Molecular environs and triggered star formation around the large Galactic infrared bubble N 24
Xu Li, Jarken Esimbek, Jianjun Zhou, W. A. Baan, Weiguang Ji, Xindi, Tang, Gang Wu, Xiaoke Tang, Qiang Li, Yingxiu Ma, Serikbek Sailanbek, Dalei, Li, and Dina Alimbetova

TL;DR
This study investigates the molecular environment and star formation processes around the Galactic infrared bubble N 24, revealing ongoing massive star formation likely driven by collect and collapse and radiation-driven implosion mechanisms.
Contribution
It provides a detailed multi-wavelength analysis of N 24, identifying dense clumps and analyzing their properties to understand star formation triggers around the bubble.
Findings
Detection of 23 dense clumps with masses up to 16,300 Msun
Evidence of gravitational collapse in several clumps
Indications of both collect and collapse and radiation-driven implosion mechanisms
Abstract
A multi-wavelength analysis of the large Galactic infrared bubble N 24 is has been presented in this paper in order to investigate the molecular and star formation environment around expanding HII regions. Using archival data from Herschel and ATLASGAL, the distribution and physical properties of the dust over the entire bubble are studied. Twenty three dense clumps are identified using the Clumpfind2d algorithm with sizes and masses in the range 0.65-1.73 pc and 600-16300 Msun, respectively. To analyse the molecular environment in N 24, observations of NH3 (1,1) and (2,2) were carried out using the Nanshan 26m radio telescope. Analysis of the kinetic temperature and gravitational stability of these clumps suggests gravitational collapse in several of them. The mass-size distributions of the clumps and the presence of massive young protostars indicate that the shell of N 24 is a region…
| Number | Clump name | R.A. | Decl. | Stage | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| J2000 (deg) | J2000 (deg) | (pc) | (K) | (1022cm-2) | 103M⊙ | 103cm-3 | |||
| 1 | G 19.058-00.209 | 276.62293 | -12.419557 | 0.810.04 | 23.12.6 | 0.700.11 | 1.350.23 | 8.782.80 | Proto-stellar |
| 2 | G 19.072-00.202 | 276.62327 | -12.403908 | 0.720.03 | 22.52.5 | 0.440.07 | 0.760.12 | 7.001.99 | Pre-stellar |
| 3 | G 19.079-00.221 | 276.64382 | -12.406570 | 0.770.03 | 24.23.0 | 0.290.05 | 0.680.12 | 5.161.51 | Pre-stellar |
| 4 | G 19.067-00.237 | 276.65235 | -12.425086 | 0.750.03 | 21.72.4 | 0.280.04 | 0.680.11 | 5.551.47 | Pre-stellar |
| 5 | G 19.076-00.249 | 276.66776 | -12.422273 | 0.850.04 | 21.82.4 | 0.500.08 | 1.200.19 | 6.762.02 | Pre-stellar |
| 6 | G 19.067-00.266 | 276.67887 | -12.438157 | 0.800.04 | 24.03.0 | 0.370.06 | 0.870.16 | 5.871.96 | H ii |
| 7 | G 19.079-00.289 | 276.70543 | -12.438254 | 1.640.07 | 23.12.9 | 2.480.48 | 9.491.84 | 7.442.39 | H ii |
| 8 | G 19.057-00.300 | 276.70490 | -12.462845 | 0.840.04 | 22.52.5 | 0.480.07 | 1.220.20 | 7.122.19 | Pre-stellar |
| 9 | G 18.888-00.476 | 276.78006 | -12.695805 | 1.410.06 | 17.01.6 | 4.010.67 | 10.871.37 | 13.443.41 | Proto-stellar |
| 10 | G 18.900-00.498 | 276.80953 | -12.693981 | 1.070.05 | 20.42.0 | 0.630.09 | 2.320.31 | 6.551.80 | H ii |
| 11 | G 18.897-00.508 | 276.81717 | -12.701291 | 0.730.03 | 21.22.2 | 0.670.10 | 1.140.17 | 10.132.76 | H ii |
| 12 | G 18.863-00.480 | 276.77555 | -12.718347 | 0.990.04 | 22.72.5 | 0.880.14 | 2.730.47 | 9.732.86 | Proto-stellar |
| 13 | G 18.880-00.509 | 276.80997 | -12.716802 | 0.930.04 | 21.62.3 | 0.790.12 | 2.090.31 | 8.982.49 | H ii |
| 14 | G 18.875-00.521 | 276.81847 | -12.726813 | 0.690.03 | 19.51.8 | 0.640.09 | 1.110.15 | 11.683.10 | Pre-stellar |
| 15 | G 18.849-00.474 | 276.76342 | -12.727943 | 0.980.04 | 20.22.0 | 0.370.05 | 1.400.20 | 5.141.36 | Pre-stellar |
| 16 | G 18.824-00.486 | 276.76237 | -12.755654 | 1.730.08 | 16.31.2 | 2.960.35 | 16.301.67 | 10.882.62 | Proto-stellar |
| 17 | G 18.836-00.508 | 276.78391 | -12.756535 | 0.720.03 | 18.71.6 | 0.490.03 | 0.870.11 | 8.072.03 | Pre-stellar |
| 18 | G 18.852-00.515 | 276.80205 | -12.744376 | 0.650.03 | 19.91.9 | 0.440.06 | 0.700.10 | 8.792.48 | Pre-stellar |
| 19 | G 18.842-00.515 | 276.79728 | -12.753226 | 0.670.03 | 19.31.8 | 0.490.07 | 0.720.10 | 8.262.26 | Pre-stellar |
| 20 | G 18.856-00.531 | 276.81848 | -12.748283 | 1.030.05 | 17.71.5 | 0.700.09 | 1.950.25 | 6.171.69 | Pre-stellar |
| 21 | G 18.788-00.499 | 276.75698 | -12.793565 | 0.940.04 | 17.61.5 | 0.470.06 | 1.310.16 | 5.451.37 | Pre-stellar |
| 22 | G 18.776-00.460 | 276.71586 | -12.786022 | 0.680.03 | 21.02.2 | 0.350.05 | 0.600.09 | 6.571.86 | Pre-stellar |
| 23 | G 18.763-00.467 | 276.71601 | -12.800786 | 0.840.04 | 21.62.3 | 0.240.04 | 0.820.13 | 4.791.44 | Pre-stellar |
| Number | Central velocity | Velocity width | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| (km s-1) | (km s | (K) | (K) | (103M⊙) | |||
| 1 | 62.90.1 | 2.50.3 | 1.200.56 | 18.41.3 | 22.12.4 | 0.840.24 | 1.610.54 |
| 2 | 62.90.2 | 2.70.3 | 1.020.65 | 22.61.7 | 29.53.7 | 0.880.23 | 0.860.26 |
| 3 | 65.30.2 | 3.40.4 | 0.790.55 | 20.41.4 | 25.52.8 | 1.520.41 | 0.450.15 |
| 4 | 65.40.2 | 2.70.4 | 1.560.64 | 18.81.5 | 22.82.8 | 0.930.31 | 0.730.27 |
| 5 | 65.50.2 | 2.80.4 | 1.510.63 | 21.21.6 | 26.93.3 | 1.110.36 | 1.080.39 |
| 6 | 65.40.1 | 2.60.2 | 1.290.37 | 21.01.0 | 26.52.0 | 0.920.19 | 0.950.26 |
| 7 | 65.60.1 | 2.80.2 | 1.850.19 | 17.20.4 | 20.20.7 | 2.170.39 | 4.371.16 |
| 8 | 64.80.1 | 3.10.2 | 0.870.35 | 18.10.8 | 21.61.5 | 1.340.23 | 0.910.22 |
| 9 | 65.90.1 | 2.60.1 | 1.820.16 | 20.40.4 | 25.30.8 | 1.610.19 | 6.751.17 |
| 10 | 66.30.1 | 2.40.2 | 0.700.31 | 21.10.8 | 26.61.6 | 1.090.22 | 2.130.52 |
| 11 | 66.40.1 | 2.60.2 | 1.170.38 | 20.81.0 | 26.12.0 | 0.850.16 | 1.340.32 |
| 12 | 65.50.1 | 2.50.1 | 1.350.23 | 18.90.5 | 22.80.9 | 1.070.12 | 2.550.52 |
| 13 | 66.20.1 | 2.40.1 | 1.070.22 | 17.90.5 | 21.30.9 | 0.940.11 | 2.220.42 |
| 14 | 65.80.1 | 2.60.2 | 0.180.37 | 19.81.0 | 24.41.9 | 0.770.15 | 1.440.34 |
| 15 | 65.30.1 | 2.30.2 | 1.530.27 | 16.90.6 | 19.61.1 | 0.910.19 | 1.540.39 |
| 16 | 65.10.1 | 2.60.1 | 2.040.11 | 17.30.2 | 20.30.4 | 2.020.24 | 8.071.27 |
| 17 | 65.50.1 | 2.40.1 | 1.490.21 | 16.60.4 | 19.30.7 | 0.710.09 | 1.230.22 |
| 18 | 65.50.1 | 3.90.4 | 0.600.27 | 18.20.7 | 21.81.3 | 1.620.40 | 0.430.12 |
| 19 | 65.60.1 | 3.70.5 | 0.520.26 | 20.20.7 | 25.11.4 | 1.510.47 | 0.480.16 |
| 20 | 65.30.2 | 4.90.3 | 0.720.39 | 17.10.9 | 20.11.6 | 4.110.70 | 0.470.10 |
| 21 | 65.20.1 | 2.80.2 | 1.280.26 | 16.40.5 | 19.00.9 | 1.270.23 | 1.030.22 |
| 22 | 66.30.3 | 3.30.5 | 1.420.65 | 20.21.6 | 25.13.2 | 1.260.43 | 0.480.18 |
| 23 | 66.40.3 | 3.70.6 | 1.070.87 | 22.62.2 | 29.44.8 | 1.900.70 | 0.430.17 |
| Number | Clump name | Central velocity | Velocity width | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| (pc) | (K) | (1022cm-2) | 103M⊙ | (km s-1) | (km s | (K) | |||
| A | G 18.974-00.272 | 0.650.03 | 18.41.6 | 0.370.03 | 0.580.08 | 66.00.2 | 3.00.5 | 0.550.62 | |
| B | G 18.945-00.320 | 0.910.04 | 19.91.9 | 0.300.04 | 0.960.14 | ||||
| C | G 18.904-00.275 | 0.690.03 | 18.81.7 | 0.460.05 | 0.770.11 | 64.50.1 | 2.70.2 | 0.960.28 | 19.11.0 |
| D | G 18.836-00.294 | 0.990.04 | 17.01.4 | 0.990.05 | 1.960.21 | 64.00.1 | 2.10.3 | 0.980.44 | 15.91.3 |
| E | G 18.805-00.298 | 1.390.06 | 15.91.2 | 1.110.10 | 5.210.60 | 65.40.1 | 2.30.1 | 3.210.21 | 14.50.3 |
| F | G 18.849-00.377 | 1.270.06 | 17.11.5 | 0.560.08 | 3.350.43 | 62.30.2 | 3.10.4 | ||
| G | G 18.862-00.419 | 0.940.04 | 19.31.8 | 0.460.06 | 1.290.18 | 65.50.3 | 3.20.3 | 2.410.83 | 29.24.5 |
| ID | SSTGLMC | Age | Stage | Association | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| [mag] | [yr] | [M⊙] | [M⊙] | [M⊙] | [M⊙yr-1] | ||||
| Y1 | G019.0549-00.2117 | 19.14 | 6.10104 | 9.57 | 5.0210-3 | 1.52103 | 2.8610-3 | I | Cl.1 |
| Y2 | G019.0839-00.2768 | 25.45 | 1.38104 | 14.61 | 8.9210-3 | 4.56102 | 3.3010-3 | I | Cl.7 |
| Y3 | G019.0762-00.2873 | 3.90 | 3.62103 | 19.75 | 0.00 | 4.10s102 | 7.7210-3 | I | Cl.7 |
| Y4 | G018.8884-00.4741 | 33.98 | 3.43104 | 12.51 | 1.0610-1 | 2.90s103 | 4.6010-3 | I | Cl.9 |
| Y5 | G018.8921-00.5108 | 24.69 | 3.46104 | 8.29 | 8.2210-3 | 1.44103 | 3.1510-3 | I | Cl.11 |
| Y6 | G018.8847-00.5095 | 8.60 | 2.93104 | 10.05 | 8.1310-3 | 1.58103 | 2.1410-3 | I | Cl.13 |
| Y7 | G018.8635-00.4805 | 0.77 | 9.13103 | 11.11 | 2.7310-2 | 1.03s102 | 1.6010-3 | I | Cl.12 |
| Y8 | G018.8537-00.4834 | 1.96 | 3.52105 | 6.97 | 1.8110-2 | 2.76101 | 7.5910-6 | II | Cl.12 |
| Y9 | G018.8331-00.4776 | 15.30 | 1.41103 | 13.69 | 0.00 | 1.40103 | 6.6710-3 | I | Cl.16 |
| Y10 | G018.8251-00.4669 | 17.10 | 3.95103 | 13.38 | 6.5910-1 | 1.08102 | 2.2110-3 | I | Cl.16 |
| Y11 | G018.8120-00.4956 | 0.75 | 2.25104 | 2.85 | 6.1810-2 | 4.92102 | 1.2310-3 | I | Cl.16 |
Peer Reviews
No public reviews on file for this paper yet. If you reviewed it on a platform where reviews are public (OpenReview, ICLR, NeurIPS, ICML), you can paste yours below so the community can read it here.
Videos
No videos yet. Explain this paper in a talk, walkthrough, or lecture? Add one.
Molecular environs and triggered star formation around the large Galactic infrared bubble N 24
Xu Li1,3 Jarken Esimbek1,2, Jianjun Zhou1,2, W. A. Baan1,4, Weiguang Ji1, Xindi Tang1,2, Gang Wu1,2, Xiaoke Tang1,3, Qiang Li1,3, Yingxiu Ma1, Serikbek Sailanbek1,3,5, Dalei Li1,2, and Dina Alimbetova5
1Xinjiang Astronomical Observatory, CAS, 150, Science 1-street, Urumqi, Xinjiang 830011, P. R. China
2Key Laboratory of Radio Astronomy, Chinese Academy of Science, 830011 Urumqi, P. R. China
3University of Chinese Academy of Science, 19A Yuquan Road, Beijing 100049, P. R. China
4Netherlands Institute for Radio Astronomy, NL-7991 PD Dwingeloo, the Netherlands
5Department of Solid State Physics and Nonlinear Physics, Faculty of Physics and Technology, AL-Farabi Kazakh National University, Almaty 050040, Kazakhstan Contact e-mail: [email protected]Contact e-mail: [email protected]
Abstract
A multi-wavelength analysis of the large Galactic infrared bubble N 24 is has been presented in this paper in order to investigate the molecular and star formation environment around expanding H ii regions. Using archival data from Herschel and ATLASGAL, the distribution and physical properties of the dust over the entire bubble are studied. Twenty three dense clumps are identified using the Clumpfind2d algorithm with sizes and masses in the range 0.65–1.73 pc and 600–16300 M*⊙, respectively. To analyse the molecular environment in N 24, observations of NH3* (1,1) and (2,2) were carried out using the Nanshan 26-m radio telescope. Analysis of the kinetic temperature and gravitational stability of these clumps suggests gravitational collapse in several of them. The mass-size distributions of the clumps and the presence of massive young protostars indicate that the shell of N 24 is a region of ongoing massive star formation. The compatibility of the dynamical and fragmentation time-scales and the overabundance of YSOs and clumps on the rim suggest that the "collect and collapse" mechanism is in play at the boundary of the bubble, but the existence of the IRDC at the edge of bubble indicates that "radiation-driven implosion" mechanism may also have played a role there.
keywords:
ISM: bubbles - ISM: individual objects: (N 24) - H ii region-stars: formation - stars: massive
††pubyear: 2018††pagerange: Molecular environs and triggered star formation around the large Galactic infrared bubble N 24–LABEL:lastpage
1 Introduction
The infrared (IR) dust bubble, which is a shell structure formed by the interaction of an expanding H ii region with the surrounding interstellar medium (ISM), provides a target for studying the effects of massive stellar feedback on the surrounding material. The last decade has seen great progress towards understanding the nature of bubbles and the star formation triggered in adjacent shells or bright rimmed clumps (i.e., Deharveng et al., 2005; , 2006; Deharveng et al., 2010; Zavagno et al., 2007; Urquhart et al., 2007; Elmegreen, 2011; Thompson et al., 2012; Kendrew et al., 2012, 2016; Dale et al., 2015). Two mechanisms for triggering star formation around bubbles have been proposed as models: the "collect and collapse" model (C & C, Elmegreen & Lada, 1977) and "radiation-driven implosion" model (RDI, Bertoldi, 1989; Lefloch & Lazareff, 1994). In the C & C process the outward expanding H ii region compress and collect the swept up medium into a region between the ionization front (IF) and the shock front (SF). This shell between the IF and SF will become denser and may collapse to form stars. By contrast, in the RDI process, the IF drives the SF into the surrounding molecular cloud, stimulating the collapse of pre-existing subcritical clumps to form stars. Recently, several observational studies and numerical simulations have supported that those two mechanisms, especially the C & C mechanism, can successfully explain star formation in several H ii regions, but they are not conclusive (see i.e., Dale et al., 2007a, b; Lee & Chen, 2007; Bik et al., 2010; Petriella et al., 2010; Bisbas et al., 2011; Ercolano et al., 2012). Various efforts have been made to find evidence that bubbles trigger star formation, including individual source studies (i.e., Ji et al., 2012; Yuan et al., 2014; Das et al., 2016; Liu et al., 2016; Duronea et al., 2017) and statistical studies (Thompson et al., 2012; Kendrew et al., 2012). However, the majority of observational studies take a phenomenological approach and frequently conclude with open questions as well as uncertainties (Kendrew et al., 2012). In addition, most of the well studied bubbles are relatively small in size, and investigations of large bubbles with radii 5 arcmin are relatively rare (Yuan et al., 2014). A large bubble with a long enough time to sweep up surrounding material would make it easier to find evidence of a triggered formation of new generation stars. To increase the observational sample of large bubbles for the study of star formation in their vicinity, we have selected a large Galactic infrared dust bubble N 24 cataloged by Churchwell et al. (2006) to carry out a multi-wavelength and molecular spectral line study.
N 24 is a large IR bubble in the inner Galaxy at l=18$$\aas@@fstack{\circ}$$908, and b=-0$$\aas@@fstack{\circ}$$315 with an effective radius of 10.93 (Simpson et al., 2012), corresponding to 15 pc at a distance of 4.6 kpc (Deharveng et al., 2010). In a recent detailed study, Kerton et al. (W 39, 2013) compared H i absorption spectra and Galactic rotation models and found a velocity km s*-1* for this region and confirmed an average (near) kinematic distance of kpc. These authors also estimated an evolutionary age of 106 years for this H ii region. The hierarchical bubble morphology is best seen in the mid-infrared (left image of Fig. 1). Enclosed by an 8.0 m shell that is generally produced by the absorption of far-ultraviolet photons from the H ii region by polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), the extended 24 m emission inside the bubble is believed to result from hot dust grains that have been heated by absorption of Lyman continuum photons near the central ionized stars. Several 8 m absorption features inside and on the rim of the bubble indicate infrared dark cloud (IRDC) structures that have been cataloged in the IRDC catalogs of Simon et al. (2006). The catalogued IRDCs inside the bubble appear to have little to do with N 24, as discussed in Section 3.3.3. The single IRDC in the distorted section of the rim (the cyan rectangle on the left of Fig. 1) is bordered by bright 8 m features that appear to be the result of the bubble expanding and interacting with it. In the right panel of Figure 1, the IRDCs are clearly visible in the Herschel data, which indicates that these structures most likely trace the collected neutral material in cold and dark molecular clouds. The advantage of studying the dust properties of the entire bubble with a widespread wavelength coverage (from 70 to 500 m) and at high resolution is that the spectral energy distribution (SED) of young stellar object candidates (YSOs) at earlier phases can be better constrained and the physical parameters can be more accurately estimated.
In this work, we adopt the numerical results of Kerton et al. (2013) for N 24 and add far-infrared observations carried out by the Hershel Space Observatory and ammonia data observed from Nanshan Observatory. We use these data to further investigate the interaction of the bubble with its surroundings by studying the dense clumps around it and to explore the possible scenario of triggered star formation. The data are described in Section 2, and the results and analysis are presented in Section 3 with a summary in Section 4.
2 Observations and Data Sets
2.1 Archive data
Mid-infrared data of the region towards N 24 have been obtained from the archives of the Spitzer Space Telescope (Werner et al., 2004). Images in four IRAC bands centered at 3.6, 4.5, 5.8, and 8.0 m with spatial resolutions ranging from 1.7 to 2 have been taken from the Galactic Legacy Infrared Midplane Survey Extraordinaire (GLIMPSE) survey (Benjamin et al., 2003). The 24 m image with a resolution of 6 has been obtained from the MIPS Galactic Plane Survey (MIPSGAL) survey (Rieke et al., 2004; Carey et al., 2009). These data have been used to investigate the structure of the bubble and the classification of the clumps.
Far-infrared data have been obtained from the ESA Herschel Space Observatory Infrared Galactic (Hi-GAL) Plane Survey. The Hi-GAL plane survey is an Open Time Key Project (Pilbratt et al., 2010; Molinari et al., 2010) that mapped the Inner Galactic plane at 70 and 160 m with the Photoconductor Array Camera and Spectrometer (PACS, Poglitsch et al., 2010) and at 250, 350, and 500 m with the Spectral and Photometric Imaging Receiver (SPIRE, Griffin et al., 2010). The spatial resolution of the images are 6, 12, 18, 24, and 35 for the five wavelength bands (Molinari et al., 2010), respectively. These data are used to investigate the physical properties of cold dust emission associated with N 24.
Sub-mm data have been obtained from the Atacama Pathfinder Experiment Telescope (APEX) Large Area Survey of the Galaxy (ATLASGAL) (Schuller et al., 2009). The ATLASGAL is an unbiased 870 m sub-millimeter survey of the Inner Galactic plane carried out with the Large APEX Bolometer Camera (LABOCA, Siringo et al., 2009). At this wavelength, the APEX Telescope has a full width at half-maximum (FWHM) beam size of 19.2. Using this data, we investigate the physical properties of the cold dust clumps. In addition, we used the 20 cm radio continuum emission data obtained from the Multi-Array Galactic Plane Imaging Survey (MAGPIS) with an angular resolution of about 5 (Helfand et al., 2006).
To trace the molecular gas, we used the 13CO (1-0) observations extracted from the Boston University (BU) and the Five College Radio Astronomy Observatory (FCRAO) Galactic Ring Survey (GRS, Jackson et al., 2006). The angular resolution is 46 and the velocity resolution is 0.21 km s*-1* covering a range from -5 to +135 km s*-1*.
2.2 Molecular Observations
In order to survey the molecular emission, we observed NH3 (1,1) and (2,2) line emission using the Nanshan 26 meter radio telescope (NSRT) of the XinJiang Astronomical Observatory, Chinese Academy of Sciences in March 2018. The rest frequency was set at 23.708564 GHz for observing NH3 (1,1) at 23.694495 GHz and NH3 (2,2) at 23.722633 GHz, simultaneously. The typical system temperature is about 50 K, the FWHM beam of the telescope is 115 obtained from point-like continuum calibrators, and the velocity resolution is 0.098 km s*-1* provided by an 8192 channel Digital Filter Bank in a 64 MHz bandwidth mode. Mapping observations were made using the on-the-fly (OTF) observing mode with a 6 6 grid size and a 30 ( beam) sample step. The antenna temperature corrected for atmospheric attenuation given by the system was , whose values were calibrated against periodically (6 s) injected signals from a noise diode. The main-beam brightness temperature was derived using the relationship , where the main beam efficiency is 0.66. The telescope pointing and tracking accuracy is better than 18. The scale has an estimated calibration uncertainty of about 14 % (Wu et al., 2018).
3 Results and Analysis
3.1 Ionized Emission
Figure 2 shows the contour map of the ATLSAGAL 870 m emission superimposed on the MAGPIS radio-continuum image at 20 cm, along with the position and velocity of cm-wavelength observations of the RRLs H85, H87, and H88 (Lockman, 1989). Sub-millimeter waveband 870 m emission is a tracer of cold dust, and 20 cm emission is generally considered to be free-free continuum emission from ionized gas, which can be used to trace the ionising influence of the H ii region. The ionised gas in N 24 is spatially associated with the hot dust grains and is surrounded by a ring of PDRs indicating the strong effects of the H ii region on its surrounding. Four compact H ii regions (G 18.88-0.49, G 18.94-0.43, G 19.04-0.43, and G 19.07-0.28) in Figure 2 are found to lie on the ridge of emission. In addition, more bubbles or H ii regions have been identified on the periphery of N 24 by the more than 3,500 astronomical volunteers and experts (Simpson et al., 2012) in the 8 m Spitzer-IRAC and 24 m Spitzer-MIPSGAL data (see the left of Fig. 1. Red and purple ellipses represent the large and small bubbles, respectively). The structure and age of N 24 are consistent with triggered star formation. The long evolution of N 24 would have provided enough time for sweeping up the surrounding material and for the mass in the shell to reach the extent, where gravitational instability resulted in the collapse of new stars. The newly formed stars then ionised their surrounding matter to form new H ii regions. Kerton et al. (2013) roughly estimated the age of the G 19.07-0.28 region at about 105 years, and they concluded that the probable timescale for the expansion of N 24 and the likely ages of the secondary regions of massive star formation are consistent with a scenario of triggered star formation.
3.2 Dust Emission
Because N 24 is large and contains complex molecular structure, we show the integrated velocity channel maps of the GRS 13CO (1-0) emission in this region from 59.0 to 71.0 km s*-1* in steps of 1.0 km s*-1* in order to better determine the corresponding velocities of different components (see Fig. 3). Two molecular condensations that are spatially associated with small H ii regions are detected at 60.0 to 69.0 km s*-1* in the East and South of the shell, suggesting that they are physically related to N 24. Figure 2 shows that the distribution of 870 m emission is consistent with that of molecular emissions. These condensations are associated with the H ii regions G 18.88-0.49 and G 19.07-0.28 and form a shell surrounding the central H ii region, suggesting that this H ii region is expanding and sweeping up surrounding material and that feedback from massive stars is taking place. However, several molecular emissions are also detected at 63.0 to 68.0 km s*-1* inside the bubble, which are associated with IRDCs and may be not directly related to N 24 (see Section 3.3.3).
3.2.1 Dust Temperature and Column Density Distributions
Assuming optically thin dust emission, we studied the properties of dust emission using the Herschel data for four bands at 160, 250, 350, and 500 m. To obtain the distribution of the dust temperature, a pixel-by-pixel spectral energy distribution (SED) fitting has been performed on the data. First, we convolved and regridded the 160, 250, and 350 m images to the lowest resolution 35 and largest pixel size 11.5 of the 500 m image. Then a grey body function (Ward-Thompson & Robson, 1990) for a single temperature can be expressed as follows:
[TABLE]
where is the effective solid angle corresponding to each pixel, is the Plank function at the dust temperature , which is defined as , where h is the Planck constant, is the frequency, c is the speed of light, and k is the Boltzmann constant. The optical depth is given by the relation , where is the dust emissivity index, which is a statistical value found in a large sample of H ii regions (Anderson et al., 2012), and is the critical frequency at which . The two free parameters used in the fitting are the dust temperature and the critical frequency . We assigned an uncertainty of 20 to each Herschel flux and use it as a calibration error (Faimali et al., 2012). The quality of the SED fitting is assessed via a minimisation, by considering the observed flux at each the four Hi-GAL wavebands available for every individual association.
Subsequently the ATLSAGAL 870 m image was convolved and regridded to the lowest resolution and largest pixel size of the 500 m image. The hydrogen molecular column density distribution of N 24 was then calculated pixel by pixel:
[TABLE]
where is 870 m flux density and is the mass of an hydrogen atom. is the mean molecular weight of the interstellar medium, R is the dust-to-gas ratio, is the dust absorption coefficient, which we assume to be equal to 2.8, 100, 1.85 cm2g*-1*, respectively (i.e., Kauffmann et al., 2008; Schuller et al., 2009; Csengeri et al., 2014). The resulting map of the dust temperature in Figure 4 shows dust heating from the interior to the edge of N 24, and nearly matches with the contours for the 70 m emission. The shell morphology seen at mid-IR wavebands and the relatively higher dust temperature in the shell of the bubble suggest that the large H ii region N 24 has been heating its surroundings. In spite of the second-generation bubbles distributed on the shell mixed with the large H ii region making the temperature distribution appear complex, the higher temperatures are found mostly in the diffuse regions heated by the H ii regions and areas associated with YSOs in the shell. The anti-correlation between and may be attributed to the dense cores being formed by cold dust where the external heating from the H ii region is lower.
3.2.2 Dense Clumps Identification and Physical Parameters
Based on the distribution of hydrogen molecular column density, the Clumpfind2d algorithm was used to identify dense clumps (Williams et al., 1994). First, the root mean square (rms) of the column density map was derived based on a background noise estimate of 4 1020 cm*-2* from weak-emission regions. Then the level range from a threshold of 4 to 20 was set with increments of 2.5 (where, is equal to the rms noise level), which is similar to the previous parameters used (i.e., Lu et al., 2014; Ohashi et al., 2016). Twenty-three possible dense clumps associated with N 24 and seven possible dense clumps associated with IRDCs inside the bubble were identified within the map. These results match to the greatest extent the dense clumps identified by Urquhart et al. (2018) using the GaussClump algorithm within the ATLASGAL 870 m emission map. Twenty-three of our 30 clumps have a counterpart while clumps 3, 4, 18, 19, 22, 23, B have no counterparts. Eighteen clumps are within an angular distance of 15 arcsec, of which twelve are in the shell and six are associated with IRDCs. Pineda et al. (2009) queried different parameter settings in the Clumpfind2d algorithm for slightly different results and it works consistently for relatively isolated clumps. Adopting the output from the Clumpfind2d algorithm it should be noted that the clumps identified around N 24 are located in three distinct regions NE, Centre, and SW in Figure 4 (left). The three pictures in Figure 4 (right) show the relative position and size of the identified clumps. The two regions NE and SW in the bubble shell are also the main regions where Kerton et al. (2013) studied YSOs, suggesting that the expanding H ii region formed dense molecular clouds and further triggered star formation. It should be noted that the clumps 16, 17, 19, 20, and 21 are coincident with the IRDC at the SW edge of the bubble in Figure 4 (right). This IRDC probably existed before bubble expanded, so we cannot ignore the possibility that these clumps and YSOs are part of the same star forming environment that formed N 24, and the clumps would have formed stars without the influence of the bubble. The seven clumps in the Centre region are associated with IRDCs and appear to have little to do with the expanding H ii region and will not be discussed further in this paper.
In order to determine the evolutionary stages of the 23 clumps in the NE and SW regions, a visual inspection was done using the mid-infrared images (3.6, 4.5, 8.0, and 24 m), and the MAGPIS 20 cm (Helfand et al., 2006), Hi-GAL 70 m (Poglitsch et al., 2010) emission images as described by Foster et al. (2011) and Hoq et al. (2013). To increase the reliability of this determination, the 24 m highly reliable point sources from the MIPSGAL catalog were also used to match the clumps (i.e., He et al., 2016). All 23 clumps were assigned a consecutive evolutionary stage: quiescent (pre-stellar), proto-stellar, and H ii region. In principle, a pre-stellar clump appears dark at 3.6, 4.5, 8.0, 24, and 70 m, and has no embedded massive YSOs. Proto-stellar clumps have 24 m point sources, 70 m compact emission or are associated with extended 4.5 m emission that is likely associated with shocks generated by molecular outflows (Hoq et al., 2013). Clumps that have 20 cm emission and are associated with a compact H ii region that emits extended 8.0, and 24 m emissions are also classified as H ii. However, in practise the size of the H ii regions around N 24 are so large that they can not be designated as single clumps. Therefore clumps that are close to the center of a H ii region, but do not contain the whole H ii region and do not have a 24 m point source, will still be categorised as an H ii region. The classification is shown in column 10 of Table 1.
Assuming optically thin dust emission, the clump masses were derived using a similar method as used for determining the H2 column density via the formula:
[TABLE]
where D is the heliocentric distance to the clumps, is the 870 m flux density, is the Plank function for a dust temperature , and the parameter settings of R and are the same as those in Section 3.2.1. Assuming that each clump has a spherical geometry, the average volume density may be derived as:
[TABLE]
where M is the mass that was derived from the 870 m flux, is the mass of an hydrogen atom, is the effective radius of the structure output from the Clumpfind2d algorithm, and the mean molecular weight is assumed to be 2.8. Finally, a summary of the aforementioned physical parameters of 23 clumps are given in Cols. 5-9 of Table 1. The effective radius, peak dust temperature, peak column density, mass, and volume density of these molecular clumps fall in the range of 0.65-1.73 pc, 16.3-24.2 K, 0.24-4.01 1022 cm*-2*, 0.60-16.30 103 M*⊙, 4.79-13.44 103* cm*-3*, respectively. And the mean values of these parameters are 0.92 0.06 pc, 20.8 0.5 K, 0.86 ( 0.19) 1022 cm*-2*, 2.66 ( 0.81) 103 M*⊙, 7.75 ( 0.46) 103* cm*-3*, respectively. Figure 5 shows the distribution of the volume density versus the peak H2 column density for the 23 clumps. Compared with the clumps around the edge of the large bubble, the clumps around second-generation bubbles tend to have a larger column density and volume density, which suggests that these bubbles provided additional feedback making the clumps more dense.
3.3 Molecular Line Emission
3.3.1 Kinetic temperature
Ammonia (NH3) inversion transitions are widely used as a spectroscopic tool to study the physical properties of dense gas in the ISM because of the lack of depletion for the molecule, its favourable hyperfine structure, and its sensitivity to kinetic temperature (Ho & Townes, 1983; Walmsley & Ungerechts, 1983; Tafalla et al., 2004). The energy levels of NH3 K=1 and K=2 are forbidden transitions, so that the intensity ratio of NH3 (1,1) and (2,2) lines is only sensitive to collisions, thus making the NH3 molecule a temperature tracer. The NH3 (1,1) and (2,2) lines were observed simultaneously. Figure 6 shows the velocity-integrated intensity map of the NH3 (1,1) emission as contours superimposed on the GRS 13CO (1-0) line emission map integrated from 60.0 to 70.0 km s*-1*. The integration range of the NH3 (1,1) emission is also from 60.0 to 70.0 km s*-1* to cover the main group of hyperfine components ( F=0, Ho & Townes, 1983), considering that the satellite lines ( F=1) are usually not accessible and the signal-to-noise (S/N) ratios may reduce if the velocity-integrated intensity includes the satellite lines. Figure 6 shows that the distribution of ammonia molecules is spatially well correlated with the distribution of 13CO emission, while ammonia traces the denser regions. The emission region located south of the N 24 bubble with many small bubbles and strong 8 m emission is more prominent than other regions, which indicates that intense star formation activities are ongoing in this region.
Assuming that the emissions from different NH3 energy levels have an equal beam-filling factor, and that the excitation temperature is constant along the line-of-sight, and that the radiation processes occur under conditions of local thermodynamic equilibrium (LTE), then the rotational temperature between the (1,1) and (2,2) inversion transitions can be derived from the following equation (Ho & Townes, 1983):
[TABLE]
where of NH3 (1,1) and (2,2) are the observed antenna brightness temperatures derived using "GAUSS" fitting in GILDAS111GILDAS (the Grenoble Image and Line Data Analysis System) is an ensemble of routines developed by IRAM to process single antenna observation spectral line data and interference data. http://www.iram.fr/IRAMFR/GILDAS/, and is the main group opacity derived using the GILDAS "NH3(1,1)" fitting method. Primary polynomial fitting is used for baseline removal in the fitting process. Subsequently, the kinetic temperature is obtained from the rotational temperature as derived from a fit of kinetic and rotational temperatures using different Monte Carlo models (Tafalla et al., 2004):
[TABLE]
Finally, we used Gaussian fittings to obtain the central velocity, and the velocity width as listed in Cols. 2-6 of Table 2. The kinetic temperature of these molecular clumps ranges from 19.0 to 29.5 K with a mean value of 23.50.6 K. Those values are slightly larger than the dust temperature, indicating that the ammonia traces the gas associated with the cold dust.
3.3.2 Gravitational stability of clumps
To assess the gravitational stability of these 23 clumps, we compare the thermal mass and virial mass of the clumps using the NH3(1,1) emissions. Assuming a density profile of for these resolved clumps, the virial mass can be obtained from the average velocity dispersion (Urquhart et al., 2013):
[TABLE]
where is the effective radius of the clump (listed in Table 1). The average velocity dispersion of the total column of gas was estimated from the measured ammonia line width (Fuller & Myers, 1992) as:
[TABLE]
where is the observed NH3 line width for the resolution of the spectrometer (), k is the Boltzmann constant, is the kinetic temperature of the gas, and (i.e. Fuller & Myers, 1992) and are the mean molecular masses of molecular hydrogen and ammonia, respectively. The uncertainty in the virial mass comes from errors of the measured distance and source size, as well as the fitted line width, the spectrometer channel width, and the kinetic temperature. It should be noted that it has been assumed that the observed NH3 line width is representative of the whole clump when calculating the virial mass, but in reality the line width may decrease towards the edges of the clumps, which leads to an overestimate (Zinchenko, Henning & Schreyer, 1997). In addition, Equation (8) only considers the simplest case of a virial equilibrium where gravity and velocity width are taken into account, and neglects other influencing factors such as an external pressure and magnetic field strength.
The estimated virial mass and virial ratio for each clump are presented in Cols. 7-8 of Table 2 and the virial ratio is plotted versus the clump mass for our sample of clumps at different stages of evolution in Figure 7. The virial ratio describes the competition between the internal supporting energy and the gravitational energy. The dashed black horizontal line in the plot denotes the line of gravitational stability: clumps below this line are likely to be unbound while those above this line are bound and unstable against gravity. The mean value of 1.81 and the median value of 1.08 for the virial ratio are both (slightly) larger than unity. The values for the proto-stellar clumps and almost all H ii clumps are significantly larger than unity, which indicates that these clumps are gravitationally bound systems and are collapsing to form stars. On the other hand, only five of 14 pre-stellar sources currently appear to be gravitationally bound systems. These results show a consistency between our (first order) estimate of the virial ratio and the evolutionary stage of the clumps.
3.3.3 IRDCs within bubble in line of sight
Further study on the Centre region of Figure 4 using the integrated velocity channel maps of the 13CO (1-0) emission reveals which of these molecular emissions within the N 24 bubble could be associated with IRDCs (see Fig. 8). The ammonia emissions provide the approximate of these IRDC clumps as presented with other parameters in Table 3. The fitting and calculation methods in Section 3.2.1, Section 3.2.2, and Section 3.3.1 were used to derive these parameters. Although their radial velocities suggest a spatial relation with the N 24 bubble system, there is no obvious evidence of interaction between them and the bubble in the available IR data and molecular emission data. If these clumps were associated with the bubble, the passing of the expanding bubble would expose the IRDCs to a strong stellar wind and a strong ultraviolet radiation field. This would make these heated IRDCs bright at 8 m. However, they only appear to be infrared dark clouds in the 8 m band. Therefore, we conclude that these IRDCs are not likely to be directly related to the N 24 bubble system and are (possibly) located near the walls of N 24 in the foreground or background. Higher resolution data and precise distance measurements are required to further clarify their spatial relation with N 24. For the above reasons, these clumps have not (yet) been taken into account as part of the impact of the expanding bubble on the surrounding regions.
3.4 Star formation in clumps
3.4.1 YSOs associated with 23 clumps
The virial ratio and evolutionary phase for these clumps suggest that they have formed stars or have the ability to form them. For the actual formation of massive stars, the classic empirical mass-size relation of was found to be an approximate threshold for massive star formation (Kauffmann & Pillai, 2010). For this reason, the mass versus effective radius relation has been plotted for the 23 clumps in Figure 9 together with the classical relation. All of our 23 clumps are found to lie above this line and are consistent with being precursors to massive star formation. In confirmation, Kerton et al. (2013) found intermediate-mass YSOs ( 2-10 M*⊙*) close to most of the clumps. However, since Kerton et al. (2013) did not use long-wavelength data, some of the YSOs buried in the clumps may have gone undetected.
In order to investigate possible YSOs associated with our 23 clumps, eleven point sources at 70 m obtained from Molinari et al. (2016) are coincident with seven out of the twenty-three clumps, as shown in the left of Figure 4. The mass range and evolution of these YSOs candidate sources follows from the bolometric luminosity by fitting the spectral energy distributions (SEDs) with the grid of YSO model SEDs of Robitaille et al. (2006). This model grid consists of 20,000 two-dimensional Monte Carlo radiation transfer models using linear regression fits to the multi-wavelength photometry measurements of each given source. As a first step, the photometry data of each candidate YSO clump source were extracted from the surveys of 2MASS, Spitzer-GLIMPSE, Spitzer-MIPSGAL and Herschel-HiGAL archives from the IRSA data base222http://irsa.ipac.caltech.edu/frontpage/ (i.e., Liu et al., 2018; Das et al., 2016). As a second step, a visual extinction in the range of 0-40 mag was estimated from the column density map by a relation of , assuming an average (kinematic) distance of 4.3-4.7 kpc for N 24. The optimum SEDs within a specific were returned based on a regression algorithm as presented in Figure 10, where all other models that satisfy are also shown with being the number of data points. Several calculated key parameters of the fits for the eleven candidate sources are tabulated in Table 4. According to these parameters, Robitaille et al. (2006) classified YSOs into three stages:
Stage I has yr*-1*,
Stage II has yr*-1* and , and
Stage III has yr*-1* and ,
where is the envelope accretion rate, is the stellar mass, and is the disk mass. Most of the best-fit model masses are larger than 8 M*⊙*, while the evolution stage is almost uniformly at Stage I. Although two YSOs (Y8 & Y11) have a smaller mass, they are all clumps that can form massive stars, which is consistent with our previous evaluation.
3.4.2 Outflow of G 19.07-00.28
The 13CO emission in the region may be used to find outflows from these star forming regions. In the G 19.07-0.28 region where Y 3 is located, we surprisingly find an apparent outflow in the line wing of the GRS 13CO (1-0) profile, but there are no obvious signs of outflows in other regions. Figure 11(a) shows the position-velocity (PV) diagram of G 19.07-0.28 region, which determined the velocity range of the red and blue lobes. The 13CO (1-0) integrated intensity images of the outflow lobes in Figure 11(b) shows the spatial extent of the redshifted and blueshifted lobes. Assuming that the 13CO emission is optically thin and that all levels have the same excitation temperature, we used the equation derived in Garden et al. (1991) to estimate the total column density:
[TABLE]
where is the observed antenna temperature of 13CO, and is the main beam efficiency of 0.48. The excitation temperature is assumed to be 30 K for the high-mass sources (Shepherd & Churchwell, 1996a, b; Beuther et al., 2002; Wu et al., 2004, 2005; Xu et al., 2006). The column density of H2 gas was required to estimate the outflow masses and a conversion factor was assumed for 13CO lines. The mass for each outflow lobe was derived via the formula:
[TABLE]
where is the mean molecular weight, is the mass of an hydrogen atom, and is the area of each pixel within the outflow lobe defined by the lowest (3) contours. The mass of each lobe was obtained by summing over all spatial pixels and the total outflow mass was obtained by adding the masses of each lobe, . Subsequently, the momentum and kinetic energy within a velocity channel were calculated for each lobe by:
[TABLE]
[TABLE]
where v is the velocity of each channel relative to the systemic velocity, and is the mass for each pixel corresponding to the emission in that channel. The velocity range for the red and blue wings of 13CO spectra were estimated to be (km s*-1*) and (km s*-1*). The total momentum and kinetic energy were obtained in a similar manner as for the total outflow mass. The dynamical timescale of the outflow is calculated as: , where l is the separation between the peaks of the red and blue lobes and v is the mean outflow velocity obtained by . The mass rate of the outflow, the mechanical force, and the mechanical luminosity of the molecular outflow are derived as:
[TABLE]
[TABLE]
[TABLE]
Finally, we presented the computed results of , , , , , , , and as 291.01 56.98 M*⊙, 214.50 42.50 M⊙, 505.51 99.48 M⊙, 1825.60 331.81 M⊙km s-1*, 71.35 ( 14.04) 1045 ergs, 13.00 ( 3.48) 104 yr, 38.35 ( 12.74) 10*-4* M*⊙yr-1*, 138.51 ( 44.82) 10*-4* M*⊙km s-1yr-1*, and 4.54 1.51 L*⊙*, respectively. These values are consistent with the mean value for a large sample of massive star-forming regions (Li et al., 2018).
3.5 Triggered star formation scenario
In order to find out whether fragmentation can really be produced by the collected material, we estimated the fragmentation time of the collected layer following (Whitworth et al., 1994):
[TABLE]
where is the turbulent velocity, is the Lyman continuum photon flux, and n0 is the original ambient density. The can be estimated following (Kurtz et al., 1994):
[TABLE]
and using GHz, K, Jy and kpc given by Kerton et al. (2013), we find value of photons s*-1*. To estimate , the total mass distributed within the shell was taken as the sum of the masses of the 23 detected clumps (at the right of Figure 4), which is 63000 M*⊙. Added to this should be the mass of the ionised component ( 7000 M⊙), which was estimated via , where is taken to be the radius of the bubble, is the electron density of 20 cm-3* (Kerton et al., 2013), and is the proton mass. Assuming that N 24 has a spherical structure, we found cm*-3*. Using the typically adopted range for the turbulent velocity = 0.2-0.6 km s*-1*, we then obtained a fragmentation time range Myr. It should be noted that the stellar winds have not been taken into account in the estimate of the fragmentation time. Therefore, the time derived from Equation (17) will be an overestimate. Given this uncertainty, the fragmentation time-scale is considered comparable to the dynamical age of = 1.5-4.0 Myr (Kerton et al., 2013) of the HII region. This suggests that the collected molecular cloud has had enough time to fragment into molecular cores during the lifetime of N 24. In addition, the spatial distribution of YSOs (see Figure 10 in Kerton et al., 2013) and clumps show an overabundance on the bubble rim relative to the surrounding ISM. Combined with the existence of ionization compression and an overabundance of YSOs and clumps, the time-scales demonstrate that the C & C mechanism is a possible scenario for the star formation at the periphery of N 24. However, since the IRDC clumps exist on the SW edge of the bubble (see Fig. 4 (right)), we cannot ignore the possibility that the RDI mechanism may have been at work there.
4 Summary
We have presented a multi-wavelength investigation towards the large Galactic IR bubble N 24 to analyse the physical properties of the dust and gas therein and to explore the possibility of triggered star formation by combining archival survey data with our molecular line observations by NSRT. The main results of our study are summarised as follows:
(1) The infrared structure and the distribution of the molecular emissions show that the two main regions of G 19.07-0.28 and G 18.88-0.49 in the N 24 shell are consistent with star formation triggered by the expanding bubble. As a result of the feedback from massive stars, some new bubbles have already formed in these two regions, which further affect the environs therein.
(2) Several filamentary structures of IRDCs appear in absorption at 8 m and are clearly visible in the far-infrared images from Herschel with widespread wavelength coverage and at high resolution. We estimated the of the IRDCs inside the bubble in order to determine the association of these clumps, but we could not accurately determine their spatial correlation with the N 24 bubble from the available data.
(3) There is an anti-correlation between the distribution of the dust temperature and the column density in clumps, which may be attributed to a lower penetration of the external heating from the H ii region into the dense regions.
(4) We found 23 dense dust clumps in the column density distribution map using the Clumpfind2d algorithm, which are almost all distributed along the bubble shell. These clumps have a mean size of 0.92 0.06 pc, a mean peak temperature of 20.8 0.5 K, a mean column density of 0.86 ( 0.19) 1022 cm*-2*, a mean mass of 2.66 ( 0.81) 103 M*⊙, and a mean volume density of 7.75 ( 0.46) 103* cm*-3*. The column density and volume density of clumps affected by second generation bubbles are larger than for others, indicating that these second generation bubbles are also expanding and sweeping up material.
(5) We classified the 23 dust clumps according to their evolutionary stage. The values of the virial ratio of clumps in a proto-stellar stage and most of those in the H ii stage are significantly larger than unity, which indicates that these are likely to be gravitationally bound systems and will collapse to form stars.
(6) The mass-size distribution of the dense clumps suggests that they all could form massive stars. The SED fitting results of the eleven identified YSOs indicate that nine of these have a mass above 8 M*⊙*.
(7) The G 19.07-0.28 region is found to contain an H ii region and a massive star Y 3 and the parameters of the apparent outflow have been derived from the line wings of the GRS 13CO (1-0) emission.
(8) The compatibility of the dynamical and fragmentation time-scales and the overabundance of YSOs and clumps on the rim suggest that the C & C mechanism is in play at the boundary of the bubble, but the co-existence of the IRDC at the edge of the bubble indicates that RDI may also play a role here.
Acknowledgements
This work has been funded by The National Natural Science foundation of China under grants Nos. 11433008, 11703074, 11603063, and the CAS "Light of West China" Program under Grant 2018-XBQNXZ-B-024, 2016-QNXZ-B-23, and The Heavenly Lake Hundred-Talent Program of Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region of China. This work is based on observations made with the Nanshan 26 meter radio telescope, which is operated by the Key Laboratory of Radio Astronomy, Chinese Academy of Sciences. WAB has been funded by Chinese Academy of Sciences President’s International Fellowship Initiative. Grant No. 2019VMA0040.
The reference list from the paper itself. Each links out to its DOI / PubMed record.
- 1Anderson et al. (2012) Anderson, L. D., Zavagno, A., Deharveng, L., et al. 2012, A&A, 542, A 10
- 2Benjamin et al. (2003) Benjamin, R. A., Churchwell, E., Babler, B. L., et al. 2003, PASP, 115, 953
- 3Bertoldi (1989) Bertoldi, F. 1989, Ap J, 346, 735
- 4Beuther et al. (2002) Beuther, H., Schilke, P., Sridharan, T. K., et al. 2002, A&A, 383, 892
- 5Bik et al. (2010) Bik, A., Puga, E., Waters, L., et al. 2010, Ap J, 713, 883
- 6Bisbas et al. (2011) Bisbas, T. G., Wunsch, R., Whitworth, A. P., Hubber, D. A., & Walch, S. 2011, Ap J, 736, 142
- 7Churchwell et al. (2006) Churchwell, E., Povich, M. S., Allen, D., et al. 2006, Ap J, 649, 759
- 8Condon et al. (1998) Condon, J. J., Cotton, W. D., Greisen, E. W., et al. 1998, AJ, 115, 1693
