No pulsed radio emission during a bursting phase of a Galactic magnetar

TL;DR

This study conducted targeted radio observations of a Galactic magnetar during an active phase, finding no pulsed radio emission coincident with SGR bursts, thus challenging the association between magnetar bursts and FRBs.

Contribution

It provides the first extensive radio observational campaign during a magnetar's active phase, setting stringent upper limits on pulsed emission and exploring the conditions for FRB-SGR associations.

Findings

No pulsed radio emission detected during SGR bursts

Upper limit on fluence is eight orders of magnitude lower than FRB 200428

FRB-SGR associations are likely rare or require specific conditions

Abstract

Fast radio bursts (FRBs) are mysterious millisecond-duration radio transients of unknown origin observed at extragalactic distances. It has been long speculated that magnetars are the engine powering repeating bursts from FRB sources, but no convincing evidence has been collected so far\cite{sun19}. Recently, the Galactic magnetar SGR J1935+2154 entered an active phase by emitting intense soft Gamma-ray bursts. One FRB-like event with two peaks (FRB 200428) and a luminosity slightly lower than the faintest extragalactic FRBs was detected from the source, in association with a soft Gamma-ray / hard X-ray flare. Here we report an eight-hour targeted radio observational campaign comprising four sessions and assisted by multi-wavelength (optical and hard X-rays) data. During the third session, 29 soft Gamma-ray repeater (SGR) bursts were detected in Gamma-ray energies. Throughout the observing period, we detected no single dispersed pulsed emission coincident with the arrivals of SGR bursts, but unfortunately we were not observing when the FRB was detected. The non-detection places a fluence upper limit that is eight orders of magnitude lower than the fluence of FRB 200428. Our results suggest that FRB -- SGR burst associations are rare. FRBs may be highly relativistic and geometrically beamed, or FRB-like events associated with SGR bursts may have narrow spectra and characteristic frequencies outside the observed band. It is also possible that the physical conditions required to achieve coherent radiation in SGR bursts are difficult to satisfy, and that only under extreme conditions could an FRB be associated with an SGR burst.