# Meta-analysis of Electron Cyclotron Resonance Absorption Features Detected in High-Mass X-ray Binaries

## TL;DR

This meta-analysis consolidates recent X-ray observations of high-mass X-ray binaries, revealing discrete magnetic field strengths in neutron stars and highlighting the need for further explanation of this phenomenon.

## Contribution

It provides a comprehensive catalog of electron cyclotron resonance absorption features in HMXBs and identifies distinct magnetic field groupings in neutron stars.

## Key findings

- Neutron star magnetic fields cluster around five distinct values.
- No correlation between magnetic fields and other neutron star or binary parameters.
- Confirmed the fundamental cyclotron levels in multiple sources.

## Abstract

Using recent compilations of detailed X-ray observations and spectral models of exceptional quality, we record the electron cyclotron resonance absorption (ECRA) features that have been detected in 45 pulsating high-mass X-ray binaries (HMXBs) and ultraluminous X-ray (ULX) sources harboring neutron stars, although seven of these detections are still questionable and another 21 are single and/or not independently confirmed. From the comprehensive catalogs of Jaisawal \& Naik and Staubert et al. and from several additional recent observations, we produce two lists of HMXB ECRA sources: a list of 17 sources in which multiple ECRA lines or single very low-energy lines are seen, in which we can reasonably assume that the lowest energy reveals the fundamental cyclotron level for each source; and a `contaminated' list of 38 sources including the 21 detections of single ECRA lines that may (not) be higher-level harmonics. Both lists confirm a previous result that we have obtained independently by modeling the propeller lines of Magellanic HMXB pulsars: the surface dipolar magnetic fields $B_*$ of HMXB neutron stars are segregated around five distinct values with $B_* = 0.28\pm 0.08, 0.55\pm 0.11, 1.3\pm 0.37, 3.0\pm 0.68$, and $7.9\pm 3.1$, in units of TG. An explanation of this phenomenon is currently lacking. We have found no correlation between these $B_*$ values and the corresponding observed spin periods, spin period derivatives, orbital periods, maximum X-ray luminosities, neutron star masses, or companion star masses.