On the Color-Metallicity Relation of the Red Clump and the Reddening Toward the Magellanic Clouds

TL;DR

This study refines the reddening and intrinsic color calibration of the red clump stars in the Magellanic Clouds, impacting distance measurements and the Hubble constant calibration.

Contribution

It introduces three methods to calibrate the red clump's intrinsic color, improving reddening estimates toward the Magellanic Clouds.

Findings

Estimated intrinsic color of LMC red clump: ~0.91

Derived luminosities for LMC and SMC red clump stars

Implications for calibrating the tip of the red giant branch and H0

Abstract

The zero point of the reddening toward the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC) has been the subject of some dispute. Its uncertainty propagates as a systematic error for methods which measure the extragalactic distance scale through knowledge of the absolute extinction of LMC stars. In an effort to resolve this issue, we used three different methods to calibrate the most widely-used metric to predict LMC extinction, the intrinsic color of the red clump, $(V-I)_{RC,0}$, for the inner $\sim$3 degrees of that galaxy. The first approach was to empirically calibrate the color zeropoints of the BaSTI isochrones over a wide metallicity range of ${\Delta}\rm{[Fe/H]} \approx 1.10$ using measurements of red clump stars in 47 Tuc, the Solar Neighborhood, and NGC 6791. From these efforts we also measure these properties of the Solar Neighborhood red clump, ($V-I$, $G_{BP}-K_{s}$, $G-K_{s}$, $G_{RP}-K_{s}$, $J-K_{s}$, $H-K_{s}$, $M_{I}$, $M_{Ks}$)$_{RC,0} =$ (1.02, 2.75, 2.18, 1.52, 0.64, 0.15, $-$0.23, $-$1.63). The second and third methods were to compare the observed colors of the red clump to those of Cepheids and RR Lyrae in the LMC. With these three methods, we estimated the intrinsic color of the red clump of the LMC to be $(V-I)_{RC,0,\rm{LMC}} = \{ \approx 0.93,0.91 \pm 0.02,0.89 \pm 0.02\}$ respectively, and similarly using the first and third method we estimated $ (V-I)_{RC,0,\rm{SMC}} = \{\approx 0.85,0.84 \pm 0.02 \}$ respectively for the Small Magellanic Cloud. We estimate the luminosities to be $M_{I,RC,\rm{LMC}}=-0.26$ and $M_{I,RC,\rm{SMC}}=-0.37$. We show that this has important implications for recent calibrations of the tip of the red giant branch in the Magellanic Clouds used to measure $H_0$.