Distance Restricted Manipulation in Voting

TL;DR

This paper introduces the concept of Distance Restricted Manipulation in voting, analyzing how colluders can influence election outcomes under uncertain knowledge, and provides complexity results for various voting rules.

Contribution

It defines new manipulation problems considering inaccuracy in votes and characterizes their computational complexity across multiple voting rules.

Findings

Polynomial algorithms for strong manipulation in several voting rules.

Intractability results for weak manipulation in most rules.

Efficient solutions for constant number of alternatives.

Abstract

We introduce the notion of {\em Distance Restricted Manipulation}, where colluding manipulator(s) need to compute if there exist votes which make their preferred alternative win the election when their knowledge about the others' votes is a little inaccurate. We use the Kendall-Tau distance to model the manipulators' confidence in the non-manipulators' votes. To this end, we study this problem in two settings - one where the manipulators need to compute a manipulating vote that succeeds irrespective of perturbations in others' votes ({\em Distance Restricted Strong Manipulation}), and the second where the manipulators need to compute a manipulating vote that succeeds for at least one possible vote profile of the others ({\em Distance Restricted Weak Manipulation}). We show that {\em Distance Restricted Strong Manipulation} admits polynomial-time algorithms for every scoring rule, maximin, Bucklin, and simplified Bucklin voting rules for a single manipulator, and for the $k$-approval rule for any number of manipulators, but becomes intractable for the Copeland$^\alpha$ voting rule for every $\alpha\in[0,1]$ even for a single manipulator. In contrast, {\em Distance Restricted Weak Manipulation} is intractable for almost all the common voting rules, with the exception of the plurality rule. For a constant number of alternatives, we show that both the problems are polynomial-time solvable for every anonymous and efficient voting rule.