On the Performance and Energy Efficiency of the PGAS Programming Model on Multicore Architectures

TL;DR

This study evaluates the performance and energy efficiency of the PGAS programming model, specifically UPC, on multicore architectures, comparing it with MPI and OpenMP across various hardware setups.

Contribution

It provides a comprehensive analysis of UPC's performance and energy efficiency on multicore systems, filling a gap in existing research.

Findings

UPC is competitive with MPI and OpenMP in performance.

UPC demonstrates comparable energy efficiency to MPI and OpenMP.

Performance and energy metrics vary across hardware configurations.

Abstract

Using large-scale multicore systems to get the maximum performance and energy efficiency with manageable programmability is a major challenge. The partitioned global address space (PGAS) programming model enhances programmability by providing a global address space over large-scale computing systems. However, so far the performance and energy efficiency of the PGAS model on multicore-based parallel architectures have not been investigated thoroughly. In this paper we use a set of selected kernels from the well-known NAS Parallel Benchmarks to evaluate the performance and energy efficiency of the UPC programming language, which is a widely used implementation of the PGAS model. In addition, the MPI and OpenMP versions of the same parallel kernels are used for comparison with their UPC counterparts. The investigated hardware platforms are based on multicore CPUs, both within a single 16-core node and across multiple nodes involving up to 1024 physical cores. On the multi-node platform we used the hardware measurement solution called High definition Energy Efficiency Monitoring tool in order to measure energy. On the single-node system we used the hybrid measurement solution to make an effort into understanding the observed performance differences, we use the Intel Performance Counter Monitor to quantify in detail the communication time, cache hit/miss ratio and memory usage. Our experiments show that UPC is competitive with OpenMP and MPI on single and multiple nodes, with respect to both the performance and energy efficiency.