Lunar close encounters compete with the circumterrestrial Lidov-Kozai effect

TL;DR

This paper investigates the complex dynamics of Luna 3's trajectory, revealing that lunar close encounters and intermediate-period effects, not captured by classical Lidov-Kozai theory, critically influence its evolution.

Contribution

The study demonstrates that lunar close encounters and intermediate-period terms are essential for accurately modeling Luna 3's trajectory, highlighting limitations of the classical Lidov-Kozai approach.

Findings

Lunar close encounters decisively affect Luna 3's trajectory.

Intermediate-period oscillations influence inclination and encounter geometry.

Classical Lidov-Kozai theory is inadequate for lunar orbits.

Abstract

Luna 3 (or Lunik 3 in Russian sources) was the first spacecraft to perform a flyby of the Moon. Launched in October 1959 on a translunar trajectory with large semi-major axis and eccentricity, it collided with the Earth in late March 1960. The short, 6-month dynamical lifetime has often been explained through an increase in eccentricity due to the Lidov-Kozai effect. However, the classical Lidov-Kozai solution is only valid in the limit of small semi-major axis ratio, a condition that is satisfied only for solar (but not for lunar) perturbations. We undertook a study of the dynamics of Luna 3 with the aim of assessing the principal mechanisms affecting its evolution. We analyze the Luna 3 trajectory by generating accurate osculating solutions, and by comparing them to integrations of singly- and doubly-averaged equations of motion in vectorial form. Lunar close encounters, which cannot be reproduced in an averaging approach, decisively affect the trajectory and break the doubly-averaged dynamics. Solar perturbations induce oscillations of intermediate period that affect the geometry of the close encounters and cause the singly-averaged and osculating inclinations to change quadrants (the orbital plane ``flips''). We find that the peculiar evolution of Luna 3 can only be explained by taking into account lunar close encounters and intermediate-period terms; such terms are averaged out in the Lidov-Kozai solution, which is not adequate to describe translunar or cislunar trajectories. Understanding the limits of the Lidov-Kozai solution is of particular significance for the motion of objects in the Earth-Moon environment and of exoplanetary systems.