Properties of LBGs with [OIII] detection at z $\sim$ 3.5: The importance of including nebular emission data in SED fitting

TL;DR

This study demonstrates that including nebular emission line data in SED fitting significantly improves the accuracy of physical property estimates for high-redshift LBGs, emphasizing the necessity of spectroscopic measurements.

Contribution

The paper provides evidence that nebular emission lines must be incorporated into SED fitting to accurately determine galaxy properties at z~3.5, highlighting the impact of emission lines on stellar mass estimates.

Findings

Neglecting nebular emission leads to overestimated stellar masses.

Emission line data are essential for constraining nebular models in SED fitting.

Spectroscopic measurements of emission lines improve the reliability of galaxy property estimates.

Abstract

Nebular emission lines are critical to measure physical properties in the ionized gas (e.g., metallicity, the SFR, or dust attenuation). They also account for a significant fraction of broadband fluxes, in particular at the highest redshifts, and therefore can strongly affect the determination of other physical properties, such as the stellar mass, which are crucial in shaping our understanding of galaxy formation and evolution. We investigate a sample of 51 LBGs at 3.0<z<3.8 with detected [OIII] line emissions and estimated the physical properties of these galaxies to examine the impact of including nebular emission data in the SED fitting. We used CIGALE to fit the rest-frame UV-to-NIR SEDs of these galaxies and their emission line data simultaneously. We ran CIGALE with and without the nebular model or the emission line data, and compare the results to show the importance of including the nebular emission line data in the SED fitting. We find that without the nebular model, the fitting overestimates the stellar mass due to the strong [OIII] lines that are redshifted to the Ks-band, consistent with previous results. The emission line data are necessary to constrain the nebular model in the SED fitting. Examining the Ks-band excess, which is mostly used to estimate the emissions of the [OIII]+Hb lines when there is no spectral data, we find that the estimation and observation are statistically consistent. However, the difference can reach up to more than 1 dex in some catastrophic cases, which shows the importance of obtaining spectroscopic measurements for these lines. We also estimate the equivalent width of the Hb absorption and find it negligible compared to the Hb emission. We conclude that line emission is important to constrain the nebular models and to obtain reliable estimates of the physical properties of galaxies. These data should be taken into account in the SED fitting.