An Empirical Exploration of Deep Recurrent Connections and Memory Cells Using Neuro-Evolution

TL;DR

This paper uses neuro-evolution to analyze and compare recurrent neural network structures, revealing that deep recurrent connections and simple neurons with time skip connections can outperform traditional memory cells in time series prediction.

Contribution

It introduces a novel neuro-evolutionary framework, EXAMM, for analyzing RNN components and demonstrates the effectiveness of deep recurrent connections over conventional memory cells.

Findings

Deep recurrent connections improve RNN performance.

Networks with only simple neurons and deep time skip connections can outperform complex memory cells.

Neuro-evolution aids in understanding and designing effective RNN architectures.

Abstract

Neuro-evolution and neural architecture search algorithms have gained increasing interest due to the challenges involved in designing optimal artificial neural networks (ANNs). While these algorithms have been shown to possess the potential to outperform the best human crafted architectures, a less common use of them is as a tool for analysis of ANN structural components and connectivity structures. In this work, we focus on this particular use-case to develop a rigorous examination and comparison framework for analyzing recurrent neural networks (RNNs) applied to time series prediction using the novel neuro-evolutionary process known as Evolutionary eXploration of Augmenting Memory Models (EXAMM). Specifically, we use our EXAMM-based analysis to investigate the capabilities of recurrent memory cells and the generalization ability afforded by various complex recurrent connectivity patterns that span one or more steps in time, i.e., deep recurrent connections. EXAMM, in this study, was used to train over 10.56 million RNNs in 5,280 repeated experiments with varying components. While many modern, often hand-crafted RNNs rely on complex memory cells (which have internal recurrent connections that only span a single time step) operating under the assumption that these sufficiently latch information and handle long term dependencies, our results show that networks evolved with deep recurrent connections perform significantly better than those without. More importantly, in some cases, the best performing RNNs consisted of only simple neurons and deep time skip connections, without any memory cells. These results strongly suggest that utilizing deep time skip connections in RNNs for time series data prediction not only deserves further, dedicated study, but also demonstrate the potential of neuro-evolution as a means to better study, understand, and train effective RNNs.