Minimal System of Generators and Syzygies of Centro-Affine Invariants and Covariants for Homogeneous Planar Cubic Differential Systems with Free Terms and Linear Part
Anis Hezzam , Dahira Dali
Faculty of Mathematics, University of Sciences and Technology Houari
Boumediene, BP 32 El Alia 16111 Bab Ezzouar Algiers Algeria, E-mail : [email protected]Faculty of Mathematics, University of Sciences and Technology Houari
Boumediene, BP 32 El Alia 16111 Bab Ezzouar Algiers Algeria, E-mail : [email protected]
Abstract
A minimal system of generators of the algebra of the centro-affine covariants for homogeneous planar cubic differential systems with linear part is known. With the help of the Gurevich theorem avoiding the Aronhold’s identities based on the calculation of determinants, we describe the algebra of the centro-affne covariants for homogeneous planar cubic differential systems with free terms.
Key words: Cubic polynomial differential systems, linear transformation, invariant, covariant, system of generators.
2010 MR Subject Classification: 34C20, 15A72, 13A50.
1 Introduction and Preliminaries
Using Einstein’s notation the polynomial differential systems in n unknown
variables and of finite degree with coefficients in a field k (k=R or C) can be written as
[TABLE]
where Ω is a finite set of distinct natural numbers and for j=1,...,n and r∈Ω , aα1⋯αrjxα1⋯xαr.
The qualitative investigation of polynomial differential systems by means of
the algebraic invariants is developed by Konstantin Sergeevich Sibirskii
[1] when he assimilated the coefficients of
the polynomial differential systems (1) to tensor components,
then made group action on the phase space of these systems and classified
geometric properties of planar quadratic differential systems with the help
of algebraic and semi-algebraic relations in terms of their coefficients.
Many difficult results about differential systems have been obtained with
the help of invariant theory, we refer the readers to [2, 3, 4].
The theory of invariants motivated by projective geometry, number theory and algebraic geometry since Johann Carl Friedrich Gauss has published his Latin book ”Disquisitiones arithmeticae” in 1801 on the representations of integers observed an invariant behavior in the theory of quadratic forms under the action of SL(2,C) by taking x to Ax+By and y to Cx+Dy. Arthur Cayley and James Joseph Sylvester are the first mathematicians who consider the invariants of algebraic forms but they never succeed in calculating it. Many mathematicians are devoted to the invariants of algebraic among them Georges Salmon, Charles Hermite, George Boole, Siegfried Heinrich Aronhold, Rudolf Friedrich Alfred Clebsch and Paul Albert Gordan who succeed in demonstrating the existence of a generating family of the invariants of binary forms of finite degree by using the symbolic calculus invented by Gordan. Faà Di Bruno worked on invariants and wrote a book ”Théorie des formes binaires” wich was regarded highly by David Hilbert who solved the fineteness problem of the invariant theory by using Noetherianity in 1890. In 1993, Hilbert had solved the major problems in the invariant theory [7, 8].
When we use the invariant theory, the main problem that we are facing
is the knowledge of the invariants, that is [13]. In the case where the
action group is the linear general group GL(n,k), the k-algebra of the algebraic invariants of systems (1) called
centro-affine covariants is of finite type. However, the description of the
algebra is a difficult matter. One has to manipulate polynomial in several
variables. The invariants for bivariate quadratic differential systems are
polynomials in 12 indeterminates. Minimal system of generators of
centro-affine invariants for differential systems where Ω={0,1,2} in [2, 11, 5] and Ω={1,3} are known in [18, 12] and
minimal system of 27 syzygies relating elements of the minimal system of (1) where Ω={0,1,2} is found in [15].
In this paper, using the theorem of Gurevich [8], we develop a
constructive to describe the k−algebra of the centro-affine
covariants for a given family of polynomial differential systems avoiding
Aronhold’s identities. This method can be used to determinate
syzygies between the elements of a given minimal system of generators of
centro-affine covariants. Then, find a minimal system of generators of the
centro-affine covariants for the planar cubic differential systems, that is,
systems (1) where Ω={0,1,3} and a
corresponding minimal generator system of the syzygies for these
differential systems. The syzygies between the relating elements of the
minimal system of a given minimal system of generators of centro-affine
covariants for a given polynomial differential systems allows us to have a
unique decomposition of centro-affine covariants of the considered
differential systems.
We denote by C(n,k,Ω) the set of all coefficients on
the right hand side of polynomial differential systems (1).
Denote by S(n,k,Ω) and can be identified as a direct
sum ⨁r∈ΩTr1, where Tr1 denotes the k-vectorial space of tensors 1 time
contravariant and r times covariant for these systems (1).
The action of GL(n,k) on the plane (q,x)↦qx induces a
representation ρ on GL(C(n,k,Ω)) defined for
all r∈Ω by
[TABLE]
where p is the inverse of the matrix q called lows of centro-affine
transformations.
A polynomial function C(a,x):C(n,k,Ω)×kn→ k is said to be a covariant with
respect to GL(n,k) or a centro-affine covariant of C(n,k,Ω)×kn or simply a centro-affine covariant for
S(n,k,Ω) if
[TABLE]
where (detq)−w is the character of GL(n,k) and w∈Z is called the weight of C(a,x). If C(a,x) is constant with respect to x, it is called centro-affine invariant and written C(a).
If w≡1, the covariant is said to be
absolute, otherwise it is said to be relative.
A G-covariant C(a,x) is said to be reducible if it can expressed as
polynomial function of G-covariants of lower degree, we write C(a,x)≡0
(modulo G-covariants of lower degree). A finite family B of
centro-affine covariants for S(n,k,Ω) is called a
system of generators if any centro-affine covariant for S(n,k,Ω) is reducible to zero modulo B. A system B of generators is said to be minimal if none of them is generated by the
others.
Example 1**.**
We can check with the help of the lows of centro-affine transformations (2) that C(a)=aαα is a centro-adffine
invariant for differential systems S(n,k,{0,1,2,...,k}) of weight w=0, k∈N. Indeed, for all q∈GL(2,R), C(ρ(q)a)=ρ(q)aαα=qiαpαjaji= δijaji=aii=C(a), where α,i,j=1,...,n. Some other examples are given in the following table:
[TABLE]
Let E be a k-vector space of dimension n, and let p and q be
two non negative integers.
A contraction over the tensor space E⊗p⊗E∗⊗q
is the map:
[TABLE]
defined by
[TABLE]
If p=q then a sequence of p contractions is called a complete
contraction.
A covariant alternation over the tensor space E⊗p⊗E∗⊗q with p,q≥n is the map:
[TABLE]
defined by
[TABLE]
and a contravariant alternation over the tensor space E⊗p⊗E∗⊗q with p,q≥n is the map:
[TABLE]
defined by
[TABLE]
where the tensor εαk1αk2...αkn(εαk1αk2...αkn)
with αk1,αk2...,αkn=1,2,...,n is an n-vector, the valence of which coincides with the dimension of the space
and the coordinates of which are equal to
[TABLE]
The k-algebra k[C(n,k,Ω)×kn]GL(n,k) is of finite type [14] and in view of
the fundamental theorem of Gurevich [8] it is generated by
polynomial expressions obtained by applying successive alternations and
complete contraction over the tensor product
[TABLE]
where r1,...,ri∈Ω, p=dr1+...+dri+δ, q=(r1−1)dr1+...+(ri−1)dri and
[TABLE]
This motivate the following definition. An homogeneous centro-affine
covariant C(a,x) for systems S(n,k,Ω) is said to be
of type (dr1,...,dri,δ) if and only if it is homogeneous of degree dri in relation to aαr1...αrij,ri∈Ω and of degree δ in relation to the contravariant vector x, and satisfying the relation(4), here r1,...,ri∈Ω,dr1,...,dri,δ∈N. A centro-affine covariant of type (dr1,...,dri,δ) is said to be of degree d=δ+dr1+...+dri.
Hence, the generators of centro-affines covariants for S(n,k,Ω) of given type (dr1,...,dri,δ) can
be obtained with the help of successive alternations and complete
contraction from the tensor tβ1...βqα1...αp, p times contravariants and q times covariants
belonging in the tensor product (3) where p=dr1+...+dri+δ and q=dr1+...+(ri−1)dri
defined by
[TABLE]
where r1,...,ri∈Ω,dr1,...,dri,δ∈N and the indices are belonging in {1,...,n} and can be
written
[TABLE]
For instance, the generators of centro-affine covariants for homogeneous
planar quadratic differential systems S(2,R,{2}) of type (d2,δ) can be obtained with the
help of successive alternations and complete contraction from the tensor (d2+δ) times contravariants and (2d2) times covariants where d2−δ≡0[3] defined by
[TABLE]
where the indices belonging in {1,2} and can be written
[TABLE]
The generators of type (1,1) can be obtained from the tensor a_ _−x− with the help of successive alternations and complete
contraction:
[TABLE]
The generators of type (2,2) can be obtained from the tensor a_ _−a_ _−x−x− with the help of successive
alternations and complete contraction:
[TABLE]
The generators of type (2,4) can be obtained from the tensor a_ _−a_ _−x−x−x−x with the help of successive
alternations and complete contraction:
[TABLE]
where α,β,γ,δ,p,q=1,2 and εpq=σ(p,q)=p−q.
The generators of centro-affine covariants for homogeneous planar quadratic
differential systems S(3,R,{2}) of type (d2,δ) can be obtained with the
help of successive alternations and complete contraction from the tensor (d2+δ) times contravariants and (2d2) times covariants where d2−δ≡0[3] defined by
[TABLE]
where the indices belonging in {1,2,3} and can be written
[TABLE]
The generators of type (1,1) can be obtained from the tensor a\-−−x− with the help of successive alternations and complete
contraction:
[TABLE]
The generators of type (2,0) can be obtained from the tensor
a−−−a−−− with the help of successive alternations
and complete contraction[2, page 88]:
[TABLE]
where α,β,γ,δ,p,q=1,2,3 and εpqr=σ(p,q,r).
2 Constructive method to describe the Algebra of Centro-Affine
Covariants for S(n,k,Ω)
The k-algebra k[C(n,k,Ω)×kn]GL(n,k) is multigraded and can be written
[TABLE]
where A(dr1,...,dri,δ) denotes the
vectorial subspace of the homogeneous centro-affie covariants of type (dr1,...,dri,δ),r1,...,ri∈Ω,dr1,...,dri,δ∈N.
Indeed, the centro-affine covariant C(a,x) for S(n,k,Ω)
can be decomposed as finite sum
[TABLE]
where for i=1,...,s, Ci(a,x) is a homogeneous polynomial in k[C(n,k,Ω)×kn] of degree di
and for i=1,...,s, Ci(a,x) is a centro-affine covariant since for
all q∈GL(n,k) one has
[TABLE]
where w be the weight of the centro-affine covariant C(a,x). Therefore,
[TABLE]
or
[TABLE]
and for all scalar λ∈ k∗, Ci(a,x)=λ−diCi(λa,λx), i=1,...,s . Then
[TABLE]
Hence, for i=1,...,s,, we get
[TABLE]
The set of the homogeneous centro-affine covariants of degree d denoted by
k[C(n,k,Ω)×kn]dGL(n,k) is a vectorial subspace of the k-algebra k[C(n,k,Ω)×kn]GL(n,k)
and for d,d′∈N, we have
[TABLE]
Hence, the k−algebra k[C(n,k,Ω)×kn]GL(n,k) can be written
[TABLE]
and k[C(n,k,Ω)×kn]dGL(n,k) is a direct sum of the vectorial subspaces A(dr1,...,dri,δ) where dr1,...,dri,δ∈N
[TABLE]
It’s easy to check that
[TABLE]
Thus, the k−algebra k[C(n,k,Ω)×kn]GL(n,k) is multigraded and can be written
[TABLE]
Let F(dr1,...,dri,δ) and B(dr1,...,dri,δ) be respectively generating family and
a basis of the vectorial subspace A(dr1,...,dri,δ) of a given type (dr1,...,dri,δ).
In view of Hilbert basis theorem, k−algebra k[C(n,k,Ω)×kn]GL(n,k) is of finite
type and then the degrees of centro-affine covariants of a minimal system B(n,k,Ω) of generators for S(n,k,Ω) are bounded and let D be the upper bound of degrees of these
generators.
The idea is to determine degree by degree a minimal system B(n,k,Ω) for given differential systems S(n,k,Ω) where constructing degree by degree the generating families F(dr1,...,dri,δ), deduce bases B(dr1,...,dri,δ) avoiding Aronhold’s identities, then
determine a minimal system B(n,k,Ω) with the help of
the test of membership in an ideal.
In view of the theorem of Gurevich, the generators of centro-affine
covariants for given differential systems B(n,k,Ω) of
given type (dr1,...,dri,δ),r1,...,ri,δ∈Ω obtained from the tensor 6 with the help of
successive alternations and complete contraction can be written as finite
products f1α1...flαl,α1,...,αl,l∈N of generators of lower degrees f1,...,fl where (dr1,...,drl,δ)=α1(dr11,...,drl1,δ1)+...+αl(dr1l,...,drll,δl) where α1,...,α1∈N, r1,...,rl∈Ω and for i=1,...,l, fi is of type (drii,...,drii,δi).
For instance, the generators of degree d of centro-affine covariants for
systems S(2,R,{1,1,2}) are of type (d0,d1,d2,δ) where d0+d1+d2+δ=d and d2−d0−δ≡0[2] . Since every generating family contain
generators of lower degrees then start from the generating families F(d0,d1,d2,δ) of degree 1. The only
generators of degree 1 are of type (0,1,0,0) and can be obtained from
the tensor once contravariant and once covariant a−− with the help
of successive tensorial operations of contraction on the
tensor from the tensor. Then obtain F(0,1,0,0)={I1}.
The only generators of degree 2 are of type (1,0,1,0), (0,2,0,0), (0,0,1,1)
and can be obtained respectively from the tensors a−a−−−, a−−a−− and a−−−x−:
[TABLE]
then obtain F(1,0,1,0),F(0,2,0,0),F(0,0,1,1) where
- F(1,0,1,0)=
{I17}.
- F(0,2,0,0)=
{I12, I2}.
- F(0,0,1,1)=
{K1}.
In the same manner we found,
- F(0,1,1,1) =
\{$$I_{1}K_{1}, K3, K_{4}$$\}.
- F(1,2,1,0) =
\{$$I_{1}^{2}I_{17}, I1I20, I1I19, I2I17, I24
- F(1,1,3,0) =
\{$$I_{1}I_{26}, I1I25, I5I17, I4I17, I3I17, I32, I31, I_{30}$$\}.
- F(2,3,2,0) =
\{$$I_{1}^{3}I_{17}^{2}, I13I23, I13I22, I12I17I20, I12I17I19, I12I29, I12I28, I1I2I172, I1I2I23, I1I2I22,
I1I5I18, I1I4I18, I1I3I18, I1I17I24, I1I202, I1I19I20, I1I192, I2I17I20, I2I17I19, I2I29,
I2I28, I6I18, I20I24, I_{19}I_{24}$$\} .
- F(2,2,2,0) =
\{$$I_{1}^{2}I_{17}^{2}, I12I23, I12I22, I1I17I20, I1I17I19, I1I29, I1I28, I2I172, I2I23, I2I22,
I5I18, I4I18, I3I18, I17I24, I202, I19I20, I192 }.
where the family {I1,…,I36,K1,…,K33} is a minimal system of generators of centro-affine invariants and covariants of S(2,R,{0,1,2})[2, 5, 11].
For a given type (dr1,...,dri,δ),r1,...,ri∈Ω, dr1,...,dri,δ∈N, a basis B(dr1,...,dri,δ) is a subfamily {fs1,⋅⋅⋅,fst},1≤t≤s of F(dr1,...,dri,δ) where fs1,⋅⋅⋅,fst are linearly independent and ⟨{fl1⋅⋅⋅,flt}⟩=⟨{f1⋅⋅⋅,fs}⟩. We shall show
how the elements fs1,⋅⋅⋅,fst of B(dr1,...,dri,δ) can be determined. Denoting by (tr1)pr the product i=1,...,ν∏((tr1)i)pri and by xα the product (x1)α1...(xn)αn where ν=dimTr1, r∈Ω, pr,α∈N, (pri,...,pri) and (α1,...,αn) are the
partitions respectively of pr and α.
A monomial associated with
S(n,k,Ω) is a finite product of the form
[TABLE]
and can be written simply
[TABLE]
where for i, j,α1⋯αri=1,...,n,aj,aα1...αrij∈C(n,k,Ω). If we define
[TABLE]
where pr1,…,pri,qr1,…,qri∈Nm with m=2(ri+1), then the set of all monomials (7) denoted by M is a monoid with the identity 1. A monomial (7) of
a centro-affine covariant of given type (dr1,...,dri,δ)
can be written
[TABLE]
and will be called a monomial of type (dr1,...,dri,δ). The set of the monomials (8) of type (dr1,...,dri,δ) denoted by M(dr1,...,dri,δ) is finite and can be written
[TABLE]
where l is the cardinality of M(dr1,...,dri,δ) and ≺ is some monomial order on M. Hence an
element f of generating the family F(dr1,...,dri,δ) of the given type (dr1,...,dri,δ) can be
decomposed in M(dr1,...,dri,δ) as follows
[TABLE]
The vector v=(α1,α2,⋅⋅⋅,αl)∈kl is called the vector associated with f. Now
let v1⋅⋅⋅,vs be the vectors associated respectively
with f1,⋅⋅⋅,fs then rank{f1,⋅⋅⋅,fs}= rank{v1⋅⋅⋅,vs}.
Hence, the family {vl1⋅⋅⋅,vlt}
is a basis of the vectorial subspace generated by the vectors v1⋅⋅⋅,vs if and only if B(dr1,...,dri,δ)={fl1⋅⋅⋅,flt}. The
vectors v1⋅⋅⋅,vs can be determined using the
algorithm 2 [7]. We illustrate our idea by means of examples. To
determine B(0,2,0,0) for the planar cubic differential
systems S(2,k,{0,1,2,3}) one construct F(0,0,2,0) where constructing the centro-affines covariants of
type (0,0,2,0). That is, F(0,0,2,0)={J4,J5} where
[TABLE]
since J4,J5 are the lonely centro-affine covariants obtained from
the tensor a−−−−a−−−−
with the help of successive alternations and complete contraction.
The set M(0,0,2,0) of all monomials of type (0,0,2,0) can
be determined where expanding the elements of F(0,2,0,0):
[TABLE]
then
[TABLE]
where the monomials
m1=a1111a1221, m2=a1111a2222, m3=(a1121)2, m4=a1121a1222, m5=a1221a1122, m6=a2221a1112, m7=a1122a2222, m8=(a1222)2
and
[TABLE]
Hence,
[TABLE]
Then obtain B(0,0,2,0)={J4,J5} since
the vectors v1 and v2 are linearly independent.
We can determine in the same manner for B(0,0,4,0) for S(2,R,{0,1,2,3}). We find the generators of centro-affine
covariants F(0,0,4,0)={(J4)2,J4J5,(J5)2,J19} where
[TABLE]
expand (J4)2,J4J5,(J5)2 and J19 then obtain all the
monomials of type (0,0,4,0): (a1111)2(a1221)2,
(a1111)2a1221a2222,
(a1111)2a2221a1222,
(a1111)2(a2222)2,
a1111(a1121)2a1221,
a1111(a1121)2a2222,
a1111a1121a1221a1222,
a1111a1121a2221a1122,
a1111a1121a1222a2222,
a1111(a1221)2a1122,
a1111a1221a2221a1112,
a1111a1221a1122a2222,
a1111a1221(a1222)2,
a1111a2221a1112a2222,
a1111a2221a1122a1222,
a1111a1122(a2222)2,
a1111(a1222)2a2222,
(a1121)4, (a1121)3a1222,
(a1121)2a1221a1122,
(a1121)2a2221a1112,
(a1121)2a1122a2222,
(a1121)2(a1222)2,
a1121(a1221)2a1112,
a1121a1221a1112a2222,
a1121a1221a1122a1222,
a1121a2221a1112a1222,
a1121a2221(a1122)2,
a1121a1112(a2222)2,
a1121a1122a1222a2222,
a1121(a1222)3,
(a1221)2a1112a1222,
(a1221)2(a1122)2,
a1221a2221a1112a1122,
a1221a1112a1222a2222,
a1221(a1122)2a2222,
a1221a1122(a1222)2,
(a2221)2(a1112)2,
a2221a1112a1122a2222,
a2221a1112(a1222)2,
a2221(a1122)2a1222,
(a1122)2(a2222)2,
a1122(a1222)2a2222,
(a1222)4, then obtain M(0,0,4,0) the set of all monomials of the type (0,0,4,0) given in some
total ordering ≺.
[TABLE]
calculate the vectors associated with (J4)2,J4J5,(J5)2
and J19:
[TABLE]
Then B(0,0,4,0)={(J4)2,J4J5,(J5)2,J19} since w1,w2,w3
and w4 are linearly independent. For d≥1, let Bd
be the set of the centro-affine covariants of B(n,k,Ω)
of degree less than or equal to d and Id=⟨Bd⟩ the ideal generated by Bd. In
view of the Hilbert basis theorem the sequence of the ideals (Id)d≥1 is increasing and stationary. Hence, B(n,k,Ω) is finite and therefore d0+d1+d3+δ≥1⨁ B(d0,d1,d3,δ) is finite.
There exist an upper bound of
degrees of these generators which we denote by D. This bound has been
calculated by V. Popov [13] and recently improved by H. Derksen [17] but still too large. We find D when all the centro-affine covariants of degree d≥D are reducible. Now we are able to determine a minimal
system B(n,k,Ω).
Theorem 2**.**
Let D be the upper bound of degrees of the generators of the centro-affine covariants differential systems S(n,k,Ω).
if 1≤d0+d1+d3+δ≤D⨁ B(d0,d1,d3,δ)={J1α11...Jτατ1,...,J1α1s...Jτατs}, i=1,...,s and j=1,...,τ αji∈N, then
[TABLE]
Proof.
We have,
[TABLE]
and
[TABLE]
then
[TABLE]
where for i=1,...,τ,d∘Jτατ1≤D.
Since J1α11...Jτατ1,...,J1α1s...Jτατs are
linearly independents and J1α11...Jτατ1,...,J1α1s...Jτατs∈ ⟨{J1,...,Jτ}⟩, thus
[TABLE]
The theorem is proved.
∎
For instance, consider the planar differential systems B(2,R,{0,1}), that is,
[TABLE]
Degree by degree we find the generating families F(d0,d1,d3,δ) of types (d0,d1,d3,δ)
where d0,d1,d3,δ∈N
and d0+d1+d3+δ≤d of given degree d and with the
help of the algorithm 2 deduce corresponding bases B(d0,d1,d3,δ). Therefore
[TABLE]
since all the centro-affine covariants of greater degree are
reducible, where
[TABLE]
then one get
[TABLE]
3 Minimal system of generators of centro-affine invariants and
covariants for S(2,R,{0,1,3})
In this section we describe the algebra of centro-affine covariants for
differential systems S(2,R,Ω0) where Ω0={0,1,3}
[TABLE]
A monomial (7) associated with S(2,R,{0,1,3}) is a finite product of the form
[TABLE]
where p0∈N2,p1∈N4,p3∈N8,α∈N2. Let us* *order the coefficients of C(2,R,{0,1,3}) and the components x1,x2 of the
contravariant vector x in the following manner:
[TABLE]
The total ordering defined by (10) is a total ordering and can
be extended to a total lexicographic ordering for the set M of
all the monoials (10) and in the usual manner (see e.g. [12,
pp. 373-375])
[TABLE]
Given type (d0,d1,d3,δ) the set of all the
monomials of type (d0,d1,d3,δ) can be written as M(d0,d1,d3,δ)={m1,...,ml,m1≺m2...≺ml}. Hence, given type (d0,d1,d3,δ) one use the algorithm 2 [7] to decompose the elements f1,...,fτ of F(d0,d1,d3,δ) in M(d0,d1,d3,δ) then obtain v1,...,vτ
the vectors associated with f1,...,fτ respectively then deduce B(d0,d1,d3,δ),d0+d1+d3+δ≥1
then get a minimal system B(2,R,{0,1,3}) of generators of centro-affine invariants of
degree up to 9 for S(2,R,{0,1,3}).
Theorem 3**.**
The family S(Ω)={J1,…,J47,K1,…,K75} form a minimal system of generators of centro-affine invariants and covariants of S(2,R,{0,1,3}), where
[TABLE]
[TABLE]
[TABLE]
[TABLE]
[TABLE]
[TABLE]
[TABLE]
[TABLE]
[TABLE]
[TABLE]
[TABLE]
[TABLE]
[TABLE]
[TABLE]
[TABLE]
[TABLE]
and εpq=εpq=q−p.
4 Syzygies between centro-affine covariants of S(2,R,{0,1,3})
S is said to be a syzygy between the elements of S(2,R,{0,1,3}) if and only if S≡0 is an identity with respect to the variables from a∈C(n,k,Ω) and the contravariant vector x, but not an identity with respect to the elements from C(n,k,Ω).
A minimal system of 27 syzygies relating elements of the minimal system of
(1) where Ω={0,1,2} is found in [2, Theorem 17.1] and [15].
The action of the general linear group GL(2) on R2:(Q,x)↦Qx induces a representation
[TABLE]
defined by
[TABLE]
where Q is a matrix of GL(2) and P its inverse. The formula (12) is called the formula of the centro-affine transformations.
Theorem 4**.**
If J7=0, then the system (9) can be transformed into
the following form
[TABLE]
*where
b1=0, b2=1, b11=J1J7−J13, b21=J6, b12=J721(J3J7+21J4J6), b22=J7J13,
b1111=J731(J7J25+21J4J30), b1121=J721(21J4J20−J7J14), b1221=J71(J72−J30), b2221=−J20,
b1112=J741(41J42J20−J7(J4J14+J7(J10+J11))), b1122=J731(21J4(J72−J30)−J7J25)),
b1222=J721(J7J14−21J4J20), b2222=J7J30.*
Proof.
Since J7=0, we can consider the following matrix
[TABLE]
The matrix q is invertible since detq=1. Then, consider the centro-affine transformation
[TABLE]
i.e.
[TABLE]
The system (9) can be transformed into the system
[TABLE]
where for j,α,β,γ=1,2,
[TABLE]
and p is the inverse of q. Hence,
=qi1ai=0
=qi2ai=1
=qi1p1j1aj1i=J71(aμεiμ)(aαaβαiβεj1i)(aj1i)=J71aαaqarpaβαsβεpqεrs=J71(J1J7−J13)
=qi1p2j1aj1i=(aμεiμ)(aj1)(aj1i)=aαaqaαpεpq=J6
=qi2p1j1aj1i=J721(aαaβαiβ)(aαaβαiβεj1i)(aj1i)=J721aαaβapγaδγαδaμβqμεpq=J721(J3J7+21J4J6)
=qi2p2j1aj1i=J71(aαaβαiβ)(aj1)(aj1i)=J71aαaβaβγaδγαδ=J7J13
=qi1p1j1p1j2p1j3aj1j2j3i
=J731(aμεiμ)(aαaβαiβεj1i)(aαaβαiβεj2i)(aαaβαiβεj3i)aj1j2j3i
=J731(aαaβaγaqaδαsδaμβlμaνγnνarkmpεpqεrsεklεmn)
=J731(J7J25+21J4J30)
=qi1p2j1p1j2p1j3aj1j2j3i
=J721(aμεiμ)(aj1)(aαaβαiβεj2i)(aαaβαiβεj3i)aj1j2j3i
=J721(aαaβaγaqaδβsδaμγlμaαrkpεpqεrsεkl)
=J721(21J4J20−J7J14)
=qi1p2j1p2j2p1j3aj1j2j3i
=J71(aμεiμ)(aj1)(aj2)(aαaβαiβεj3i)aj1j2j3i
=J71(aαaβaγaqaδγsδaαβrpεpqεrs)
=J71(J72−J30)
=qi1p2j1p2j2p2j3aj1j2j3i
=(aμεiμ)(aj1)(aj2)(aj3)aj1j2j3i
=aαaβaγaqaαβγpεpq
=−J20
=qi2p1j1p1j2p1j3aj1j2j3i
=J741(aαaβαiβ)(aαaβαiβεj1i)(aαaβαiβεj2i)(aαaβαiβεj3i)aj1j2j3i
=J741(aαaβaγaδaμαφμaνβqνaηγsηaλδlλaprkφεpqεrsεkl)
=J741(41J42J20−J7(J4J14+J7(J10+J11)))
=qi2p2j1p1j2p1j3aj1j2j3i
=J731(aαaβαiβ)(aj1)(aαaβαiβεj2i)(aαaβαiβεj3i)aj1j2j3i
=J731(aαaβaγaδaμγλμaναqνaηβsηaδprλεpqεrs)
=J731(21J4(J72−J30)−J7J25))
=qi2p2j1p2j2p1j3aj1j2j3i
=J721(aαaβαiβ)(aj1)(aj2)(aαaβαiβεj3i)aj1j2j3i
=J721(aαaβaγaδaμδημaναqνaβγpηεpq)
=J721(J7J14−21J4J20)
=qi2p2j1p2j2p2j3aj1j2j3i
=J71(aαaβαiβ)(aj1)(aj2)(aj3)aj1j2j3i
=J71(aαaβaγaδaμδνμaαβγν)
=J7J30.
Theorem 5**.**
Ther exist 109 syzygies between J1,…,J47,K1,…,K75. where
J72J2=J7(J12J7−2J1J13+2J3J6)+J4J62+2J132.
J72J5=2(J4(J31−J30)+J7(2J26+3J25)+(J11+J10)J20+J142).
6J72J8=3((J12−J2)J7+2(J21−J1J12))J14+6(J7J12−J40)+(2J6J10+6(J34−J33))J6+6(J8J30+(J13−J12)J22).
2J72J9=[J1(J5J7+2J25)−2(J3J14+(J11+J10))]J7−2(J4J6J14+2J13J25).
2J72J10=3(2(2J26+3J25−J5J7)J14+2(J11+J10)(J30−J31)+(2J19−J52)J20).
J72J12=J1J7(J72−J30)−(J3J7+J4J6)J20+J6J7J14−(J72−2J30)J13.**
2J7J15=−J12J7(J5+J4)+J1(J4(J13+J12)−J5J13−2J7J9)+(J2J4+2J32)J7+2J3J24−2J4J21+2J9J13.
2J7J16=J12(J26−J4J7)+(2J9−J1J5)(3J13−J12)+J1[2J3J14+J4(J13+J12)−2J6(J11+2J10)−2J7J9]+J2(J7(J5+J4)−2J26)+2(J3(J3J7+J22−(J24+J23))−J4J21+2J6(J18+J17)−J8J14).
4J7J17=J5(J1J14+J5J6−J3J7)+2J1J7J10+2J3(J26+J25)+J4(J6(J5−J4)−2(J24+J23−J22))−2J6J19−2J9J14+2(J11+J10)(J13−J12).
2J7J18=(J3J7−J1J14)(J5−J4)−2J3(J26+2J25)−J5J6(J5+J4)+2J4J23+2J6J19+2J9J14+2(J11+J10)J12.
2J72J19=J52J72+2J4J142+4J7J14(J11+J10)+4J252.
J7J21=J12J13−J6J24.
2J7J22=J4(J1J20−J6J7−2J29)+2(J3(J30−J72)−J13J14).
2J7J23=J1(J5J20−2J7J14)+2(J3(J30−J31)+J6(J26+J25)−J9J20+J12J14).
2J7J24=J1(J4J20+2J7J14)+2(J3(J30−J72)−J4(J6J7+J29)+J6J25−2J13J14).
J72J26=(2J25−J4J7)(J31−J30)+2J14J41+J20J35−J30(J26+2J25).
4J7J27=4J4J32−8J6J28+2J7J8(J4+J5)+2J2(J7J11+J4J14−2J35)+J3(8(J34−J4J12+J7J9)−12J33+4J6(2J10+J11)+J13(3J4−J5)−4J3J14)+J1(J6(2J19−J4J5−J52)−4J7(J17+J18)−2J4(J22+J23)+2J3(J26−J7(J4+2J5)))+2J12(J35−J4J14+J7(2J10+J11)).
12J7J28=J3(4J7J10+6J35)+J4(2J6J10−3J1J26−3J5J13+6J34)+J13(6J19−3J52)+J25(12J9−6J1J5)+12J24(J11+J10)**
J7J29=J20(J1J7−J13)−J6J30.
J72J31=(J72−J30)2−2J7J14J20+J4J202+J302.
J7J32=J1(J7J23+J12J14)+J3J40−J8J30−J13J23+J12J22−J14J21.
2J7J33=J7(J1(J26+2J25)+J4(J13−J12))+J14(2J24−2J3J7−J4J6)−2J25(J13+J12).
J7J34=J6J35+J13J26+2J25(J13−J12)+2J14J24.
3J7J35=3(J14J25+(J72−J30)(J11+J10)−J4J41)−J72J10.
24J7J36=24J18J21+12J9(2J32+J7J8)+12J6(J4(J16−J15)−J8(J11+J10))+12J3(2(J42+J7J16+J6(J18+2J17))+J21(2J4−J5)+J8J14)+24J32(J22−2J24−J3J7)+6J2(J6(J52−2J19)+J3(2(J26+4J25)−J7(J5+3J4)−2J7J18)+6J1(24J12J17−12J9(J23+J22)+12J8J25+6J6(8J28−3J4J9)−12J5(J32+J7J8)+J3(48J33−36J34−48J7J9−8J6(3J11+8J10)+6J5(2J13+J12)+12J4(2J12−3J13)+24J3J14)+12J2(2J35−J7J11−J4J14))+J12(6J5(J23+J22)−12(J10J12+J7(J18+J17))+6J4(J23−J24+J22)+3J4J6(5J5−J4)−24J3(J26+2J25)+6J3J7(5J5+J4))+12J13(J7(J11+J10)−J35+J4J14).
12J7J37=3J4[2(2J42−J7J16−J6J18−J21(3J5+J4))+J2(J7(J4+2J5)−2(J26+J25))+J3(2(J22−J24−2J23+J3J7)+J6(5J5−2J4))]+J1[J5(6(J34−J33)+9(J7J9+J1J25−J3J14)−5J6(3J11+J10)−21/2J1J5J7)+3J4(3J5(J13+J12)+J1(2J26+J25−7/2J5J7)+J4(J13+J12−J1J7)+J6(J11+3J10)−2(J34+J33)+J7J9−J3J14)+J7(6J1J19−4J3J10−12J28)+6J3J35]+J3[12J7J17−24J43+3J6(6J19−J52)+6J5(5J24−3J22)+4J10(J13−J12)+6J3(J26+2J25+J5J7)]+12J9(J33−J34)+3J5(J2(J5J7−6J25)+2(J6J18−J7J16))−4J8(3J35+J7J10)−8J6(3J38+J9J10).
24J7J38=12J9J35+6J24(J52−2J19)+12J7(J5(2J18+3J17)+J3J19)+J4[24J43+12J7(J1J10−J17)+3J6(J52+J4J5−2J19)+6J5J24−6J3(J26+2J25−2J5J7)+4J10(J12−J13)]−6J1J5(J35+J7(4J11+6J10)).
24J7J39=9J5[J7(2J19−(J5+J4)J5)+2J25(J4−J5)]+12J4(6J44+J10J14)++36[J19J25+J35(J10+J11)]−8J7J102.
J7J40=J12J30+J20J24.
J7J41=J20J25+J14(J30−J72).
2J7J42=2J3(J5J29−2J45)−J6(J1J35+J6J19−4J7J17+16J43)+J24(4J24+6J23)+1/2(J5+J4)(J5J62−12J12J13+8J7J21)+2J4(J6J23−J8J20−2J122+6J12J13−3J7J21)+6J12(J34−J33)−2/3J6J10(J13+J12)−4J21(J26+J25)+2J22(2J3J7−J24−4J23)+(9J3J6−2J2J7)(J26+2J25)+(4(J32−J15)+2J2J4)(J30−J31)+4J7J9J12+2J13J34−4J14J32−4J18J29.
12J7J43=(6J35+4J7J10)(J13−J12)−3(2J24+J4J6)(J26+2J25).
6J7J44=3J25(J5J7−J26)−J14(2J7J10+3J35)−6J252.
2J7J45=2J72(J22−J24)+J4(J7J29−J12J20)+2(J12(J7J14+J41)+J24J31).
J7J46=J14(J4J20−2(J7J14+J41))−J20J35+J26J30+2J25(J30−J31).
2J7J47=J20(J4J20−2(J41+J7J14))+2J30J31.
J7K2=J6K3+J13K1.
J7K4=K1(K7−J1K3−J3K1)+K2K3.
2J7K5=2K32+J4K12.
J7K6=J12K3+J24K1.
2J7K7=2J13K3−J4J6K1.
J7K8=J25K1+J14K3.
J7K9=K1K17+K3K6.
2J7K10=2J13K5+K1(J4(J1K1−2K2)−2J3K3).
J7K11=K1K18+K3K8.
J7K12=J20K3−J30K1.
J7K13=K1(J7K3+J14K1−K29)+K3K12.
J7K14=J24K2+J21K3−J6K17.
2J7K15=K1(J4(J13−J12)−2J3J14)+2(J14K7−J13K8+J22K3).
2J7K16=K1(J4(J13−J12)−2(J3J14+J33K1))+2(K2(J26K2+J25)−J6(K19+K18))+4(J14K6−J12K8)+2J23K3.
2J7K17=J1(2J7K8+J4(K12+2J7K1))+2J3(K29−J14K1−J7K3)−4J13K8+2J6K18−J4(2K28+J7K2+J6K3).
2J7K18=2J25K3−K1(2J7(J11+J10)+J4J14).
3J7K19=K1(J7(3J11+2J10)+3(J4J14−J35))+3J26K3.
J7K20=K1(K1K8+K32−K32)+K3K13.
J7K21=K1(J1K17−J8K3)+J24K4−K2K17+K3K14.
2J7K22=J1J4(K13+K1K3)−J4(2K31+J6K5)+2J3(K32−K1K8−J7K5)−2J13K11.
J7K23=2(K3K16+K6K8)−(J12K11+J14K9+J23K5).
2J7K24=2K3K17−J4K1K6.
J7K25=J25K5−K1(K3(J11+J10)+J4K8).
2J7K25=2K3K18−J4K1K8.
3J7K26=3K5(J26+4J25)−K1(K3(6J11+8J10)+6K38)−12K3K18.
J7K27=K12K11+2K3K20−K5K13.
J7K28=K1(J3J20+J7J12)+J13K12−J20K7+J29K3.
2J7K29=2J30K3+J4J20K1.
2J7K30=2J31K3+J20(J4K1−2K8)+2J14K12.
J7K31=K12(J24−J22)−J29K5+2K3K28.
2J7K32=2J30K5+K1(J4(2K12+J7K1)−2J14K3).
2J7K33=K12(2J26+J4J7)+2K1(J7K8−2J14K3+J4K12)+2(J31K5−J20K11+J14K13).
J7K34=(J3K1−K7)(J24+J23)+J13(K17+K16)−J12K17+J24K6+J32K3.
2J7K35=J4[2K48−J23K1−J14K2−J12K3+J7(K7−2K6−J3K1+J1K3)+J1(J14K1−K29)]+J3(2K49+J26K1−2J14K3)+2J13K19.
6J7K36=K1(12J43+3J5J24−3J4J23+J10(3J12−4J13))−6K8(2J24+J23)−6K7(J26+2J25)+6(J14K16−J12K18+3J25K6+2J34K3−J35K2).
J7K37=K12(K17−K15)+2K3K31−K5K28**
4J7K38=K1(J7(2J19−J4J5−J52)+2J4J26)+4(K3(J35−J4J14)+J4J7K8)**
2J7K39=K3(J4K12−2K1K8+4K32)+2K5(J14K1−K29)**
6J7K40=3K3(2K33+K12(J4−J5))−K1(6(K51+K1K19+J7K11)−3J4K13+2J10K12).
J7K41=J12K22+J22K9−J32K5+2K3K34−2K6K15.
2J7K42=J12(K26+4K25)+K3(4K35−2J18K1)+K9(J26+2J25)−2K6(K19+3K18)+2(J24K11−J28K12−J33K5+K8K17−2J14K24).
J7K43=J12(K26+2K25)+2(K8K17−J14K24+K3K36−K6(K19+K18))+J26K9−J34K5.
J7K44=K2(K3K5−K39)−K1(K1K22+K5K6)+K3(K37−K3K4)+K4K32.
J7K45=J14K26+J26K11−J35K5+2K3K38−2K8K19.
2J7K46=2K3(K39−K1K11)+J4K1(K20+K1K5).
2J7K47=K12(J4K5−2(K26+K25))+K1(J4K20−2(K56+K3K11))+2K3K40.
J7K48=J12((K29−K30)−J14K1)+J20(K17+K16)−J23K12+J31K6.
J7K49=K1(J7J25−J142)+J14K29−J30K8+J41K3.
J7K50=K1(J24K3−J25K2)+J12K32+J14K31−J41K4+K2K49+K3K48−K6K29−K8K28.
6J7K51=6(J41K5−K1(J14K8+K12(J10+J11)))+J7(3J14K5−6K1K19−K12(5J10+3J11)−3J7K11).
2J7K52=J5(J7K14−J21K3)+K1(J8J26−J4(J7J8+J32)+2J21(J11+J10))+2[J14K34+J21(K19+K18)−K14(J26+J25)−J32K8+J42K3].
12J7K53=K1(3J4(J34−J5J13)+3J13(2J19−J52)+J24(4J10+6J11)−12J7J28)+6(J24K19−J26K17+2J43K3).
2J7K54=K12(K3(J1(J5−J4)−2J9)+2J4K6)+2(J7K1K24−J12(J24K20K39+K1K11)).
4J7K55=2J26(K1(J11+J10)−K18)+2J25(K1(3J11+2J10)+K19)−J4J5J14K1+4(J14K38−J35K8+J44K3).
2J7K56=2K12(K3(J11+J10)+J4K8)+K1(J7(K26−J5K5+6K25)−2J14K11)+2(J25K20J14K39−J7K3K11)**
2J7K57=J5(J7K21−K3K14)+J21(K26+2K25)+K34(2K8−J4K1)−J26K21+2(K3K52−J32K11−K14K18)**
6J7K58=2J10(K2K8−J14K4)−K1(6(K17(J11+2J10)+J18K8+J28K3)+K15(6J11+4J10))+3[K26(J24+J23+J22)+J26(K23−K22+K24(J26+4J25)]+6[K18(K16−K15−2K17)−K19(K17+K16)+K8(2K36+K35)+K38(K6−2K7)+J35(K10−K9)−K11(J34+J33)+K25(J22−J23)+J13K45−J14K43+J43K5].
J7K59=K1(K5K17−K6K11)+K6K39+K17K20.
6J7K60=3K18(J5K3+K1(3J11+4J10)+3K19+6K18)−2K8(9K38+J10K3)+3J14K45+6(K3K55−J26K25−J25(K26+4K25)+2J35K11−J44K5).
J7K61=K11(K32−K32)+2K8(K39−K3K5)+K13K25.
2J7K62=J5(J7K28−J29K3)−J12(J26K1+2K49)+2(J22(K29−K30)+K15(J31−J30)+K1(J14J23−J18J20)+J20K35−J33K12+J41K6+J45K3).**
J7K63=K30(2J25−J26)+K19(J31−2J30)−K1(J72J11+J14J26)+J46K3+2(J26K29−J31K18).
6J7K64=K12(2J10J12+J7(2J1J10−6J17))+3K1(K3(J5J12−J4J12)+J7(K3(2J9+J1(J4−J5))−2J4K6)+2J12K19)+6J72(K22−K24)+J12(6(J7K11+K51)−3J4K13)+3J4J7K31+6J24K33.
2J7K65=K12(J4J26−4J44)−2J46K5+4K3K63**
2J7K66=2K1[J18K13+K9(J26+J25)−K10(J26+2J25)+K5(J34−J33)−K8(K16+3K15)+K1K53−K3K36+2K6K18]+K28(K26+6K25)+K20(3J33−J34)−K37(3J26+4J25)−K12(K43+2K42)+2[K31(K19−K18)+K32(3K15−K16)+K39(J23−3J22)+K3(2(J22K5−K3K15)+K64)+2(K8K50−K11K48)+K13K36].
12J7K67=12K3K65+K1(6J11K33+3J14(J5−2K26−6K25)+2J10(3K33+K32+K5(2K1K8−J7)+J4K12)+3J7(K11(2J4−J5)−2K45)+6J11K32+3J4(J5K13+2K1K19)).
4J7K68=4((2K17−J9K1)K40−J24K47+J12(K61+K5K11))+2J7(J3(K46−K52)−K5K24−K4K25)−2J4J12K27+J1(J7(J4K27−2K5K11)+2(J5−J4)K1K40).
J7K69=J26K46−J35K27+2(K3K67−K1(K3K45−K5K38)−K19K39+K20K38)−K5K65−K13K45+K26K32.
2J7K70=J20K1(J5J7−2J26−4J25)+2(K29(J72−2J31)+J30(K30−2J7K3)+J47K3).
J7K71=K1(J14(2K29−K30)−(J20K18+J41K3))+K3K70+K29(J7K3+K30−2K29)+J30(2K32−K1K8−K32−K33).
2J7K72=2K12(2J14K8+K12(J11+2J10)+J7(K19−K3(J5+J4))+2J4K30)+2J30K40−2(K56+K1K26)+J7(K1(2J4K13−6K51−5J14K5+3J7K11)+K13(3J11+J10)−2J14K20)+J4(J20(K20−K1K5)+J14K13).
2J7K73=K1(K8(K1K8+(3K33−2K32)+2K32)+K3K51+K5K49−3K11K30+K12K26−K13(K19+2K18))+K34−K32(K33+K32)+3K3(K72−K5K29)+K5(2J7K32+K71)+2(K12K56+K30K39)+K29(2K39−K40)−3K32K33.
6J7K74=K13(6J5K11+12K67+K5(6J11−4J10)−15K45)+K12(K20(3J11+5J10)+K39(6J4−9J5)−3J4K3K5)+3K1(K27(J4J7−J26)+J14(3K46−4K52−K47)−3J7K61)+3(K3(2K73−J14K27)+J7K8K27).
J7K75=K1(3K11(K39−K40)−2K27(K19+K18)−K20K26)+K3(K11K20−2K8K27)+K5(J7K46−K5K32+2K8K20−K11K13+K73)+2(K32K47−K33K46).
Proof.
Since J1,...,J47,K1,...,K75 still invariant under any centro-affine transformation, they still particularly invariant after the transformation q13 . In each element of S(2,R,{0,1,3}) we substitute each tonsorial coefficient by its expression in J1,...,J47,K1,...,K75 then lead on syzygies. For example,
[TABLE]
where α,β,γ,δ,μ,ν,τ,p,q=1,2 i.e.
α=1∑2β=1∑2γ=1∑2δ=1∑2μ=1∑2η=1∑2τ=1∑2p=1∑2q=1∑2bαbβbγbδbδντμbγμpνbαβqτεpq
−(b1)2(b2)2b1112b22222+(b1)3b2b1221b11112−(b1)4b1112b1122b1221−(b1)4b1111b1221b1112++(b2)2(b1)2b2221b11112+(b1)4b11212b1112−(b1)4b1112b12222−(b1)3b2b11212b1122−b1(b2)3b1221b11212−(b1)2(b2)2b11213+2(b1)2(b2)2b12212b1112+(b2)4b1121b2222b1221−(b2)4b12212b1121−(b1)4b1111b1222b1122+(b1)4b11222b1222−2(b2)2(b1)2b2221b11222−(b2)3b1b1122b22222+(b2)4b2222b1122b2221+b2(b1)3b1122b12222+(b2)4b2221b1122b1221+(b2)2(b1)2b1121b12222+(b2)3b1b1221b12222+(b2)2(b1)2b12223+(b2)2(b1)2b1111b2222b1121+(b2)2(b1)2b2222b1112b1221−2(b1)3b2b1112b1222b2222+(b1)3b2b1111b1222b1121+(b2)3b1b2222b1112b2221−(b1)3b2b1111b2221b1112−(b1)3b2b1112b1122b2221−2(b2)4b12212b1222+(b2)4b2221b11212+2(b1)4b1121b11222−(b2)4b2221b12222−3b1(b2)3b1121b1222b1221−2(b1)2(b2)2b1121b1122b1221+(b2)3b1b2221b1112b1221+(b2)3b1b1221b2222b1122+2(b1)2(b2)2b1221b1222b1122−(b2)3b1b12212b1111+(b1)3b2b11222b2222−(b1)3b2b1111b2222b1122−2b1(b2)3b1222b1122b2221−(b1)2(b2)2b1111b2221b1122−(b2)3b1b1121b2222b1222−(b1)3b2b1111b12222−(b1)2(b2)2b1111b2222b1222+(b2)3b1b12222b2222−(b2)2(b1)2b1121b2222b1122−(b1)3b2b11212b1111+2(b1)3b2b1221b1112b1121+3(b1)3b2b1121b1222b1122+(b2)3b1b11212b2222+2(b2)3b1b2221b1111b1121−(b1)2(b2)2b11212b1222+(b2)3b1b1111b2222b1221+(b1)2(b2)2b1111b1222b1221−(b1)3b2b1111b1122b1221
Since b1=0 and b2=1 then
b11212b2221−b1121b12212+b1121b1221b2222−2b12212b1222+b1221b2221b1122+b2221b1122b2222−b2221b12222
−J74(1/2J4J20−J7J14)2J20−J74(1/2J4J20−J7J14)(J72−J30)2+J74(1/2J4J20−J7J14)(J72−J30)J30+J74J20(J7J14−1/2J4J20)2−2J74(J72−J30)2(J7J14−1/2J4J20)−J74(J72−J30)J20(1/2J4(J72−J30)−J7J25)−J74J20(1/2J4(J72−J30)−J7J25)J30
J7(−J72+J30)J14+J20J25
or J7J41=(−J72+J30)J14+J20J25 then lead to SJ41.
Another example,
[TABLE]
where α,β,γ,δ,p,q=1,2 i.e.
−b1b1111b1221x2+b1b1111b1222x1+b1b11212x2−2b1b1121b1122x1+b1b1221b1112x1+b1b2222b1112x1−b1b1122b1222x1+b1b2222b1122x2−b1b12222x2−b2b1111b1221x1−b2b1111b2221x2+b2b11212x1+b2b1121b1221x2−b2b1121b2222x2+2b2b1221b1222x2−b2b2221b1122x2+b2b2222b1122x1−b2b12222x1
−b1111b1221x1−b1111b2221x2+b11212x1+b1121b1221x2−b1121b2222x2+2b1221b1222x2−b2221b1122x2+b2222b1122x1−b12222x1
J7J14K3+J25K1
or J7K8=J14K3+J25K1 then lead to SK8.
Similarly, we obtain 109 syzygies between J1,…,J47,K1,…,K75.
These syzygies are independent since each syzygy contain only one covariant of S(2,R,{0,1,3}) and generating. Indeed, a syzygy Si is of the form λiJ7miIj+pi where for i=1,109 λi∈R∗,mi∈N∗,Ij∈S(2,R,{0,1,3}) and pi is the right hand side
of Si. Then any syzygy S between J1,…,J47,K1,…,K75 can be expressed in pi/aiJ7mi then S can be expressed in pi,,i=1,109. Furthermore, these syzygies still hold at J7=0 by passing to the limit since S(2,R,{0,1,3}) is isomorphic
to R6. The proof is completed.
∎