Renormalising vector currents in lattice QCD using momentum-subtraction schemes

TL;DR

This paper investigates the renormalisation of vector currents in lattice QCD using momentum-subtraction schemes, comparing different schemes to identify nonperturbative artefacts and proposing a safer method for accurate calculations.

Contribution

It provides a detailed comparison of renormalisation schemes for vector currents, highlighting the advantages of Ward-Takahashi identity-based schemes and proposing a robust RI'-MOM ratio method.

Findings

Ward-Takahashi identity schemes are free of nonperturbative condensate contamination.

Standard RI'-MOM scheme has ~1% nonperturbative contamination.

A ratio-based RI'-MOM scheme yields a safer $Z_V$ for lattice QCD.

Abstract

We examine the renormalisation of flavour-diagonal vector currents in lattice QCD with the aim of understanding and quantifying the systematic errors from nonperturbative artefacts associated with the use of intermediate momentum-subtraction schemes. Our study uses the Highly Improved Staggered Quark (HISQ) action on gluon field configurations that include $n_f=2+1+1$ flavours of sea quarks, but our results have applicability to other quark actions. Renormalisation schemes that make use of the exact lattice vector Ward-Takahashi identity for the conserved current also have renormalisation factors, $Z_V$, for nonconserved vector currents that are free of contamination by nonperturbative condensates. We show this by explicit comparison of two such schemes: that of the vector form factor at zero momentum transfer and the RI-SMOM momentum-subtraction scheme. The two determinations of $Z_V$ differ only by discretisation effects (for any value of momentum-transfer in the RI-SMOM case). The RI$^{\prime}$-MOM scheme, although widely used, does not share this property. We show that $Z_V$ determined in the standard way in this scheme has $\mathcal{O}(1\%)$ nonperturbative contamination that limits its accuracy. Instead we define an RI$^{\prime}$-MOM $Z_V$ from a ratio of local to conserved vector current vertex functions and show that this $Z_V$ is a safe one to use in lattice QCD calculations. We also perform a first study of vector current renormalisation with the inclusion of quenched QED effects on the lattice using the RI-SMOM scheme.