An Approach for Reviewing Security-Related Aspects in Agile Requirements Specifications of Web Applications

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel NLP-based approach to assist reviewers in identifying security issues in agile web application requirements, improving effectiveness and efficiency.

Contribution

The approach links user stories to security properties and uses focused reading techniques to enhance security review in agile development.

Findings

Significant improvement in review effectiveness.

Enhanced efficiency in security inspections.

Positive impact demonstrated through controlled experiments.

Abstract

Defects in requirements specifications can have severe consequences during the software development lifecycle. Some of them result in overall project failure due to incorrect or missing quality characteristics such as security. There are several concerns that make security difficult to deal with; for instance, (1) when stakeholders discuss general requirements in (review) meetings, they are often not aware that they should also discuss security-related topics, and (2) they typically do not have enough security expertise. These concerns become even more challenging in agile development contexts, where lightweight documentation is typically involved. The goal of this paper is to design and evaluate an approach to support reviewing security-related aspects in agile requirements specifications of web applications. The designed approach considers user stories and security specifications as input and relates those user stories to security properties via Natural Language Processing (NLP) techniques. Based on the related security properties, our approach then identifies high-level security requirements from the Open Web Application Security Project (OWASP) to be verified and generates a focused reading techniques to support reviewers in detecting detects. We evaluate our approach via two controlled experiment trials, comparing the effectiveness and efficiency of novice inspectors verifying security aspects in agile requirements using our reading technique against using the complete list of OWASP high-level security requirements. The (statistically significant) results indicate that using the reading technique has a positive impact (with very large effect size) on the performance of inspectors in terms of effectiveness and efficiency.