Should We Worry About Interference in Emerging Dense NGSO Satellite Constellations?

TL;DR

This paper evaluates the interference challenges in dense NGSO satellite constellations, revealing that current regulations and mitigation techniques may be insufficient, necessitating more advanced solutions for coexistence.

Contribution

The study provides a comprehensive analysis of inter-satellite interference in the Ku-band, highlighting limitations of existing mitigation and regulatory approaches for dense NGSO systems.

Findings

Existing spectrum regulation may be insufficient for GSO protection.

Traditional mitigation techniques like look-aside can be ineffective or harmful depending on constellation size.

Band-splitting significantly degrades throughput in Ku-band NGSO systems.

Abstract

Many satellite operators are planning to deploy NGSO systems for broadband communication services in the Ku-, Ka-, and V-band, where some of them have already launched. Consequently, new challenges are expected for inter-system satellite coexistence due to the increased interference level and the complexity of the interactions resulting from the heterogeneity of the constellations. This is especially relevant for the Ku-band, where the NGSO systems are most diverse and existing GSO systems, which often support critical services, must be protected from interference. It is thus imperative to evaluate the impact of mutual inter-system interference, the efficiency of the basic interference mitigation techniques, and whether regulatory intervention is needed for the new systems. We conduct an extensive study of inter-satellite coexistence in the Ku-band, where we consider all recently proposed NGSO and some selected GSO systems. Our throughput degradation results suggest that existing spectrum regulation may be insufficient to ensure GSO protection from NGSO interference, especially due to the high transmit power of the LEO Kepler satellites. This also results in strong interference towards other NGSO systems, where traditional interference mitigation techniques like look-aside may perform poorly. Specifically, look-aside can be beneficial for large constellations, but detrimental for small constellations. Furthermore, we confirm that band-splitting among satellite operators significantly degrades throughput, also for the Ku-band. Our results overall show that the complexity of the inter-satellite interactions for new NGSO systems is too high to be managed via simple interference mitigation techniques. This means that more sophisticated engineering solutions, and potentially even more strict regulatory requirements, will be needed to ensure coexistence in emerging, dense NGSO deployments.