Average motion of emerging solar active region polarities II: Joy's law

TL;DR

This study measures the evolution of active region tilt angles on the Sun, revealing that Joy's law emerges about two days after active regions appear and is influenced by initial flux separation speeds and surface buffeting.

Contribution

It provides new observational constraints on the emergence and evolution of active region tilt angles, challenging existing flux tube models by showing initial east-west alignment.

Findings

Active regions emerge aligned east-west, contrary to flux tube model predictions.

Joy's law becomes evident approximately two days after emergence.

Tilt angle scatter is influenced by flux and surface buffeting.

Abstract

The tilt of solar active regions described by Joy's law is essential for converting a toroidal field to a poloidal field in Babcock-Leighton dynamo models. In thin flux tube models the Coriolis force causes Joy's law, acting on east-west flows as they rise towards the surface. Our goal is to measure the evolution of the average tilt angle of hundreds of active regions as they emerge, so that we can constrain the origins of Joy's law. We measured the tilt angle of the primary bipoles in 153 emerging active regions in the Solar Dynamics Observatory Helioseismic Emerging Active Region survey. We used line-of-sight magnetic field measurements averaged over 6 hours to define the polarities and measure the tilt angle up to four days after emergence. We find that at the time of emergence the polarities are on average aligned east-west, and that neither the separation nor the tilt depends on latitude. We do find, however, that ARs at higher latitudes have a faster north-south separation speed than those closer to the equator at the emergence time. After emergence, the tilt angle increases and Joy's law is evident about two days later. The scatter in the tilt angle is independent of flux until about one day after emergence, when higher-flux regions have a smaller scatter in tilt angle than lower-flux regions. Our finding that active regions emerge with an east-west alignment is surprising since thin flux tube models predict that tilt angles of rising flux tubes are generated below the surface. Previously reported tilt angle relaxation of deeply anchored flux tubes can be largely explained by the change in east-west separation. We conclude that Joy's law is caused by an inherent north-south separation speed present when the flux first reaches the surface, and that the scatter in the tilt angle is consistent with buffeting of the polarities by supergranulation.