Improved model-independent constraints on the recombination era and development of a direct projection method

TL;DR

This paper develops a model-independent approach to constrain the recombination era using Planck data, introducing optimized eigenmodes and a new projection method to improve the analysis of ionization history variations.

Contribution

It presents new optimized eigenmodes based on Planck 2015 data, a direct likelihood sampling method, and a novel projection technique for non-standard recombination parameters.

Findings

No significant deviations from standard recombination detected.

Third eigenmode constraint improved by 60%.

Recreated Planck constraint on two-photon decay rate within 0.05σ.

Abstract

The precision of recent experiments such as ${\it Planck}$ have allowed us to constrain standard and non-standard physics (e.g., due to dark matter annihilation or varying fundamental constants) during the recombination epoch. However, we can also probe this era of cosmic history using model-independent variations of the free electron fraction, $X_{\rm e}$, which in turn affects the temperature and polarization anisotropies of the cosmic microwave background. In this paper, we improve on the previous efforts to construct and constrain these generalised perturbations in the ionization history, deriving new optimized eigenmodes based on the full Planck 2015 likelihood data, introducing the new module 'FEARec++'. We develop a direct likelihood sampling method for attaining the numerical derivatives of the standard and non-standard parameters, and discuss complications arising from the stability of the likelihood code. We improve the amplitude constraints of the ${\it Planck}$ 2015 principal components constructed here, $\mu_1=-0.09\pm0.12$, $\mu_2=-0.17\pm0.20$ and $\mu_3=-0.30\pm0.35$, finding no indication for departures from the standard recombination scenario. The third mode error is reduced by $60\%$. We utilise an efficient eigen-analyser that keeps the cross-correlations of the first three eigenmodes to $\xi_{\mu,\mu'}<0.1\%$ after marginalisation for all the considered data combinations. We also propose a new projection method for estimating constraints on the parameters of non-standard recombination. Using our eigenmodes, this allows us to recreate the ${\it Planck}$ constraint on the two-photon decay rate, $A_{\rm 2s1s}=7.60\pm0.64$, giving an estimate to within $\simeq 0.05\sigma$ of the full MCMC result. The improvements on the analysis using the ${\it Planck}$ data will allow us to implement this new method for analysis with fundamental constant variations in the future.