Critical gravity from four dimensional scale invariant gravity

TL;DR

This paper demonstrates the existence of a critical condition in four-dimensional scale-invariant gravity, where the massive ghost becomes a massless graviton, leading to zero energy and entropy for black holes, without adding Einstein gravity explicitly.

Contribution

It introduces a new critical gravity condition in four dimensions derived from pure quadratic actions, without explicitly including Einstein gravity, and shows its implications for black hole thermodynamics.

Findings

Critical condition: eta=6lpha in dS/AdS backgrounds

Massive ghost becomes a massless graviton at criticality

Black hole energy and entropy vanish at the critical point

Abstract

We show that a critical condition exists in four dimensional scale invariant gravity given by the pure quadratic action $\beta \,C_{\mu\nu\sigma\rho} C^{\mu\nu\sigma \rho} + \alpha \,R^2$ where $C^{\mu}_{\,\,\nu \sigma \rho}$ is the Weyl tensor, $R$ is the Ricci scalar and $\beta$ and $\alpha$ are dimensionless parameters. The critical condition in a dS or AdS background is $\beta =6 \alpha$. This leads to critical gravity where the massive spin two physical ghost becomes a massless spin two graviton. In contrast to the original work on critical gravity, no Einstein gravity with a cosmological constant is added explicitly to the higher-derivative action. The critical condition is obtained in two independent ways. In the first case, we show the equivalence between the initial action and an action containing Einstein gravity, a cosmological constant, a massless scalar field plus Weyl squared gravity. The scale invariance is spontaneously broken. The linearized Einstein-Weyl equations about a dS or AdS background yield the critical condition $\beta=6\alpha$. In the second case, we work directly with the original quadratic action. After a suitable field redefinition, where the metric perturbation is traceless and transverse, we obtain linearized equations about a dS or AdS background that yield the critical condition $\beta= 6\alpha$. As in the first case, we also obtain a propagating massless scalar field. Substituting $\beta=6\alpha$ into the energy and entropy formula for the Schwarzschild and Kerr AdS or dS black hole in higher-derivative gravity yields zero, the same value obtained in the original work on critical gravity. We discuss the role of boundary conditions in relaxing the $\beta=6\alpha$ condition.