The dynamical history of the evaporating or disrupted ice giant planet around white dwarf WD J0914+1914

TL;DR

This paper investigates the origin and current state of an ice giant planet around white dwarf WD J0914+1914, exploring its dynamical history, possible disruption, and orbital characteristics through tidal and scattering models.

Contribution

It presents new constraints on the planet's dynamical history, proposing scenarios of disruption, inward migration, or eccentric orbit, based on tidal and scattering analyses.

Findings

The planet likely scattered from several au to 0.07 au.

Chaotic f-mode tidal excitation is unlikely unless the planet is highly inflated.

Non-chaotic tides imply unrealistic tidal quality factors for a circular orbit.

Abstract

Robust evidence of an ice giant planet shedding its atmosphere around the white dwarf WD J0914+1914 represents a milestone in exoplanetary science, allowing us to finally supplement our knowledge of white dwarf metal pollution, debris discs and minor planets with the presence of a major planet. Here, we discuss the possible dynamical origins of this planet, WD J0914+1914 b. The very young cooling age of the host white dwarf (13 Myr) combined with the currently estimated planet-star separation of about 0.07 au imposes particularly intriguing and restrictive coupled constraints on its current orbit and its tidal dissipation characteristics. The planet must have been scattered from a distance of at least a few au to its current location, requiring the current or former presence of at least one more major planet in the system in the absence of a hidden binary companion. We show that WD J0914+1914 b could not have subsequently shrunk its orbit through chaotic f-mode tidal excitation (characteristic of such highly eccentric orbits) unless the planet was or is highly inflated and possibly had partially thermally self-disrupted from mode-based energy release. We also demonstrate that if the planet is currently assumed to reside on a near-circular orbit at 0.07 au, then non-chaotic equilibrium tides impose unrealistic values for the planet's tidal quality factor. We conclude that WD~J0914+1914~b either (i) actually resides interior to 0.07 au, (ii) resembles a disrupted "Super-Puff" whose remains reside on a circular orbit, or (iii) resembles a larger or denser ice giant on a currently eccentric orbit. Distinguishing these three possibilities strongly motivates follow-up observations.