# Competitive Search in a Network

## TL;DR

This paper investigates optimal search strategies in network search problems, comparing pathwise and expanding search paradigms, and provides new strategies with proven competitive ratios for both deterministic and randomized cases.

## Contribution

It introduces and analyzes new search strategies for both pathwise and expanding search, including a 5/4 approximation for expanding search and improved strategies for pathwise search.

## Key findings

- Expanding search with waterfilling strategy is optimally deterministic.
- Complex strategies are needed for optimal randomized expanding search.
- New strategies improve competitive ratios over previous methods.

## Abstract

We study the classic problem in which a Searcher must locate a hidden point, also called the Hider in a network, starting from a root point. The network may be either bounded or unbounded, thus generalizing well-known settings such as linear and star search. We distinguish between pathwise search, in which the Searcher follows a continuous unit-speed path until the Hider is reached, and expanding search, in which, at any point in time, the Searcher may restart from any previously reached point. The former has been the usual paradigm for studying search games, whereas the latter is a more recent paradigm that can model real-life settings such as hunting for a fugitive, demining a field, or search-and-rescue operations. We seek both deterministic and randomized search strategies that minimize the competitive ratio, namely the worst-case ratio of the Hider's discovery time, divided by the shortest path to it from the root. Concerning expanding search, we show that a simple search strategy that applies a "waterfilling" principle has optimal deterministic competitive ratio; in contrast, we show that the optimal randomized competitive ratio is attained by fairly complex strategies even in a very simple network of three arcs. Motivated by this observation, we present and analyze an expanding search strategy that is a 5/4 approximation of the randomized competitive ratio. Our approach is also applicable to pathwise search, for which we give a strategy that is a 5 approximation of the randomized competitive ratio, and which improves upon strategies derived from previous work.