\omega-categorical structures avoiding height 1 identities

TL;DR

This paper investigates the algebraic conditions for the tractability of CSPs in infinite structures, demonstrating that local satisfaction of certain identities does not imply global satisfaction, thus challenging existing conjectures.

Contribution

It provides a counterexample showing that height 1 identities are insufficient for characterizing CSP tractability in certain infinite structures, and resolves a key open problem in the algebraic theory of  structures.

Findings

Counterexample for height 1 identities and CSP tractability

Difference between local and global satisfaction of identities

Resolution of an open problem in  algebraic theory

Abstract

The algebraic dichotomy conjecture for Constraint Satisfaction Problems (CSPs) of reducts of (infinite) finitely bounded homogeneous structures states that such CSPs are polynomial-time tractable if the model-complete core of the template has a pseudo-Siggers polymorphism, and NP-complete otherwise. One of the important questions related to the dichotomy conjecture is whether, similarly to the case of finite structures, the condition of having a pseudo-Siggers polymorphism can be replaced by the condition of having polymorphisms satisfying a fixed set of identities of height 1, i.e., identities which do not contain any nesting of functional symbols. We provide a negative answer to this question by constructing for each non-trivial set of height 1 identities a structure within the range of the conjecture whose polymorphisms do not satisfy these identities, but whose CSP is tractable nevertheless. An equivalent formulation of the dichotomy conjecture characterizes tractability of the CSP via the local satisfaction of non-trivial height 1 identities by polymorphisms of the structure. We show that local satisfaction and global satisfaction of non-trivial height 1 identities differ for $\omega$-categorical structures with less than doubly exponential orbit growth, thereby resolving one of the main open problems in the algebraic theory of such structures.