Deep Encoder, Shallow Decoder: Reevaluating Non-autoregressive Machine Translation

TL;DR

This paper demonstrates that with a sufficiently deep encoder, simple autoregressive models can outperform non-autoregressive models in translation quality without sacrificing speed, challenging previous assumptions.

Contribution

It shows that optimizing encoder depth and proper evaluation can significantly improve autoregressive models' speed and accuracy, redefining the non-autoregressive vs. autoregressive tradeoff.

Findings

Deep encoders enable shallow decoders to outperform non-autoregressive models.

Previous speed disadvantages of autoregressive models were overestimated.

Proper evaluation protocols reveal autoregressive models can be faster and more accurate.

Abstract

Much recent effort has been invested in non-autoregressive neural machine translation, which appears to be an efficient alternative to state-of-the-art autoregressive machine translation on modern GPUs. In contrast to the latter, where generation is sequential, the former allows generation to be parallelized across target token positions. Some of the latest non-autoregressive models have achieved impressive translation quality-speed tradeoffs compared to autoregressive baselines. In this work, we reexamine this tradeoff and argue that autoregressive baselines can be substantially sped up without loss in accuracy. Specifically, we study autoregressive models with encoders and decoders of varied depths. Our extensive experiments show that given a sufficiently deep encoder, a single-layer autoregressive decoder can substantially outperform strong non-autoregressive models with comparable inference speed. We show that the speed disadvantage for autoregressive baselines compared to non-autoregressive methods has been overestimated in three aspects: suboptimal layer allocation, insufficient speed measurement, and lack of knowledge distillation. Our results establish a new protocol for future research toward fast, accurate machine translation. Our code is available at https://github.com/jungokasai/deep-shallow.