An Evaluation of Change Point Detection Algorithms

TL;DR

This paper emphasizes the importance of evaluating change point detection algorithms on real-world data, introducing a new annotated dataset and benchmarking 14 algorithms to improve understanding of their practical performance.

Contribution

It provides a new annotated dataset of 37 real-world time series and a comprehensive benchmark of 14 algorithms, addressing the gap in real-world evaluation.

Findings

Human annotator agreement analyzed

Evaluation metrics for multiple ground truths proposed

Benchmark results highlight algorithm performance variations

Abstract

Change point detection is an important part of time series analysis, as the presence of a change point indicates an abrupt and significant change in the data generating process. While many algorithms for change point detection have been proposed, comparatively little attention has been paid to evaluating their performance on real-world time series. Algorithms are typically evaluated on simulated data and a small number of commonly-used series with unreliable ground truth. Clearly this does not provide sufficient insight into the comparative performance of these algorithms. Therefore, instead of developing yet another change point detection method, we consider it vastly more important to properly evaluate existing algorithms on real-world data. To achieve this, we present a data set specifically designed for the evaluation of change point detection algorithms that consists of 37 time series from various application domains. Each series was annotated by five human annotators to provide ground truth on the presence and location of change points. We analyze the consistency of the human annotators, and describe evaluation metrics that can be used to measure algorithm performance in the presence of multiple ground truth annotations. Next, we present a benchmark study where 14 algorithms are evaluated on each of the time series in the data set. Our aim is that this data set will serve as a proving ground in the development of novel change point detection algorithms.