Wide binaries are rare in open clusters

TL;DR

This study uses Gaia DR2 data to analyze the frequency of wide binary stars in open clusters, finding a lower fraction than in the field, with implications for star formation and cluster dynamics.

Contribution

It provides the first detailed measurement of wide binary fractions in open clusters and compares these with other stellar populations, revealing environmental effects on binary survival.

Findings

Wide binary fraction in clusters is about 2-3%.

Clusters show fewer wide binaries than the field.

Looser associations have wide binary fractions similar to or above the field.

Abstract

The population statistics of binary stars are an important output of star formation models. However populations of wide binaries evolve over time due to interactions within a system's birth environment and the unfolding of wide, hierarchical triple systems. Hence the wide binary populations observed in star forming regions or OB associations may not accurately reflect the wide binary populations that will eventually reach the field. We use Gaia DR2 data to select members of three open clusters, Alpha~Per, the Pleiades and Praesepe and to flag cluster members that are likely unresolved binaries due to overluminosity or elevated astrometric noise. We then identify the resolved wide binary population in each cluster, separating it from coincident pairings of unrelated cluster members. We find that these clusters have an average wide binary fraction in the 300-3000\,AU projected separation range of 2.1$\pm^{0.4}_{0.2}$\% increasing to 3.0$\pm^{0.8}_{0.7}$\% for primaries with masses in the 0.5-1.5\,$M_{\odot}$ range. This is significantly below the observed field wide binary fraction, but shows some wide binaries survive in these dynamically highly processed environments. We compare our results with another open cluster (the Hyades) and two populations of young stars that likely originated in looser associations (Young Moving Groups and the Pisces-Eridanus stream). We find that the Hyades also has a deficit of wide binaries while the products of looser associations have wide binary fractions at or above field level.