Incentivized Blockchain-based Social Media Platforms: A Case Study of Steemit

TL;DR

This study empirically evaluates Steemit, a blockchain-based social media platform, revealing low decentralization levels and significant misuse of its cryptocurrency reward system, highlighting challenges in its design and consensus protocol effectiveness.

Contribution

The paper provides the first comprehensive analysis of Steemit's decentralization, reward system misuse, and operational challenges, offering insights into blockchain social media platforms.

Findings

Decentralization in Steemit is significantly lower than ideal levels.

Over 16% of cryptocurrency transfers are suspected to be bot-related.

Existence of a supply network for bot accounts suggests reward system abuse.

Abstract

This paper presents an empirical analysis of Steemit, a key representative of the emerging incentivized social media platforms over Blockchains, to understand and evaluate the actual level of decentralization and the practical effects of cryptocurrency-driven reward system in these modern social media platforms. Similar to Bitcoin, Steemit is operated by a decentralized community, where 21 members are periodically elected to cooperatively operate the platform through the Delegated Proof-of-Stake (DPoS) consensus protocol. Our study performed on 539 million operations performed by 1.12 million Steemit users during the period 2016/03 to 2018/08 reveals that the actual level of decentralization in Steemit is far lower than the ideal level, indicating that the DPoS consensus protocol may not be a desirable approach for establishing a highly decentralized social media platform. In Steemit, users create contents as posts which get curated based on votes from other users. The platform periodically issues cryptocurrency as rewards to creators and curators of popular posts. Although such a reward system is originally driven by the desire to incentivize users to contribute to high-quality contents, our analysis of the underlying cryptocurrency transfer network on the blockchain reveals that more than 16% transfers of cryptocurrency in Steemit are sent to curators suspected to be bots and also finds the existence of an underlying supply network for the bots, both suggesting a significant misuse of the current reward system in Steemit. Our study is designed to provide insights on the current state of this emerging blockchain-based social media platform including the effectiveness of its design and the operation of the consensus protocols and the reward system.