Self induced class stratification in competitive societies of agents: Nash stability in the presence of envy

TL;DR

This paper models how envy in competitive societies causes self-induced class stratification, which is stable and resistant to political control, with society dynamics depending on utility functions and levels of envy.

Contribution

It introduces a model demonstrating how envy leads to stable class separation and analyzes the universal properties and resistance to political influence of such stratified societies.

Findings

Class stratification is Nash stable and strict.

The fraction of upper class agents decreases with higher envy levels.

Society properties are universal and indirectly controllable.

Abstract

Envy, the inclination to compare rewards, can be expected to unfold when inequalities in terms of payoff differences are generated in competitive societies. It is shown that increasing levels of envy lead inevitably to a self-induced separation into a lower and an upper class. Class stratification is Nash stable and strict, with members of the same class receiving identical rewards. Upper class agents play exclusively pure strategies, all lower class agents the same mixed strategy. The fraction of upper class agents decreases progressively with larger levels of envy, until a single upper class agent is left. Numerical simulations and a complete analytic treatment of a basic reference model, the shopping trouble model, are presented. The properties of the class-stratified society are universal and only indirectly controllable through the underlying utility function, which implies that class stratified societies are intrinsically resistant to political control. Implications for human societies are discussed. It is pointed out that the repercussions of envy are amplified when societies become increasingly competitive.