Equivariant one-parameter formal deformations of Hom-Leibniz algebras
Goutam Mukherjee, Ripan Saha

TL;DR
This paper introduces a new cohomology theory for multiplicative Hom-Leibniz algebras that governs their deformations, extending the framework to include equivariant cases with finite group actions.
Contribution
It develops a novel cohomology and deformation theory for Hom-Leibniz algebras, including an extension to equivariant settings with group actions.
Findings
Defined a new cohomology controlling deformations.
Extended deformation theory to equivariant Hom-Leibniz algebras.
Established foundational results for equivariant deformation analysis.
Abstract
Aim of this paper is to define a new type of cohomology for multiplicative Hom-Leibniz algebras which controls deformations of Hom-Leibniz algebra structure. The cohomology and the associated deformation theory for Hom-Leibniz algebras as developed here are also extended to equvariant context, under the presence of finite group actions on Hom-Leibniz algebras.
Peer Reviews
No public reviews on file for this paper yet. If you reviewed it on a platform where reviews are public (OpenReview, ICLR, NeurIPS, ICML), you can paste yours below so the community can read it here.
Videos
No videos yet. Explain this paper in a talk, walkthrough, or lecture? Add one.
Equivariant one-parameter formal deformations of Hom-Leibniz algebras
Goutam Mukherjee
Stat-Math Unit, Indian Statistical Institute, Kolkata 700108, West Bengal, India.
and
Ripan Saha
Department of Mathematics, Raiganj University, Raiganj, 733134, West Bengal, India.
Abstract.
Aim of this paper is to define a new type of cohomology for multiplicative Hom-Leibniz algebras which controls deformations of Hom-Leibniz algebra structure. The cohomology and the associated deformation theory for Hom-Leibniz algebras as developed here are also extended to equvariant context, under the presence of finite group actions on Hom-Leibniz algebras.
Key words and phrases:
Group action, Hom-Leibniz algebra, equivariant cohomology, formal deformation, rigidity.
2010 Mathematics Subject Classification:
16E40, 17A30, 55N91.
1. Introduction
Gerstenhaber in a series of papers [6, 7, 8, 9, 10] introduced the notion of algebraic deformation theory for associative algebras. Later following Gerstenhaber, deformation theory of other algebraic structures are studied extensively in various context ( [24], [5], [11], [17], [25]). For example, A. Nijenhuis and R. Richardson studied formal one-parameter deformation theory of Lie algebras [24].
To study deformation theory of a type of algebra one needs a suitable cohomology, called deformation cohomology which controls deformations in question. In the case of associative algebras, deformation cohomology is Hochschild cohomology and for Lie algebras, the associated deformation cohomology is Chevalley-Eilenberg cohomology.
Hartwig, Larsson, and Silvestrov introduced the notion of Hom-Lie algebras in [12]. Hom-Lie algebras appeared as examples of -deformations of the Witt and Virasoro algebras. In [22], Makhlouf and Zusmanovich described Hom-Lie algebra structures on affine Kac-Moody algebras. The notion of a Hom-Lie algebra structure is a generalization of Lie algebra structure on a vector space. A Lie algebra equipped with self linear map, called the structure map, is said to be a Hom-Lie algebra if the Jacobi identity is replaced by Hom-Jacobi identity, which is Jacobi identity twisted by the structure map. Obviously, a Hom-Lie algebra is a Lie algebra when the associated structure map is identity.
In [15], J.-L. Loday introduced a version of non anti-symmetric Lie algebra and its (co)homology, known as Leibniz algebra. The bracket of a Leibniz algebra satisfies Leibniz identity instead of Jacobi identity. In the presence of skew-symmetry Leibniz identity reduces to Jacobi identity. Cohomology of any Leibniz algebra with coefficients in a bimodule was introduced in [16].
Makhlouf and Silvestrov introduced the notion of a Hom-Leibniz algebra in [19] generalizing Hom-Lie algebras. Thus, Hom-Leibniz algebras are generalizations of both Leibniz and Hom-Lie algebras. In Hom-Leibniz algebras, Leibniz identity is twisted by a self linear map and it is called Hom-Leibniz identity. Other variants of Hom-type algebras have been studied in [1], [18], [19], [20], [21], [26].
In [20], Makhlouf and Silvestrov introduced deformation cohomologies of first and second order to study one-parameter formal deformation theory for Hom-associative and Hom-Lie algebras. Hurle and Makhlouf introduced a new type of cohomology theory considering the structure map for Hom-associative and Hom-Lie algebras in [13], [14]. Cheng and Cai defined cohomology groups of all orders for Hom-Leibniz algebras in [4].
In the present paper, we define a cohomology theory for multiplicative Hom-Leibniz algebras generalizing [4]. We call this new cohomology as -type cohomology for Hom-Leibniz algebras. We also develop one-parameter formal deformation theory for Hom-Leibniz algebras using -type cohomology as the deformation cohomology.
Finally, we define a notion of finite group action on Hom-Leibniz algebras along the line of Bredon cohomology of a G-space, [3] and define equivariant version of -type cohomology. It turns out that for a Hom-Leibniz algebra equipped with an action of a finite group, its equivariant deformations are controlled by this -type cohomology. Note that an action of a finite group on a Hom-Leibniz algebra over a field naturally extends to the formal power series by bilinearly extending the multiplication of making a Hom- Leibniz algebra over
The paper is organized as follows. In Section 2, we recall basics of Hom-Leibniz algebras which we shall use throughout the paper. In Section 3, we show that there is a Gerstenhaber bracket on shifted cochains for Hom-Leibniz cohomology introduced in [4], and the bracket induces a graded Lie algebra structure on the graded cohomology. In Section 4, we introduce -type cohomology of multiplicative Hom-Leibniz algebras. In Section 5, we introduce one-parameter formal deformation theory of Hom-Leibniz algebras. We define infinitesimal deformation, study the the problem of extending a given deformation of order to a deformation of order and define the associated obstruction. We also study rigidity conditions for formal deformations. In Section 6, we define the notion of finite group actions on Hom-Leibniz algebras and introduce equivariant -type cohomology for Hom-Leibniz algebras equipped with a finite group action. In the final Section 7, we define equivariant formal deformations and prove that equivariant -type cohomology is the right notion of deformation cohomology in the present context. We end with a brief discussion of rigidity of equivariant deformations for Hom-Leibniz algebras equipped with finite group action.
2. Preliminaries
In this section, we recall the basics of Hom-Leibniz algebras. Let be a field of characteristic zero. Though most of the constructions should also work in other characteristics (not ) or if is a ring containing the rational numbers.
Definition 2.1**.**
A Hom-Leibniz algebra is a -linear vector space together with a -bilinear map and a -linear map (structure map) satisfying Hom-Leibniz identity:
A Hom-Leibniz algebra is called multiplicative if -linear map satisfies .
A morphism between Hom-Leibniz algebras and is a -linear map which satisfies and .
Example 2.2**.**
Any Hom-Lie algebra is automatically a Hom-Leibniz algebra as in the presence of skew-symmetry Hom-Leibniz identity is same as Hom-Jacobi identity.
Example 2.3**.**
Given a Leibniz algebra and a Leibniz algebra morphism , one always get a Hom-Leibniz algebra , where .
Example 2.4**.**
Let is a two-dimensional -vector space with basis . We define a bracket operation as and zero else where and the endomorphism is given by the matrix
[TABLE]
It is a routine work to check that is a Hom-Leibniz algebra which is not Hom-Lie.
Definition 2.5**.**
A Hom-vector space is a -vector space together with a -linear map such that vector space operations are compatible with . We write a Hom-vector space as .
Definition 2.6**.**
Let be a Hom-Leibniz algebra. A -bimodule is a Hom-vector space together with two -actions (left and right multiplications), and satisfying the following conditions,
[TABLE]
for any and .
Note that any Hom-Leibniz algebra can be considered as a bimodule over itself by taking and .
We recall the cohomology of Hom-Leibniz algebra defined in [4]. Let
[TABLE]
For , is defined as follows:
[TABLE]
For , and is a cochain complex. The cohomology of this cochain complex is discussed in [4].
3. Gerstenhaber bracket on cochains for Hom-Leibniz Cohomology
In [1], authors studied Gerstenhaber algebra structure on the shifted cochains for Hom-associative algebras. In this section, we define a Gerstenhaber bracket on shifted cochains for Hom-Leibniz algebra cohomology introduced by Cheng and Cai,[4] and show that this bracket induces a graded Lie algebra structure on cohomology of Hom-Leibniz algebra.
Definition 3.1**.**
Let be the permutation group of elements A permutation is called a -shuffle if and
[TABLE]
In the group algebra let be the element
[TABLE]
where the summation is over all
Suppose for , is the space of all -linear maps satisfying
[TABLE]
Let and , where , we define as follows,
[TABLE]
Suppose
[TABLE]
We define a bracket on as .
Remark 3.2**.**
For ,
[TABLE]
For , this is nothing but -associator of .
Proposition 3.3**.**
Suppose . Then is a Hom-Leibniz algebra if and only if
Proof.
[TABLE]
Thus, is a Hom-Leibniz algebra if and only if ∎
Lemma 3.4**.**
Let be a Hom-Leibniz algebra and , then , where is the Leibniz bracket of .
Proof.
Let . From the coboundary formula, we have
[TABLE]
Note that and .
[TABLE]
On the other hand, we have
[TABLE]
Therefore,
[TABLE]
Thus, we have ∎
The graded -module together with the bracket is a graded Lie algebra [2]. If , then we define . We define a linear map as follows:
[TABLE]
Using the graded Lie algebra structure on , we prove the following lemma.
Lemma 3.5**.**
The differential satisfies the the following graded derivation formula:
[TABLE]
for .
Proof.
Let and . To prove this Lemma, we use properties of graded Lie algebra.
[TABLE]
∎
From the Lemma (3.5), is a differential graded Lie algebra. The cohomology group of is denoted by . It is clear from the Lemma (3.5) that the Gerstenhaber bracket on graded cochains induces a bracket on the cohomology level and we have the following theorem.
Theorem 3.6**.**
* is a graded Lie algebra.*
4. -type Leibniz cohomology of Hom-Leibniz algebras
For the deformation theory we need a new type of cohomology that can capture information of deformation for both multiplication and structure map of a Hom-Leibniz algebra. We begin this section by introducing a cohomology theory for Hom-Leibniz algebras considering both the bracket and the structure map . We call this cohomology for Hom-Leibniz algebras by -type cohomology of Hom-Leibniz algebras. We will see that this cohomology is a generalization of the cohomology defined in the last section.
Let and we define the cochain complex for the cohomology of with coefficients in as follows:
[TABLE]
[TABLE]
[TABLE]
We may write elements of as or , where and . Note that we set instead of as usual, otherwise would be needed in the definition of the differential. We define four maps with domain and range given in the following diagram:
[TABLE]
[TABLE]
[TABLE]
[TABLE]
[TABLE]
We set
[TABLE]
Theorem 4.1**.**
* together with the map is a cochain complex.*
Proof.
We need to show that . This is same as the following equations:
[TABLE]
For this we verify the following equations
[TABLE]
We only verify above equations for . The proof of the general case is lengthy and can be obtained following [13], we omit the detail computation. Observe that
[TABLE]
Note that in the above computation the third equality is obtained by using the Hom-Leibniz identity and cancellation of terms. On the other hand, we have
[TABLE]
Thus, .
[TABLE]
On the other hand, we have
[TABLE]
Thus, . As , we have
[TABLE]
Therefore, for we proved . ∎
We denote the cohomology of the cochain complex \big{(}\widetilde{CL}^{\ast}(L,L),\partial\big{)} by and call it -type Hom-Leibniz cohomology of with coefficients in itself.
Remark 4.2**.**
Note that -type cohomology for multiplicative Hom-Leibniz algebras generalizes the cohomology introduced in [4]. To show this we consider only those elements in where second summand is zero, that is, Thus, we have elements of the form . We define a subcomplex of as follows:
[TABLE]
The map defines a diffential on this complex and this complex is same as the complex defined in [4]. Thus, -type cohomology generalizes the cohomology developed in [4].
5. Deformation theory of Hom-Leibniz algebra structure
In this section, we introduce one-parameter formal deformation theory for multiplicative Hom-Leibniz algebras and discuss how -type cohomology controls deformations. We only consider multiplicative Hom-Leibniz algebras.
Definition 5.1**.**
A one-parameter formal deformation of multiplicative Hom-Leibniz algebra is given by a -bilinear map and a -linear map of the forms
[TABLE]
such that,
- (1)
For all , is a -bilinear map, and is a -linear map. 2. (2)
is the bracket and is the structure map of . 3. (3)
satisfies the Hom-Leibniz identity, that is,
4. (4)
The map is multiplicative, that is, .
Condition (3) in the last definition is equivalent to
[TABLE]
Condition (4) in the last definition is equivalent to
[TABLE]
For a Hom-Leibniz algebra , a -associator is a map,
[TABLE]
defined as
. By using -associator, the deformation equation may be written as
[TABLE]
Thus, for , we have the following infinite equations:
[TABLE]
We can rewrite the Equation (9) as follows:
[TABLE]
where
[TABLE]
and
[TABLE]
From the multiplicativity of , we have
[TABLE]
We can rewrite the Equation (13) as follows:
[TABLE]
where
[TABLE]
For ,
[TABLE]
This is the original Hom-Leibniz relation and from the Equation (13) we have
[TABLE]
This just shows is multiplicative.
For , from the Equation (9) we have
[TABLE]
.
This is same as
[TABLE]
Now from the multiplicative part of the deformation, we have
[TABLE]
This is same as
[TABLE]
Thus, we have
[TABLE]
Definition 5.2**.**
The infinitesimal of the deformation is the pair . Suppose more generally that is the first non-zero term of after , such is called a -infinitesimal of the deformation.
Therefore, we have the following theorem.
Theorem 5.3**.**
Let be a Hom-Leibniz algebra, and be its one-parameter deformation then the infinitesimal of the deformation is a -cocycle of the -type Hom-Leibniz cohomology.
5.1. Obstructions of deformations
Now we discuss obstructions of deformations for multiplicative Hom-Leibniz algebras from the cohomological point of view.
Definition 5.4**.**
A -deformation of a Hom-Leibniz algebra is a formal deformation of the forms
[TABLE]
such that and satisfies the Hom-Leibniz identity,
[TABLE]
and is multiplicative,
[TABLE]
We say a -deformation of a Hom-Leibniz algebra is extendable to a -deformation if there is an element and such that
[TABLE]
and satisfies all the conditions of one-parameter formal deformations.
The -deformation gives us the following equations.
[TABLE]
[TABLE]
This is same as the following equations
[TABLE]
[TABLE]
We define the th obstruction to extend a deformation of Hom-Leibniz algebra of order to order as , where
[TABLE]
Thus, and .
Theorem 5.5**.**
A deformation of order extends to a deformation of order if and only if cohomology class of vanishes.
Proof.
Suppose a deformation of order extends to a deformation of order . From the obstruction equations, we have
[TABLE]
As , we get the cohomology class of vanishes.
Conversely, suppose the cohomology class of vanishes, that is,
[TABLE]
for some -cochains . We define extending the deformation of order as follows-
[TABLE]
The map satisfy the following equations for all .
[TABLE]
Thus, is a deformation of order which extends the deformation of order . ∎
Corollary 5.6**.**
If then any -cocycle gives a one-parameter formal deformation of .
5.2. Equivalent and trivial deformations
Suppose and be two one-parameter Hom-Leibniz algebra deformations of , where and .
Definition 5.7**.**
Two deformations and are said to be equivalent if there exists a -linear isomorphism of the form , where and are -linear maps such that the following relations holds:
[TABLE]
Definition 5.8**.**
A deformation of a Hom-Leibniz algebra is called trivial if is equivalent to . A Hom-Leibniz algebra is called rigid if it has only trivial deformation upto equivalence.
Condition (21) may be written as
[TABLE]
The above conditions is equivalent to the following equations:
[TABLE]
This is same as the following equations:
[TABLE]
Comparing constant terms on both sides of the above equations, we have
[TABLE]
Now comparing coefficients of , we have
[TABLE]
The Equations (26) and (27) are same as
[TABLE]
Thus, we have the following proposition.
Proposition 5.9**.**
Two equivalent deformations have cohomologous infinitesimals.
Proof.
Suppose and be two equivalent one-parameter Hom-Leibniz deformations of . Suppose and be two -infinitesimals of the deformations and respectively. Using Equation (24) we get,
[TABLE]
Using equation (25) we get,
[TABLE]
Thus, infinitesimals of two deformations determines same cohomology class. ∎
Theorem 5.10**.**
A non-trivial deformation of a Hom-Leibniz algebra is equivalent to a deformation whose infinitesimal is not a coboundary.
Proof.
Let be a deformation of Hom-Leibniz algebra and be the -infinitesimal of the deformation for some . Then by Theorem (5.3), is a -cocycle, that is, . Suppose and for some , that is, is a coboundary. We define a formal isomorphism of as follows:
[TABLE]
We set
[TABLE]
Thus, we have a new deformation which is isomorphic to . By expanding the above equations and comparing coefficients of , we get
[TABLE]
Hence, . By repeating this argument, we can kill off any infinitesimal which is a coboundary. Thus, the process must be stopped if the deformation is non-trivial. ∎
Corollary 5.11**.**
Let be a Hom-Leibniz algebra. If then is rigid.
6. Group action and equivariant cohomology
The notion of a finite group action on a Leibniz algebra was introduced by authors in [23]. In this section, we introduce a notion of a finite group action on Hom-Leibniz algebra. We also define an equivariant cohomology of Hom-Leibniz algebra equipped with action of a finite group.
Definition 6.1**.**
Let be a finite group and be a Hom-Leibniz algebra. We say group acts on the Hom-Leibniz algebra from the left if there is a funtion
[TABLE]
satisfying
- (1)
For each , the map is a -linear map. 2. (2)
, where denotes identity element of the group . 3. (3)
For all and , . 4. (4)
For all and , and
We may write a Hom-Leibniz algebra equipped with a finite group action as . An alternative way to present the above definition is the following:
Proposition 6.2**.**
Let be a finite group and be a Hom-Leibniz algebra. The group acts on from the left if and only if there is a group homomorphism
[TABLE]
where denotes group of ismorphisms of Hom-Leibniz algebras from to .
Let be Hom-Leibniz algebras equipped with actions of group . We say a -linear map is equivariant if for all and , . We write the set of all equivariant maps from to as .
A -Hom-vector space is a Hom-vector space together with a action of on , and is an equivariant map. We denote an equivariant Hom-vector space as triple .
Example 6.3**.**
Any -Hom-vector space together with the trivial bracket (i.e. for all ) is a Hom-Leibniz algebra equipped with an action of .
Example 6.4**.**
Let be -module which is a representation space of a finite group On
[TABLE]
there is a unique bracket that makes it into a Hom-Leibniz algebra by taking and verifies
[TABLE]
This is the free Hom-Leibniz algebra over the -module . The linear action of on extends naturally to an action on .
Definition 6.5**.**
Let be a Hom-Leibniz algebra equipped with an action of a finite group . A -bimodule over is a -Hom-vector space together with two -actions (left and right multiplications), and such that satisfying the following conditions:
[TABLE]
for any , and .
Remark 6.6**.**
Any Hom-Leibniz algebra equipped with an action of a finite group is a G-bimodule over itself. In this paper, we shall only consider G-bimodule over itself.
We now introduce an equivariant cohomology of Hom-Leibniz algebras equipped with an action of a finite group .
Set
[TABLE]
Here is -cochain group of the Hom-Leibniz algebra and consists of all -cochains which are equivariant. Clearly, is a submodule of and is called an invariant -cochain.
Lemma 6.7**.**
If a -cochain is invariant then is also an invariant -cochain. In otherwords,
[TABLE]
Proof.
As , we have
[TABLE]
for all and . It is enough to show that the four differentials respect the group action. Observe that
[TABLE]
On the other hand, we have
[TABLE]
Similarly, it is easy to show that
[TABLE]
Thus, . ∎
The cochain complex is called an equivariant cochain complex of . We define th equivariant cohomology group of with coefficients over itself by
[TABLE]
7. Equivariant formal deformation of Hom-Leibniz algebra structure
In this section, we introduce an equivariant one-parameter formal deformation theory including the deformation of the structure map of Hom-Leibniz algebra equipped with action of a finite group . We show that equivariant cohomology controls such equivariant deformations.
Definition 7.1**.**
An equivariant one-parameter formal deformation of is given by -bilinear and a -linear map and respectively of the forms
[TABLE]
where each is a -bilinear map and each is a -linear map satisfying the followings:
- (1)
is the original Hom-Leibniz bracket on and . 2. (2)
and satisfies the following Hom-Leibniz algebra condition:
[TABLE] 3. (3)
The map is multiplicative, that is, . 4. (4)
For all , and ,
[TABLE]
that is, and
For all , the Condition (2) in the above Definition is equivalent to
[TABLE]
For all , the Condition (3) in the above Definition is equivalent to
[TABLE]
Definition 7.2**.**
An equivariant -cochain is called an equivariant infinitesimal of the equivariant deformation . Suppose more generally that is the first non-zero term of after , such is called an equivariant -infinitesimal of the equivariant deformation.
Proposition 7.3**.**
Let be a finite group and be a Hom-Leibniz algebra. Suppose is its equivariant one-parameter deformation then the equivariant infinitesimal of an equivariant deformation is a -cocycle of the equivariant Hom-Leibniz cohomology.
Proof.
Let be an equivariant -infinitesimal of an equivariant deformation . Thus, for all and . From the Equation (28), we have
[TABLE]
From the Equation (29), we have
[TABLE]
This is same as . Thus, the desired result follows. ∎
An equivariant -deformation of a Hom-Leibniz algebra equipped with a finite group action is a formal deformation of the forms
[TABLE]
such that
- (1)
For each , and , that is, each and are equivariant -linear maps. 2. (2)
satisfies the Hom-Leibniz identity, that is,
3. (3)
The map is multiplicative, that is, .
We say an equivariant -deformation of a Hom-Leibniz algebra is extendable to an equivariant -deformation if there is an element such that
[TABLE]
and satisfies all the conditions of formal deformations.
For , we can rewrite the Equation (28) in the following form using Hom-Leibniz cohomology
[TABLE]
[TABLE]
This is same as the following equations
[TABLE]
[TABLE]
We define th obstruction to extend a deformation of Hom-Leibniz algebra of order to order as , where
[TABLE]
Lemma 7.4**.**
Suppose is an equivariant -deformations, then is a cocycle for all .
Proof.
As for all , and . So for all , and . Now,
[TABLE]
[TABLE]
Thus, As , we have is an equivariant cocycle. ∎
We can prove the following theorem along the same line as of non-equivariant case.
Theorem 7.5**.**
An equivariant -deformation extends to an equivariant -deformation if and only if cohomology class of vanishes.
Corollary 7.6**.**
If then any equivariant -cocycle gives an equivariant one-parameter formal deformation of .
Finally, we study rigidity conditions for equivariant deformations. Observe that an action of a finite group on Hom-Leibniz algebra induces an action on by bilinearity.
Definition 7.7**.**
Given two equivariant deformations and of , where and . We say and are equivalent if there is a formal isomorphism of the following form:
[TABLE]
Such that
- (1)
and for , are equivariant -linear maps. 2. (2)
Remark 7.8**.**
Suppose and are equivalent deformation. For every subgroup , -fixed point set is a Hom-Leibniz sub algebra. A formal equivariant isomorphism induces formal isomophism for all subgroups of .
From the second condition of the Definition (7.6) we have the following equations:
[TABLE]
Comparing coefficients of infinitesimals on both sides of the above equations, we have the following proposition.
Proposition 7.9**.**
Equivariant infinitesimals of two equivalent equivariant deformations determine the same cohomology class.
Similar to the non-equivariant case, we have the following rigidity theorem for equivariant deformations.
Theorem 7.10**.**
Let be a Hom-Leibniz algebra equipped with an action of finite group . If then is equivariantly rigid.
The reference list from the paper itself. Each links out to its DOI / PubMed record.
- 1[1] Faouzi Ammar, Zeyneb Ejbehi and Abdenacer Makhlouf, Cohomology and deformations of Hom-algebras. J. Lie Theory 21 (2011), no. 4, 813-836.
- 2[2] D. Balavoine, Deformations of algebras over a quadratic operad, Operads: Proceedings of Renaissance Conferences (Hartford, CT/Luminy, 1995) (Providence, RI), Contemp. Math. , vol. 202, Amer. Math. Soc., 1997, pp. 207-234.
- 3[3] G. E. Bredon, Equivariant cohomology theories, Lecture Notes in Math. , No. 34, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1967.
- 4[4] Yong Sheng Cheng ; Su, Yu Cai. (Co)homology and universal central extension of Hom-Leibniz algebras, Acta Math. Sin. (Engl. Ser.) 27 (2011), no. 5, 813-830.
- 5[5] T.F. Fox, An introduction to algebraic deformation theory, J. of Pure and Appl. Algebra , 84 (1) (1993), 17-41.
- 6[6] M. Gerstenhaber. The cohomology structure of an associative ring. Ann. of Math. (2) , 78 :267-288, 1963.
- 7[7] M. Gerstenhaber. On the deformation of rings and algebras. Ann. of Math. (2) , 79 :59-103, 1964.
- 8[8] M. Gerstenhaber. On the deformation of rings and algebras. II. Ann. of Math. , 84 :1-19, 1966.
