Can ethnic tolerance curb self-reinforcing school segregation? A theoretical Agent Based Model

TL;DR

This paper uses an agent-based model to explore how ethnic tolerance among parents influences school segregation, revealing conditions under which increased tolerance can reduce segregation levels.

Contribution

It introduces a novel agent-based model for school segregation that incorporates individual preferences, heterogeneity, and residential segregation patterns, extending previous residential models.

Findings

Ethnic school segregation is robust even with high tolerance levels.

A moderate residential segregation combined with high local school preference maximizes tolerance impact.

Heterogeneity in parental tolerance influences segregation dynamics significantly.

Abstract

Schelling and Sakoda prominently proposed computational models suggesting that strong ethnic residential segregation can be the unintended outcome of a self-reinforcing dynamic driven by choices of individuals with rather tolerant ethnic preferences. There are only few attempts to apply this view to school choice, another important arena in which ethnic segregation occurs. In the current paper, we explore with an agent-based theoretical model similar to those proposed for residential segregation, how ethnic tolerance among parents can affect the level of school segregation. More specifically, we ask whether and under which conditions school segregation could be reduced if more parents hold tolerant ethnic preferences. We move beyond earlier models of school segregation in three ways. First, we model individual school choices using a random utility discrete choice approach. Second, we vary the pattern of ethnic segregation in the residential context of school choices systematically, comparing residential maps in which segregation is unrelated to parents' level of tolerance to residential maps reflecting their ethnic preferences. Thirdly, we introduce heterogeneity in tolerance levels among parents belonging to the same group. Our simulation experiments suggest that ethnic school segregation can be a very robust phenomenon, occurring even when about half of the population prefers mixed to segregated schools. However, we also identify a sweet spot in the parameter space in which a larger proportion of tolerant parents makes the biggest difference. This is the case when the preference for nearby schools weighs heavily in parents' utility function and the residential map is only moderately segregated. Further experiments are presented that unravel the underlying mechanisms.