmic cost.

Classical circuits have only quasipolynomial advantage over random guessing for specific functions.

Abstract

The Forrelation problem, introduced by Aaronson [A10] and Aaronson and Ambainis [AA15], is a well studied problem in the context of separating quantum and classical models. Variants of this problem were used to give exponential separations between quantum and classical query complexity [A10, AA15]; quantum query complexity and bounded-depth circuits [RT19]; and quantum and classical communication complexity [GRT19]. In all these separations, the lower bound for the classical model only holds when the advantage of the protocol (over a random guess) is more than $\approx 1/\sqrt{N}$, that is, the success probability is larger than $\approx 1/2 + 1/\sqrt{N}$. To achieve separations when the classical protocol has smaller advantage, we study in this work the XOR of $k$ independent copies of the Forrelation function (where $k\ll N$). We prove a very general result that shows that any family of Boolean functions that is closed under restrictions, whose Fourier mass at level $2k$ is bounded by $\alpha^k$, cannot compute the XOR of $k$ independent copies of the Forrelation function with advantage better than $O\left(\frac{\alpha^k}{{N^{k/2}}}\right)$. This is a strengthening of a result of [CHLT19], that gave a similar result for $k=1$, using the technique of [RT19]. As an application of our result, we give the first example of a partial Boolean function that can be computed by a simultaneous-message quantum protocol of cost $\mbox{polylog}(N)$ (when players share $\mbox{polylog}(N)$ EPR pairs), however, any classical interactive randomized protocol of cost at most $\tilde{o}(N^{1/4})$, has quasipolynomially small advantage over a random guess. We also give the first example of a partial Boolean function that has a quantum query algorithm of cost $\mbox{polylog}(N)$, and such that, any constant-depth circuit of quasipolynomial size has quasipolynomially small advantage over a random guess.