Terrestrial modification of the Ivuna meteorite and a reassessment of the chemical composition of the CI type specimen

TL;DR

This study examines terrestrial modifications of the Ivuna meteorite, the most pristine CI chondrite, revealing how storage conditions affect its mineralogy and composition, and providing an updated average composition consistent with solar abundances.

Contribution

The paper provides a detailed comparison of two Ivuna meteorite samples, highlighting the impact of terrestrial weathering and proposing guidelines for preserving pristine samples.

Findings

BM2008 M1 is the most pristine Ivuna sample stored in nitrogen.

BM1996 M4 shows recent sulphate formation due to terrestrial weathering.

The new average composition aligns with previous CI chondrite data and solar abundances.

Abstract

The rare CI carbonaceous chondrites are the most aqueously altered and chemically primitive meteorites but due to their porous nature and high abundance of volatile elements are susceptible to terrestrial weathering. The Ivuna meteorite, type specimen for the CI chondrites, is the largest twentieth-century CI fall and least affected by terrestrial alteration. The main mass of Ivuna (BM2008 M1) has been stored in a nitrogen atmosphere at least since 2008 and is the most pristine CI chondrite stone. We report the mineralogy, petrography and bulk elemental composition of BM2008 M1 and a second Ivuna stone (BM1996 M4) stored in air. Both Ivuna stones are breccias consisting of multiple rounded, phyllosilicate-rich clasts formed through aqueous alteration followed by impact processing. A polished thin section of BM2008 M1 analysed immediately after preparation was found to contain sulphate-bearing veins formed when primary sulphides reacted with oxygen and atmospheric water. A section of BM1996 M4 lacked veins but had sulphate grains on the surface recently formed (last 6 years). Differences in the extent of terrestrial alteration recorded by BM2008 M1 and BM1996 M4 probably reflect variations in the post-recovery curation history of the stones before entering the NHM collection, and indicate that where possible pristine samples of hydrated carbonaceous should be kept out of the terrestrial environment in a stable environment to avoid modification. The bulk elemental composition of the two Ivuna stones show some variability due to their heterogeneous nature but in general are similar to previous analyses of CI chondrites. We combine our elemental abundances with literature values to calculate a new average composition for the Ivuna meteorite, which is in good agreement with existing compilations of CI chondrites and the most recent solar photospheric abundances.