Medium Amplitude Parallel Superposition (MAPS) Rheology, Part 2: Experimental Protocols and Data Analysis

TL;DR

This paper introduces an experimental protocol for MAPS rheology that measures complex material responses to multi-frequency shear, enabling detailed characterization and model validation of complex fluids.

Contribution

It develops a novel experimental method for directly measuring third order complex modulus in MAPS rheology, including data analysis techniques and validation against models.

Findings

Large, rich data set of MAPS response for wormlike micelles

Demonstrates internal consistency and model compatibility of the data

Shows advantages of stress-controlled over strain-controlled experiments

Abstract

An experimental protocol is developed to directly measure the new material functions revealed by medium amplitude parallel superposition (MAPS) rheology. This experimental protocol measures the medium amplitude response of a material to a simple shear deformation composed of three sine waves at different frequencies. Imposing this deformation and measuring the mechanical response reveals a rich data set consisting of up to 19 measurements of the third order complex modulus at distinct three-frequency coordinates. We discuss how the choice of the input frequencies influences the features of the MAPS domain studied by the experiment. A polynomial interpolation method for reducing the bias of measured values from spectral leakage and variance due to noise is discussed, including a derivation of the optimal range of amplitudes for the input signal. This leads to the conclusion that conducting the experiment in a stress-controlled fashion possesses a distinct advantage to the strain-controlled mode. The experimental protocol is demonstrated through measurements of the MAPS response of a model complex fluid: a surfactant solution of wormlike micelles. The resulting data set is indeed large and feature-rich, while still being acquired in a time comparable to similar medium amplitude oscillatory shear (MAOS) experiments. We demonstrate that the data represents measurements of an intrinsic material function by studying its internal consistency, its compatibility with low-frequency predictions for Coleman-Noll simple fluids, and its agreement with data obtained via MAOS amplitude sweeps. Finally, the data is compared to predictions from the corotational Maxwell model to demonstrate the power of MAPS rheology in determining whether a constitutive model is consistent with a material's time-dependent response.