Upper boundaries of AGN regions in optical diagnostic diagrams

TL;DR

This study identifies upper boundaries in optical diagnostic diagrams for AGN narrow-line regions, constraining physical parameters like SED shape and N/O ratios using photoionization models and MaNGA survey data.

Contribution

It reveals the existence of upper boundaries in optical BPT diagrams for AGN regions and constrains the AGN SED shape and N/O ratios through detailed modeling.

Findings

Upper boundaries exist in optical BPT diagrams for AGN regions.

The SED power-law index is constrained to ≤ -1.40 ± 0.05.

High N/O ratios are favored by the data in the [N II] BPT diagram.

Abstract

The distribution of galaxies in optical diagnostic diagrams can provide information about their physical parameters when compared with ionization models under proper assumptions. By using a sample of central emitting regions from the MaNGA survey, we find evidence of the existence of upper boundaries for narrow-line regions (NLRs) of active galactic nuclei (AGN) in optical BPT diagrams, especially in the diagrams involving [S II]$\lambda \lambda$6716, 6731/H$\alpha$. Photoionization models can well reproduce the boundaries as a consequence of the decrease of [S II]$\lambda \lambda$6716, 6731/H$\alpha$ and [O III]$\lambda$5007/H$\beta$ ratios at very high metallicity. Whilst the exact location of the upper boundary in the [S II] BPT diagram only weakly depends on the electron density of the ionized cloud and the secondary nitrogen prescription, its dependence on the shapes of the input SEDs is much stronger. This allows us to constrain the power-law index of the AGN SED between 1 Ryd and $\sim100$ Ryd to be less than or equal to $-1.40\pm 0.05$. The coverage of the photoionization models in the [N II] BPT diagram has a stronger dependence on the electron density and the secondary nitrogen prescription. With the density constrained by the [S II] doublet ratio and the input SED constrained by the [S II] BPT diagram, we find that the extent of the data in the [N II] BPT diagram favors those prescriptions with high N/O ratios. Although shock-ionized cloud can produce similar line ratios as those by photoionization, the resulting shapes of the upper boundaries, if exist, would likely be different from those of a photoionizing origin.