Thermodynamic stability of droplets, bubbles and thick films in open and closed pores

TL;DR

This study investigates the thermodynamic stability of droplets, bubbles, and films of water in pores, revealing how pore size, shape, and boundary conditions influence stability and metastability through a combined capillary and equation of state approach.

Contribution

It introduces a new methodology for analyzing film stability and provides comprehensive phase diagrams for heterogeneous structures in different pore conditions.

Findings

Large pores' stability governed by mechanical stability.

Films in closed pores are often metastable.

Open pores favor homogeneous or droplet/bubble phases.

Abstract

A fluid in a pore can form diverse heterogeneous structures. We combine a capillary description with the cubic-plus-association equation of state to study the thermodynamic stability of droplets, bubbles and films of water at 358 K in a cylindrically symmetric pore. The equilibrium structure depends strongly on the size of the pore and whether the pore is closed or connected to a particle reservoir. A new methodology is presented to analyze the thermodynamic stability of films, where the integral that describes the total energy of the system is approximated by a quadrature rule. We show that, for large pores, the thermodynamic stability limit of adsorbed droplets and bubbles in both open and closed pores is governed by their mechanical stability, which is closely linked to the pore shape. This is also the case for a film in a closed pore. In open pores, the film is chemically unstable except for very low film-phase contact angles and for a limited range in external pressure. This result emphasizes the need to invoke a complete thermodynamic stability analysis, and not restrict the discussion to mechanical stability. A common feature for most of the heterogeneous structures examined is the appearance of regions where the structure is metastable with respect to a pore filled with a homogeneous fluid. In the closed pores, these regions grow considerably in size when the pores become smaller. [...] Complete phase diagrams are presented that compare all the investigated structures. In open pores at equilibrium, the most stable structure is either the homogeneous phase or adsorbed droplets and bubbles, depending on the type of phase in the external reservoir. Smaller pores allow for droplets and bubbles to adsorb for a larger span in pressure. In closed pores, most of the investigated configurations can occur depending on the total density, the contact angle and the pore shape. [...]