Bayesian joint modeling of chemical structure and dose response curves

TL;DR

This paper introduces a Bayesian model that links chemical structure to toxicity responses, enabling improved toxicity prediction and chemical similarity assessment without extensive in vivo testing.

Contribution

The novel BS3FA model jointly learns chemical toxicity-related distances and predicts dose-response curves from structure alone, advancing in silico toxicity assessment methods.

Findings

Superior distance learning performance in simulations

Modest to large improvements in toxicity prediction accuracy

Insights into chemical structure-toxicity relationships

Abstract

Today there are approximately 85,000 chemicals regulated under the Toxic Substances Control Act, with around 2,000 new chemicals introduced each year. It is impossible to screen all of these chemicals for potential toxic effects either via full organism in vivo studies or in vitro high-throughput screening (HTS) programs. Toxicologists face the challenge of choosing which chemicals to screen, and predicting the toxicity of as-yet-unscreened chemicals. Our goal is to describe how variation in chemical structure relates to variation in toxicological response to enable in silico toxicity characterization designed to meet both of these challenges. With our Bayesian partially Supervised Sparse and Smooth Factor Analysis ($\text{BS}^3\text{FA}$) model, we learn a distance between chemicals targeted to toxicity, rather than one based on molecular structure alone. Our model also enables the prediction of chemical dose-response profiles based on chemical structure (that is, without in vivo or in vitro testing) by taking advantage of a large database of chemicals that have already been tested for toxicity in HTS programs. We show superior simulation performance in distance learning and modest to large gains in predictive ability compared to existing methods. Results from the high-throughput screening data application elucidate the relationship between chemical structure and a toxicity-relevant high-throughput assay. An R package for $\text{BS}^3\text{FA}$ is available online at https://github.com/kelrenmor/bs3fa.