Spectroscopic orbits of nearby stars
J. Sperauskas, V. Deveikis, A. Tokovinin

TL;DR
This study presents spectroscopic orbits for 57 nearby stars, including 53 new orbits, derived from 1320 radial velocity measurements over 30 years, enhancing understanding of stellar multiplicity and system dynamics.
Contribution
The paper provides 53 first-time spectroscopic orbits and reveals new hierarchical systems among nearby stars, expanding data on stellar multiplicity.
Findings
Derived 57 spectroscopic orbits, including 53 first-time orbits.
Identified 20 new hierarchical stellar systems.
Provided detailed orbital parameters for stars with periods from 2.2 days to 14 years.
Abstract
We observed stars with variable radial velocities to determine their spectroscopic orbits. Velocities of 132 targets taken over a time span reaching 30 years are presented. They were measured with the correlation radial velocity spectrometers (1913 velocities) and the new VUES echelle spectrograph (632 velocities), with typical accuracy of 0.5 and 0.2 km/s, respectively. We derived spectroscopic orbits of 57 stars (including 53 first-time orbits), mostly nearby dwarfs of spectral types K and M. Their periods range from 2.2 days to 14 years, some of those are Hipparcos astrometric binaries. Comments on individual objects are provided. Many stars belong to hierarchical systems containing three or more components, including 20 new hierarchies resulting from this project. The preliminary orbit of the young star HIP~47110B has a large eccentricity e=0.47 despite short period of 4.4 d; it…
| Name | JD | RV | Inst. | a/b | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| +2400000 | (km s-1 ) | (km s-1 ) | |||
| HIP 96 | 55470.486 | 11.70 | 0.60 | C | |
| HIP 96 | 55485.410 | 11.60 | 0.50 | C | |
| HIP 3428 | 58387.512 | 1.09 | 0.42 | V | a |
| HIP 3428 | 58387.512 | 14.29 | 0.53 | V | b |
Peer Reviews
No public reviews on file for this paper yet. If you reviewed it on a platform where reviews are public (OpenReview, ICLR, NeurIPS, ICML), you can paste yours below so the community can read it here.
Videos
No videos yet. Explain this paper in a talk, walkthrough, or lecture? Add one.
11institutetext: Vilnius University Observatory, Saulėtekio al. 3, 10257 Vilnius, Lithuania
11email: [email protected] 22institutetext: Cerro Tololo Inter-American Observatory, Casilla 603, La Serena, Chile
22email: [email protected]
Spectroscopic orbits of nearby stars
J. Sperauskas 11
V. Deveikis 11
A. Tokovinin 22
(Received 2019; accepted )
Abstract
*Aims. *We observed stars with variable radial velocities to determine their spectroscopic orbits.
Methods. Velocities of 132 targets taken over a time span reaching 30 years are presented. They were measured with the correlation radial velocity spectrometers (1913 velocities) and the new VUES echelle spectrograph (632 velocities), with typical accuracy of 0.5 and 0.2 km s-1 , respectively.
*Results. *We derived spectroscopic orbits of 57 stars (including 53 first-time orbits), mostly nearby dwarfs of spectral types K and M. Their periods range from 2.2 days to 14 years, some of those are Hipparcos astrometric binaries. Comments on individual objects are provided. Many stars belong to hierarchical systems containing three or more components, including 20 new hierarchies resulting from this project. The preliminary orbit of the young star HIP 47110B has a large eccentricity despite short period of 4.4 d; it could be still circularizing.
*Conclusions. *Our results enrich the data on nearby stars and contribute to a better definition of the multiplicity statistics.
Key Words.:
**Binary stars – Nearby stars **
1 Introduction
Solar neighbourhood is the best studied part of the Galaxy. Yet, it is still a site of active research and new discoveries. While the Gaia satellite is improving the census of our stellar neighbours, several observational campaigns target nearby stars in search of exo-planets. Studies of specific stellar populations, such as young associations or metal-poor stars, inevitably focus on the nearest objects. Last, but not least, solar neighbourhood is the benchmark for stellar multiplicity statistics.
Here we report the results of the large campaign of radial velocity (RV) measurements targeting mostly nearby low-mass stars. It started three decades ago, before the Hipparcos mission. The aims and main results of this campaign are presented by Sperauskas et al. (2016), where the stars with constant RVs are featured. Here we focus on the remaining objects with variable (or supposedly variable) RVs. Our goal is the determination of spectroscopic orbits of these stars.
RV monitoring during several years is very efficient in discovering spectroscopic binaries (SBs); only a few (e.g. three) RV measurements suffice to detect the RV variability or double lines. However, determination of orbits of these SBs requires substantial follow-up efforts. For example, the Geneva-Copenhagen Survey, GCS (Nordström et al., 2004), discovered hundreds of SBs, but their orbits remain, for the most part, unknown or unpublished. This leads to uncertainties in the study of stellar multiplicity, namely in the distribution of periods and mass ratios of nearby solar-type stars (Tokovinin, 2014).
Nowadays, hundreds of thousands of RV measurements are coming from Gaia (Gaia Collaboration et al., 2018) and ground-based surveys such as APOGEE (e.g. Albareti et al., 2017), RAVE (Steinmetz et al., 2006), or LAMOST (Zhao et al., 2012). However, some SB orbits require either a long time span or a frequent cadence, not furnished by the automatic surveys. So far, only Gaia offers the full-sky coverage, but it has not yet provided individual RVs measurements suitable for orbit calculation. Moreover, treatment of double-lined systems and complex cases such as triples by the Gaia pipeline may be problematic. Our results, therefore, are unlikely to become obsolete in the near term.
The results of our observations will be useful in many ways. They provide previously unknown periods and mass ratios of low-mass binaries in the solar neighbourhood that serve to improve the multiplicity statistics. Recent discovery of the strong dependence of close-binary fraction on metallicity (Moe et al., 2018) puts such efforts in a new context. Several binaries detected by Hipparcos accelerations have their spectroscopic orbits determined here. Similarly, this data will help in the interpretation of astrometric accelerations measured by Gaia, as our time coverage is much longer than the duration of this mission. Finally, some objects in our sample present special interest for various reasons, making essential the knowledge of their orbits.
The objects of this study are presented in Sect. 2. Sect. 3 covers the instruments and methods used to derive the orbits. Our results, namely the orbits and comments on individual objects, are given in Sect. 4. The conclusions in Sect. 5 close the paper.
2 The observed sample
The core of the observing program is the survey of K- and M-type dwarfs featured in the McCormic catalog (see a review in Upgren & Weis, 1989) and in the catalog of nearby stars (Gliese & Jahreiß, 1991). Stars with constant RVs, presented by Sperauskas et al. (2016), were used to study the local kinematics. Objects with variable RVs, studied here, were monitored more extensively for orbit determination. The spectroscopic survey of nearby K dwarfs by Halbwachs et al. (2003, 2018) pursued similar goals, and six of their objects are common to our sample. In addition to the nearby dwarfs, we monitored several other objects with variable RVs and present here their orbits. In particular, our program was augmented by the Hipparcos stars with astrometric accelerations (Makarov & Kaplan, 2005), with the aim to establish their periods.
Table LABEL:tab:list contains the object list and the synopsis of our results. Its first column gives common identifiers (HIP numbers are preferred, with HD or BD as the second choice), and the following two columns give the equatorial coordinates for J2000. Then follow the visual magnitude , parallax , and spectral type. All these data are recovered from Simbad. Most, but not all, parallaxes come from the Gaia DR2 (Gaia Collaboration et al., 2018). The remaining columns of Table LABEL:tab:list summarize our results. The variability is coded as C – constant, V – variable, s2 – double-lined, S1, S2, or S3 – single- double- and triple-lined binaries with orbits determined here. Then follow the number of RV measurements , their time span , and the weighted mean velocity . For binaries with orbits, is the center-of-mass velocity. The last two columns contain the statistics explained below.
To give an idea of the stars studied here, we place them on the color-magnitude diagram in Fig. 1. Most stars are low-mass dwarfs, although hotter F-type stars and giants are also present in our sample. Remember that at the start of our program, the trigonometric parallaxes were not available, and some stars classified spectroscopically as dwarfs turned out to be giants. The median parallax is 25 mas, so half of the objects are located within 40 pc from the Sun. The closest, HIP 29295, has a distance of only 5.7 pc. On the other hand, 16 objects (mostly giants) have parallaxes less than 5 mas.
3 Observations and data processing
3.1 Instruments
The first RV measurements reported here date back to February 1988. They were made using the correlation radial-velocity meter (RVM) installed at the 1-m Lithuanian telescope at Mt. Maidanak, in Uzbekistan (see e.g. Tokovinin, 1992). Like the CORAVEL instrument (Baranne et al., 1979), it scans the echelle spectrum over the physical mask with slits corresponding to individual spectral lines, accumulates the transmitted flux as a function of the relative shift, and determines the RV by approximating the cross-correlation curve with one or several Gaussian curves.
Starting from 1998, a similar CORAVEL-type instrument constructed at the Vilnius observatory became operational. It worked, mostly, at the 1.65-m telescope of the Moletai observatory, although several trips to other telescopes were made. The instrument and observing runs are further described by Sperauskas et al. (2016). That paper also gives a thorough analysis of the RV zero points and accuracy by comparing to several lists of RV standards. In the following, we refer to both instruments as CORAVELs, without making distinction between them.
In 2015, the CORAVEL in Moletai was replaced by the modern fiber-fed echelle spectrometer VUES (Jurgenson et al., 2016). It covers the spectral range from 400 nm to 880 nm with a resolutions from 30000 to 60000. In this program we used the lowest resolution of 30000. The first RV measurement with VUES reported here was made on November 26, 2015 (JD 2457352). The spectrum recorded by the CCD detector is extracted and calibrated in the standard way. The RV is determined by numerical cross-correlation of this spectrum with a binary mask, emulating the CORAVEL method in software. Compared to CORAVEL, the RVs delivered by VUES are more accurate; their rms residuals from the orbits are, typically, from 0.2 to 0.3 km s*-1* . The RV zero point is controlled by observations of the IAU RV standards (Fig. 2). The systematic RV offset of VUES is less than 0.1 km s*-1* .
3.2 Detection of variable RVs
For each star, the mean radial velocity was computed with weights inversely proportional to the squares of the measurement errors. The errors of the CORAVEL RVs were used as listed, while the errors of the RVs measured by VUES were augmented by adding quadratically 0.2 km s*-1* because the listed errors are internal, determined by the dip fitting, and they do not account for other error sources such as wavelength calibration and instrument stability.
The weighted rms deviation from the mean, , is computed as
[TABLE]
The first term of this equation, divided by the number of measurements , gives the normalized statistic, which has a mathematical expectation of one for a constant RV and realistic errors . The statistics and are given in the last two columns of Table LABEL:tab:list, except for the stars with computed orbits. The large values are replaced by 99. For multi-lined systems, the statistics are computed for the primary component.
3.3 Orbit calculation
Spectroscopic orbits were determined with the help of the IDL code orbit.pro.111The code can be downloaded from http://www.ctio.noao.edu/~atokovin/orbit/ Individual RVs are weighted in proportion to . However, the errors are artificially increased when RVs are deduced from partially blended dips and in other instances were the residuals strongly exceed the errors. In a few cases where the spectroscopic pair is also resolved, we fitted combined spectro-visual orbits using the same code. The errors of RVs and positional measurements are balanced in the sense that the normalized statistic for each type of data should be close to one. Finally, orbits of triple systems were fitted using an extension of this code called orbit3.pro and described by Tokovinin & Latham (2017); it is also available online.
4 Results
4.1 Individual RVs
Table 1, published in full at the CDS, lists individual RV measurements, a total of 1913 velocities obtained with CORAVEL and 632 velocities measured with VUES. Its first column is the object name (same as in the object list). Then follow the Julian date, RV, its internal error, and the instrument code (V for VUES and C for CORAVEL). For double-lined binaries, the last column distinguishes the primary and secondary components by the letters a and b, respectively. For VUES, we list the internal errors determined by fitting the correlation dips, while for CORAVEL the errors include the instrumental noise.
4.2 Spectroscopic orbits
The orbital elements and their errors are listed in Table LABEL:tab:sborb, in standard notation. For circular orbits, we fixed the eccentricity and the argument of periastron . The before-last column gives the weighted rms residuals for the primary component or for both components of double-lined (SB2) binaries. The spectroscopic masses , i.e. the minimum masses, are provided for SB2s in the last column. For the single-lined pairs (SB1s), this column contains the minimum secondary mass estimated from the orbit after adopting a reasonable guess for the primary mass.
The RV curves of spectroscopic binaries are given in Figs. 3–5. In each panel, the horizontal axis is the orbital phase from 0 to 1.5 (the last half-period is repeated), the vertical axis is the RV in km s*-1* . The RV curves of the primary and secondary components are plotted in full and dashed lines, respectively, while the squares and triangles denote the measurements. In some plots, crosses denote RVs with reduced weights.
4.3 Comments on the individual objects
This subsection provides notes on individual stars and stellar systems from our list. Hierarchical systems with three or more components are also featured in the Multiple-Star Catalog, MSC (Tokovinin, 2018). Several objects with subsystems discovered here are added to the MSC. Data on visual components are taken from the Washington Double Star catalog, WDS (Mason et al., 2001) and from the MSC.222See the latest version at http://www.ctio.noao.edu/~atokovin/stars. Unknown periods of visual binaries are estimated crudely from projected separations assuming that they equal the semimajor axis. Similary, the semimajor axes of spectroscopic binaries are estimated from their periods, using known distance and a guess of the components’ masses. Information on astrometric accelerations detected by the Hipparcos mission comes from the paper by Makarov & Kaplan (2005).
HIP 96 (BD+13 5195, M0.5V, 43 pc). This visual triple system consists of the 11″ pair A,B and the 02 subsystem Aa,Ab with yr. All components are M-type dwarfs. We find that the RVs of both A and B are slowly variable. This is expected for A, which is a close pair; the component B may also host a low-mass companion.
HIP 374 (HD 225220), a K0 giant, is the main component A of the hierarchical system located at the 200 pc distance. The outer pair A,D has a 953 separation; A,B is a visual binary with yr. The main-sequence star D (TYC 2267-1300-1, probably of F9V spectral type) is found here to be an SB1 with d. This is therefore a quadruple system of 2+2 hierarchy. The star C = HIP 375, listed in the WDS, is optical, as evidenced by its proper motion (PM), different parallax, and the RV measured here.
HIP 1412 (K7V, 32 pc) has a large RV variation, but no orbit can be derived yet from our 6 RVs.
HIP 3428 (BD+23 97, K7, 45 pc) is a double-lined twin binary with d and the mass ratio . Interestingly, it has an astrometric acceleration, so, likely, it is a triple system. However, residuals to the spectroscopic orbit do not show any slow trends.
HIP 5110 ** (HD 6440, 27 pc) is a 61 physical binary STF 87 with an estimated period of 2 kyr. We discover RV variability of the component B, of K8V spectral type. Considering also the 2.5 km s-1 RV difference between A and B, presumably caused by the orbital motion of Ba,Bb, we believe that this is a triple system.
HD 8691 (G0, 50 pc) is a high-PM star and an SB1 with d, with a low-mass secondary.
HIP 9867 (GJ 84.2, M0V, 19 pc) is a high-PM star and a double-lined pair with d and unequal correlation dips. WDS lists three visual companions, all optical. Eclipses are reported by Malkov et al. (2006).
**HIP 10258 ** (BD+03 301, K5, 47 pc) is a chromospherically active double-lined binary with d and a mass ratio . Its visual companion at 25″(SKF 1518) shares common parallax, PM, and RV.
BD+49 646 (unknown spectral type, 53 pc) has double correlation dips, but we have not derived its orbit from the 8 spectra. It is an X-ray source.
HIP 11437 (AG Tri, K7V, 41 pc) is a young chromospherically active star in the Pictoris moving group (Messina et al., 2017); it has extensive coverage in the literature. We found a constant RV of 6.0 km s*-1* (see also Sperauskas et al., 2016), in agreement with other published studies. The visual companion at 22″ is physical.
**HIP 12787 ** (MCC 401, M0Ve, 49 pc) is a triple system with the outer 21″physical binary A,C. Its primary component is an astrometric binary, resolved directly in 2015.9 at 025 by Janson et al. (2017); its estimated period is 40 yr. The spectrum is double-lined, suggesting existence of a close subsystem, but no orbit is derived. The components A and C are located above the main sequence and belong to the Pictoris moving group according to Janson et al. The component B at 25″ listed in the WDS is optical.
HIP 13398 (G 36-38, M2V, 23 pc) is a high-PM star, likely with a variable RV.
**HIP 13460 ** (BD+60 585, K3V, 39 pc) is a triple system discussed in the next subsection.
HIP 14478 (V568 Per, K6, 27 pc) is a triple system. The outer 29 pair A 1572 has an estimated period of 600 yr. Its primary component is a single-lined binary with days. The semimajor axis of the inner subsystem is 87 mas and it is detectable astrometrically from the PM difference between Gaia and Hipparcos.
HIP 14669 ** (MCC 99, M2V, 17 pc) is a Hipparcos visual binary with known orbit, yr. We see an RV trend by 6 km s-1 over 7 years, presumably caused by this orbit.
HIP 14864 (BD+60 637, M0Ve, 25 pc) is a triple system consisting of the 06 binary discovered by Hipparcos (period 40 yr) and the double-lined subsystem Aa,Ab with d and , discovered here.
BD+03 480 (V1221 Tau, G0, 83 pc) is a young visual triple system, where the inner 09 binary A 2417BC has been known for a long time (since 1912), while another companion D at 22 was discovered a century later, in 2012, and has not yet been confirmed as physical (it is not found in Gaia DR2). Our 11 observations during 13 years show a constant RV of 12.66 km s*-1* . However, Gaia DR2 gives an RV of 18.05 km s*-1* with an error of 7.26 km s*-1* , suggesting variability.
HIP 17102 (HD 278874, 39 pc) is a flaring K2V dwarf in a triple system. The outer pair ES 327 has a 155 separation and a long 10 kyr period. The secondary star B is located above the main sequence. The main component A is a double-lined binary with d and (the components Aa and Ab are interchanged in our orbit). The inner semimajor axis is 18 mas, so the subsystem Aa,Ab can be resolved.
GJ 3248 is an M1V dwarf at 16 pc. We suspect that its RV is variable.
HIP 18448 (K0, 149 pc) is a triple system composed of the outer 25″pair LDS 1583 and the inner subsystem Aa,Ab revealed by astrometric acceleration. Here we derive its accurate spectroscopic orbit with yr. The primary star is a subgiant located above the main sequence, while the component B is below; Chanamé & Ramirez (2012) consider B to be a white dwarf.
HIP 19140 (BD15 728, K5V, 40 pc) certainly has a variable RV, as well as astrometric acceleration.
HIP 19915 (HD 26872, F8, 166 pc) is a triple system composed of the tight 32-mas interferometric pair YSC 128 with an estimated period of 6 yr (no orbit is known yet) and the double-lined subsystem with days. The inner orbit is seen at large inclination, as evidenced by the small spectroscopic masses . We could not detect variations of the systemic velocity that might be caused by the visual binary.
HD 279846 (K2, 82 pc) is just a double-lined binary with days and an accurately determined orbit; .
HIP 20709 (HD 27961, F5, 132 pc) is an interesting hierarchical system where both the outer 82-yr visual orbit and the inner 141-day double-lined orbit, determined here, are known. The spectrum is triple-lined. We fitted both orbits simultaneously, accounting for the slow RV drift caused by the visual pair HU 609. The inclination of the spectrosopic pair derived from comparison between the spectroscopic mass and the mass estimated from absolute magnitude, is 60°or 120°, while the outer inclination is 122°. The two orbits thus can be coplanar. The inner semimajor axis is 5 mas, so the system can be resolved with long-baseline interferometers like CHARA array to measure the relative inclination. The rms scatter of RVs of the visual secondary component, B, is large, 2.3 km s*-1* . A possible orbit of Ba,Bb with a 1600 d period and an amplitude of 2.3 km s*-1* can be fitted, reducing the weighted rms to 0.6 km s*-1* . This tentative orbit is not given here. The minimum mass of the hypothetical component Bb is 0.15 .
**HIP 21710 ** (HD 286955, K2, 27 pc) is a nearby 3-tier quadruple system. The outer 34″pair A,B (GIC 51) has an estimated period of 23 kyr, the intermediate visual binary Aa,Ab resolved by Hipparcos has an orbit with yr, and the inner spectroscopic binary has a period of 610 days announced by Halbwachs et al. (2003) and eventually published by Halbwachs et al. (2018). We determined the spectroscopic orbit from our own observations, but publish here more accurate elements derived from the combined data.
HIP 21845 ** (HD 29696, F8, 115 pc) might have a slow RV variation, although comparison between Gaia and Hipparcos does not reveal any astrometric acceleration. The visual companion at 29″ listed in the WDS is physical, according to its Gaia parallax and the RV of 11.4 km s-1 (the first discordant measure of this pair given in the WDS is misleading).
HIP 23550 (HD 32387, G8V, 73 pc) shows an RV trend over 9 years, indicative of a long period; it is an acceleration binary. The RV variability with an rms of 1.8 km s*-1* was also detected by Niedever et al. (2002).
HIP 24488 ** (HD 33798, V390 Aur) is a visual binary with a period of 513 yr according to its current, still uncertain, orbit. The Gaia parallax of 2.14 mas is erroneous, so the Hipparcos parallax of 8.73 mas is adopted, in better agreement with the dynamical parallax from the orbit, 6.0 mas. Fekel & Marschall (1991) studied this lithium-rich chromospherically active G5III giant and concluded that it is not a spectroscopic binary; they quote the RV of km s-1 . We noted doubling of some correlation dips that could be caused by the fast rotation, km s*-1* . The RVs derived from double dips are ignored here, and the RV is likely constant.
GJ 220 is a nearby M2V dwarf (parallax 51.54.6 mas) with a variable RV. We derive a tentative orbit with d and km s*-1* from the 13 measured RVs. More observations are needed, however, to constrain the orbit before it can be published. The pair may have been resolved by Gaia because the DR2 does not provide its parallax.
HIP 28663 (HD 41028, F4IV, 103 pc) is a single-lined binary with a well-determined orbit of d and the minimum secondary mass of 0.35 .
HIP 29295 (HD 42581, GJ 229) is a flaring M1V dwarf located at 5.8 pc distance. Its RV is constant during 15.8 years spanned by our observations. Extensive literature covers the search for exo-planets with precise RVs and photometry and the distant brown dwarf companion GJ 229B detected by imaging.
HIP 29316 (BD+10 1032) is an M3V nearby (11 pc) close visual binary KAM 1 with an estimated period of 20 yr. Gaia DR2 does not provide astrometry of this resolved source. The RV is variable, possibly because of the visual orbit. The WDS companion C at 13″ is optical.
**HIP 30269 ** (HD 44517, F5V, 311 pc) has a large-amplitude RV variation discovered by Nordström et al. (2004), but no orbit yet.
**HIP 33560 ** (HD 51849, K4V, 22.5pc) is a visual triple system composed of the 50″outer pair AB,C and the 06 inner pair A,B discovered by Hipparcos with an estimated period of 50 yr but yet unknown orbit. We suspect RV variability that might be caused by motion in the visual pair. The RV trend is also detected by Halbwachs et al. (2018). The star is featured in Sperauskas et al. (2016).
**HIP 34341 ** (BD+03 1552, K5V, 26 pc) is a single-lined binary with d, as well as an astrometric binary.
**HIP 35706 ** (BD+68 474, K5V, 42 pc) has a long period of 13 years, fully covered by our RV data. The minimum mass of the secondary is rather large, 0.5 , and its lines are likely blended with those of the primary, reducing the RV amplitude. It is also an astrometric binary.
**HIP 36758 ** (BD+39 1967, F8, 168 pc) might have a variable RV, although our 11 measurements are not conclusive.
HIP 38195 (HD 63207, G 111-38, G5, 111 pc) is a three-tier visual quadruple system with separations of 109″, 22, and 0084. It is metal-poor. One of our 10 RVs deviates from the rest, suggesting variability. However, Latham et al. (2002) found a constant RV of 71.61 km s*-1* , so the existence of a spectroscopic subsystems is unlikely. The inner pair has an estimated period of 20 years and should cause slow RV changes.
HIP 39681 (HD 66948, G5IV, 68 pc) is a single-lined binary with a long 4.7-yr period. Astrometric orbit with similar period has been published by Goldin & Makarov (2007). The large minimum secondary mass, 0.5 , indicates that the RV amplitude could be reduced by line blending.
**HIP 40253 ** (HD 68119, F5, 116 pc) is a single-lined binary with d, as well as an astrometric binary.
HIP 40724 ** (BD14 2469, K5V, 35 pc) has only two RV measurements that differ by 2 km s-1 ; it is an astrometric binary.
HD 71028 is a distant (480 pc) chromospherically active K0III giant for which we determine an orbit with d.
**HIP 42507 ** (BD05 2603, K6V, 26 pc) has a large caused by one outlying measurement, hence the RV variability is not certain.
HIP 42550 (HD 73394) is a distant (600 pc) G5III giant. Its visual companion B (ES 209) at 57″ separation is optical, with different PM and RV. Both stars were observed here, and we found that B has double lines. No orbit can be derived from our five spectra.
HIP 43820 (HD 75632, M1V, 11.6 pc) is a visual binary on a 609-yr orbit, currently at 3″ separation. The RV of the brighter component A varies slowly during 14 years of our monitoring, while its mean value differs slightly from the two RVs of the component B. Therefore we believe that it could be a triple system. Halbwachs et al. (2018) published 9 pairs of RVs, splitting the CORAVEL correlation dips in two components. Combining these data with our RVs and with two RVs from Tokovinin & Smekhov (2002), we can fit an orbit with d, km s*-1* , km s*-1* , and km s*-1* . The minimum masses are suspiciously small, 0.05 and 0.02 , therefore we prefer not to publish this orbit.
HIP 46383 (BD+40 2208, K4V, 32 pc) is a double-lined pair with d and equal components, . After the orbit was computed from our 12 RVs, the paper by Halbwachs et al. (2018) came to our attention. Here we fit the orbit to the combined set of 33 RVs. The small residuals of 0.38 and 0.43 km s*-1* for the primary and secondary components, respectively, attest the good quality of our RVs and the lack of substantial zero-point differences between the CORAVELs at Moletai and OHP and the VUES. Considering the physical companion at 56″(LEP 36), this is a triple system.
BD08 2689 (M0V) shows an increasing RV during 6 years of our monitoring. Simbad quotes only a crude parallax of 9.215.0 mas that places the star at 3 mag above the main sequence (see Fig. 1). Most likely this parallax is wrong. Gaia DR2 provides no parallax because the star is a resolved 02 binary BEU 13 with an estimated period of 80 yr.
HIP 46926 (BD+16 1992, G0, 107 pc) is a triple system. The outer 33″ pair is physical (common PM and parallax). We discovered the double-lined inner subsystem Aa,Ab with days and determined its orbit. Comparison of the RV amplitudes with the estimated masses implies a low orbital inclination of 15°.
HIP 47110 (HD 82939, G5V, 39 pc) is a young multiple system belonging to the Pictoris moving group (Alonso-Floriano et al., 2015). The outer pair with a large separation of 162″ is physical, with common PM, RV, and parallax; its estimated period is 160 kyr. The M0V secondary component B (HIP 47133) was found to be a double-lined spectroscopic binary by Schlieder et al. (2012), but they have not provided its orbit. We observed the component B for almost 16 years and derive here an orbit with days. The residuals are quite large, 2.7 km s*-1* , partly because the star is faint and partly because of its chromospheric activity. The outstanding feature of this orbit is its large eccentricity of 0.47. This pair is still in the phase of tidal orbit circularization. However, more observations are needed to confirm and improve the orbit.
HIP 47899 (MCC 554, K4V, 79 pc) is also a double-lined binary with a period of 146 days and a small but statistically significant orbital eccentricity. The mass ratio is .
**HIP 48346 ** (BD+38 2075, K8, 52 pc) is a double-lined binary with d, rather large eccentricity , and no other known visual companions.
HIP 50156 (DK Leo, M0.7V, 23 pc) is a triple system composed of the 01 visual binary A,B with estimated period 3 yr, also detected by astrometric acceleration, and the 73-day single-lined inner pair Aa,Ab found here. It is a variable star of BY Dra type. The system belongs to the Pictoris group according to several authors such as Schlieder et al. (2012); Alonso-Floriano et al. (2015); Messina et al. (2017) and has an extensive bibliography.
**HIP 50271 ** (BD+26 2062, G0, 173 pc) is a distant (869″) optical companion to the nearby (37 pc) G0V star HIP 50355. Our observations lead to the single-lined orbit with days.
**HIP 52021 ** (BD05 3108, K8, 38 pc) has a variable RV, but our data do not suffice to find its orbit.
**HIP 54002 ** (AB Crt, K3V, 31 pc) is a BY Dra type variable star with variable RV, but no spectroscopic orbit yet.
HIP 54094 (BD+54 1411, unknown spectral type, 47 pc) has the first deviant RV measurement that suggests its variability. Further monitoring is needed.
HIP 56229 ( BD+41 2201, M0, 44 pc) is a double-lined binary. The 186-day spectroscopic orbit derived here from only eight RVs is not very secure. The star is an X-ray source. Astrometric acceleration was detected.
HIP 57058 (GJ 435.1, K4V, 31 pc) is a spectroscopic and acceleration binary for which we derive a preliminary single-lined orbit with d by combining our RVs with those of Halbwachs et al. (2018). These authors found that the correlation dips are double and measured the RVs of the secondary component. The VUES profiles are double as well, we also measure the RVs of both components. This means that the CORAVEL RVs derived by fitting a single component are biased both in our data and in those of Halbwachs et al. when the RV difference is small. We use CORAVEL RVs with a low weight and disregard some of them. The period and estimated masses of 0.69 correspond to a semimajor axis of 57 mas. This star was resolved twice in 2018 by speckle inetrferometry at the Southern Astrophysical Research Telescope, SOAR, at similar separations and shows a fast orbital motion, in qualitative agreement with the 2-year period (Tokovinin et al. 2019, in preparation).
The RVs of the secondary component do not vary in anti-phase with the primary and, therefore, cannot be used to derive a double-lined orbit. Hypothetically, this is a triple system where the outer orbit has a small inclination (hence small ) and its secondary component contains a short-period subsystem. Spectroscopic monitoring with higher resolution and future astrometric orbits from Gaia and SOAR will clarify the architecture of this low-mass system.
BD+44 2120 (F5, 345 pc) is a distant triple system. The outer 68 pair ES 123 is physical, based on the common distances and RVs (the PMs are very small). Its secondary component B is a single-lined binary with days. We also observed the component C at 42″ separation. Its RV, as well as PM, are distinct, so the star C is unrelated (optical).
GQ Leo (TYC 870-798-1, K5Ve, 61 pc) has a slowly variable RV. Its mean value of km s*-1* differs from km s*-1* measured by Gaia and from 3 RVs around km s*-1* reported by Griffin (2005). An orbit with d and km s*-1* can be fitted to all RVs. However, alternative periods are not excluded, so we refrain from publishing this tentative orbit. The object is a 025 pair MET 57Aa,Ab with an estimated period of 45 years, so some RV variation could be caused by this binary. WDS lists another companion at 95, which is optical according to the Gaia astrometry.
HIP 57857 (G148-14, K0V, 54 pc) has a variable RV, but our data are insufficient for orbit determination. Astrometric acceleration is evident from comparison of the average PM of mas yr*-1* deduced from the difference of Hipparcos and Gaia positions with the “instantaneous” PM measured by Gaia: mas yr*-1*. The 43 pair LEP 46 is physical according to Gaia PM and parallax, so this is a triple system. The component B has an RV of (Gaia) km s*-1* and its PM matches the average PM of A.
HIP 57949 (MCC 622, M0.5Ve, 31 pc) also has a variable RV, likely with a long period.
HIP 59000 (HD 105065, K5V, 23 pc) is a triple or quadruple system. The outer 183″ binary (estimated period 300 kyr) is physical. The main star is an acceleration binary. Our single RV measurement, km s*-1* , differs from the Gaia RV of km s*-1* . The large error of the latter also signals variability. Two mutually discordant RVs were measured by Maldonado et al. (2010). It is not clear whether the spectroscopic and astrometric subsystems are same or distinct.
HIP 60433 (BD+21 2415, K4V, 40 pc) and HIP 60448 (MCC 654, K5V, 30 pc) both have variable RVs, but no orbits were computed. The first is also an acceleration binary. Both stars have 18 years of RV coverage.
HIP 61436 (GJ 9412, K5V, 30 pc) is a double-lined binary with d.
HIP 62505 (HD 111312, K2V, 26 pc) is a close visual and spectroscopic binary WSI 74 with a period of 2.66 yr. Its combined orbit was determined by Tokovinin (2017). Another visual companion at 27 was measured by Hipparcos, but never confirmed; it is not spotted by Gaia and therefore remains questionable.
HIP 62755 was originally mis-identified with a nearby K6V dwarf MCC 679. The Gaia parallax of mas places HIP 62755 among giants. We determined an orbit with years from 11 RVs covering 8.2 years.
HIP 63253 (GJ 490, M0V, 21 pc) has an RV trend, so the period is longer than 7 years. This is a 2+2 quadruple system. The outer 16″ pair has a period of 6 kyr. Both components were resolved into 01 pairs with estimated periods of a few years. The observed RV variation is most likely related to the subsystem Aa,Ab.
HIP 63816 (GJ 497, M0V, 16 pc) is a 16 visual binary WOR 23. We find its RV constant over a time span of 7 years.
HIP 63942 (BD+21 2486, K4V, 19 pc) has a constant RV. This is a visual binary HU 739 with an orbital period of 431 years and a semimajor axis of 265.
HIP 65012 (GJ 507B, M3V, 14 pc) is the secondary component B of HIP 65011 (at 178 distance) which itself is a visual and spectroscopic pair with d. We measured RV(B) once, km s*-1* ; Gaia measured it at km s*-1* .
HIP 65026 (HD 115953, K0, 9 pc) is a remarkable triple system. The outer 15 binary HU 644 has a good-quality visual orbit with a period of 49 yr. The inner subsystem Aa,Ab is also resolved as CHR 193 at 01. Here we determined its single-lined orbit with a period of 447 d. A preliminary period of 450 d was announced by Beuzit et al. (2014). A preliminary combined orbit of the inner subsystem shows that the mutual inclination in this triple system is small.
HIP 65327 (HD 238224, K5V, 24 pc) was resolved by Hipparcos at 03 separation and mag. We computed its single-lined orbit with years. However, the RV amplitude is likely reduced by line blending. A combined visual/spectroscopic orbit can be computed now. WDS also mentions the wide CPM pair SHY 67 with a separation of 94, too wide to be a bound binary.
GJ 513 (M3V, 19 pc) has a slowly variable RV.
HIP 65887 (HD 117466, K0, 3 kpc) is a distant giant for which we provide a single-lined orbit with a 3.3-year period. Its semimajor axis should be 11 mas, and, indeed, the astrometric acceleration was detected by Hipparcos.
**HIP 66290 ** (HD 118244, F5V, 38 pc) is a single-lined binary with a period of 5.4 years, as well as acceleration binary. The orbit is determined from 36 RVs measured during 23 years.
HIP 67086 (K5, 46 pc) is a 06 binary resolved by Hipparcos (estimated period 100 yr) containing a spectroscopic subsystem. We measured RVs of both components with VUES and determined the orbit of the secondary subsystem Ba,Bb with d.
BD+26 2498 is a G5 giant with the DR2 parallax of mas. Our 31 RVs measured during 18 years securely define the spectroscopic orbit with a period of 4.2 years. This orbit corresponds to the minimum secondary mass of 1 . The secondary component could be a compact remnant. Gaia is expected to detect acceleration or deliver a full astrometric orbit.
HIP 67808 (BD+13 2721, K7V, 22 pc) is a 02 visual (and acceleration) binary with an estimated period of 10 years discovered by Beuzit et al. (2014). Our 6 RVs measured during 7 years are probably constant, with one measure deviating from the rest.
BD+19 2735 (K2, 37 pc) is a single-lined binary with a period of almost 10 years; 1.5 orbital cycles of its eccentric orbit are covered. Rotational modulation was measured by Kiraga (2012).
**HIP 68801 ** (HD 123034, G5, 51 pc) is a double-lined binary with a circular 2.8-day orbit and a mass ratio (a twin). Nordström et al. (2004) discovered the RV variability but provided no orbit.
**HIP 69549 ** (HD 124605, G0, 85 pc) is a double-lined pair with d and nearly equal components, . The interferometric pair 008 TOK 723 with mag remains unconfirmed and could be spurious; its parameters are similar to the optical ghosts reported in the discovery paper by Tokovinin et al. (2018). If it were a triple system, the outer period would be around 10 yr. However, we do not see any modulation of the center-of-mass velocity during 19 years covered by our data.
HIP 72508 (HR 5537, F5IV, 52 pc) has double lines, but the period is not known yet. The WDS companion B at 15″ is optical according to its Gaia astrometry. However, Gaia detected another faint ( mag) star at 92 separation with similar parallax and PM, so this system is at least triple.
BD+49 2364 is a giant, according to the Gaia parallax of mas. Its RV shows a trend and has changed by 5 km s*-1* . The orbital period is longer than the time span of our data, 29.5 years.
HIP 76941 (MCC 316, K5V, 50 pc) is a single-lined binary with d.
HIP 77141 (BD+36 2641, K4/5V, 54 pc) has a well-defined orbit with d and a very large (for this period) eccentricity of . Better coverage near periastron of this orbit is needed to constrain the eccentricity.
HIP 78158 (K5V, 52 pc) is a triple system that consists of the wide 187″ physical pair A,B (LDS 983) and the single-lined spectroscopic subsystem Aa,Ab discovered here. Its orbital period is 322 d. In some spectra we noted secondary dips, but their RVs do not match the orbit.
HIP 79796 (BD+55 1823, CR Dra, M5.6V, 20 pc) is a low-mass flare star and an interferometric binary BLA 3, for which an orbit with 4.04 yr period was computed by Tamazian et al. (2008). We see double lines, but their RVs do not match the visual orbit. A tentative RV curve with a period of 1.57 yr is plotted in Fig. 5. Shkolnik et al. (2010) obtained two double-lined spectra and determined that the period is less than 530 d. More work is needed to reconcile RVs with position measurements and, hopefully, to compute the combined orbit.
HIP 80751 (BD+24 3014, K5V, 32 pc) has a variable RV measured during 18 years. We determined a tentative orbit with yr, but its confirmation by new measurements and a better coverage are needed. Astrometric acceleration was detected.
BD+52 1968 (K8, 44 pc) is a 56 visual binary ES 968 (estimated period 3 kyr). The RV of the component A, measured 13 times with VUES, is certainly variable with a long period. The RV of B was measured only on one night and agrees with the mean RV of A.
**HIP 82506 ** (HD 152342, F4III, 67 pc) has a variable RV, but not enough data for orbit calculation. Is is also an astrometric binary.
BD+61 1678C (GJ 685, M1V, 14 pc) is the distant (738″) component to the visual pair A,B (GJ 684, HIP 86036, G0V) which has a period of 76 yr and the corresponding single-lined spectroscopic orbit. We monitored RV of the component C and found it constant, agreeing with the RV of A. The same conclusion was reached by Tokovinin (1992).
**HIP 90274 ** (HD 170527, K0, 175 pc) is a giant observed during 16 years. The spectrum has blended double lines, but no orbit is derived yet.
**HIP 91043 ** (HD 171488, V889 Her, G2V, 35 pc) has a double-lined spectrum and no spectroscopic orbit despite our 39 observations, mostly with unresolved CORAVEL dips. Several faint companions are listed in the WDS, but none of those is confirmed as physical.
HIP 92952 (G 229-18, M0V, 46 pc) is a quadruple system. The outer pair A,B (GIC 154) has a separation of 119″ and an estimated period of 300 kyr. The component A is a 04 visual binary Aa,Ab resolved by Hipparcos and not measured since; its estimated period is 70 years. We see double lines in the spectrum. Stationary lines correspond to the visual secondary Ab and the moving lines to the primary Aa, which is a spectroscopic binary Aa1,Aa2 with a period of 8 d. The eccentricity of the spectroscopic orbit is small, but statistically significant, . The RV of the star Ab is about km s*-1* . Its measurements are not accurate owing to blending with the lines of Aa1.
HIP 94557 (G 185-12, M4.5V, 18 pc) is the brighter component of the wide visual binary WDS J19147+1918 (LDS 2020, 41″). Our 3 RVs show variability. Shkolnik et al. (2012) measured a very different RV of km s*-1* , quoted in Simbad.
HIP 94622 (GJ 751, M0, 29 pc) has a variable RV, and some spectra have double lines. The RV variability was also noted by Tokovinin (1992). This is a Hipparcos binary with 02 separation and an estimated period of 10 yr. It is not clear whether the visual and spectroscopic systems correspond to the same pair or, alternatively, if it is a triple system.
BD+77 767 (K8, 41 pc) is a single-lined binary with d.
HIP 99969 (BD+06 4489, K4V, 44 pc) has double lines, but we are not yet able to determine its orbit.
HIP 101941 (HD 196928, K4III, 380 pc) is a single-lined binary with yr, as well as an astrometric binary.
HIP 102300 (M0Ve, 21 pc) has a variable RV. The period is longer than 8 yr covered by our data.
HIP 102320 (HD 335007, K5, 42 pc) belongs to a triple system where the outer 44 pair ES 366 has a period of the order of 2 kyr and mag. The main component A is a double-lined twin binary with d and equal components, . The orbital inclination of the spectroscopic pair is about 55°.
**HIP 102718 ** (BD+04 4551, F7Vw, 103 pc) is the primary component of WDS J20488+0512, a 66 pair. Its RV is likely constant.
**HIP 103375 ** (HD 235405, G0, 132 pc) belongs to WDS J20566+5250 (ADS 14465, A 1437, separation 13). Its RV is likely constant.
HIP 104994 (BD+28 4035, G5, 143 pc) is a triple-lined system. The outer 019 binary was first resolved by Hipparcos and not measured since; its period is 100 yr. Stationary lines in the spectrum belong to the visual secondary B with RV of km s*-1* . The pair of moving lines corresponds to the subsystem Aa,Ab with d and systemic velocity of km s*-1* . Its inclination is about 52°.
HIP 105504 (HD 358435, K7, 42 pc) definitely has a variable RV, but not enough data for an orbit. Its astrometric acceleration was detected.
BD+47 3439 (K0, 115 pc) is an evolved star in the visual triple system ADS 15052, with separations of 11 and 02. The spectra have double lines, but we could not yet figure out the orbit. Either there is an additional spectroscopic subsystem, or the inner binary is going through the periastron of its eccentric orbit (its estimated period is 80 years). The fact that Gaia DR2 measured the parallax favors the second option because partially resolved sources do not have parallaxes in DR2.
**HIP 110291 ** (HD 212029, G0, 62 pc) is a single-lined binary with a period of 2.1 yr. A similar period was determined by D. Latham (2012, private communication), while two astrometric orbits with periods of 2.07 and 2.17 yr and large eccentricities were computed by Goldin & Makarov (2006). WDS lists several optical companions.
HIP 110526 (GJ 826, M3.0V, 15 pc) has a constant RV over eight years of our monitoring. It is a visual binary WOR 11 with yr and semimajor axis 161.
**HIP 110978 ** (HD 213054, K2III, 800 pc) may have a mild RV trend over 34 days. It has astrometric acceleration.
HIP 111685 (BD+38 4818, M0Ve, 24 pc) is the main component of the triple system. The faint ( mag) outer component C is at 334 distance from the main star, with common PM and parallax. The inner pair A,B, first resolved by Hipparcos, has a well-defined visual orbit with yr. We fitted our RVs and all available positional measurements to a combined orbit and give here its spectroscopic elements.
HIP 111942 (GJ 870, K8V, 31 pc) is a single-lined binary with days. The orbit derived from our 20 RVs is very similar to the orbit published independently by Halbwachs et al. (2018) and based on 25 CORAVEL RVs. Here we list orbital elements fitted to the combined data, with global rms residual of 0.32 km s*-1* .
HIP 112040 (BD+18 5029, M0V, 31 pc) has a variable RV with a period longer than 15 yr, as well as astrometric acceleration.
HIP 112268 (BD+16 4806, K6V, 50 pc) has a variable RV. We computed an uncertain orbit with yr which is not publishable until a better coverage is obtained.
HIP 112523 (MCC 851, K5V, 37 pc) has a preliminary orbit with yr derived from 13 RVs spanning the period of 15 yr. The eccentricity was fixed in the orbit fitting. Astrometric acceleration was detected.
HIP 116003 (GJ 1284, M2Ve, 16 pc) is a flare star and an X-ray source. As our two RVs are very different from each other, it must be a fast spectroscopic binary. Variable RV was noted by Gizis et al. (2002).
BD+66 1664 (G5, 90 pc) is a single-lined binary with a circular 3-day orbit. Fast synchronous rotation is responsible for its high chromospheric activity.
HIP 118212 (GJ 913, K7V, 17 pc) is a single-lined binary with a period of 872 d (2.4 yr). It is also an acceleration binary and suspected non-single star in Hipparcos. One interferometric resolution at 62 mas with mag was reported by Balega et al. (2007). The astrometric orbit by Goldin & Makarov (2006) with d and is similar to our spectroscopic orbit. However, their revised parallax of 67 mas is not confirmed by Gaia.
4.4 The triple system HIP 13460
This star, also known as BD+60 585 and GJ 3185, is a K3V dwarf at 39 pc from the Sun. The spectrum is double-lined, and the period of 76 d is readily found. However, all 30 RVs cannot be fitted by the common elements, leaving residuals of 1.6 and 2.0 km s*-1* for Aa and Ab, respectively. Individual fits to the RVs measured with CORAVEL and VUES are better, but result in slightly different elements.
All RVs can be modeled better by assuming that the pair Aa,Ab moves slowly on an outer orbit. Astrometric acceleration reported by Makarov & Kaplan (2005) and confirmed by Gaia supports the triple-star hypothesis. We fitted the long-period orbit with km s*-1* using orbit3.pro (Fig. 6). The rms residuals to the triple-star solution are 0.88 km s*-1* for Aa and 3.23 km s*-1* for Ab. The component Ab may contain a short-period subsystem.
The masses of Aa and Ab estimated from the absolute magnitudes and the mass ratio are 0.78 and 0.71 . Comparison with the minimum masses leads to the inclination . The minimum mass of the tertiary component B is 0.29 . Although the semimajor axis of the outer orbit, computed from the period and mass sum, is 92 mas, there is little hope of resolving A,B directly owing to the expected faintness of B. On the other hand, Gaia can provide astrometric orbits of both inner and outer systems. To do so, an initial guess of the orbital periods and other parameters will likely be needed, and our work provides these parameters. It is unlikely that Gaia astrometry of this complex system can be interpreted correctly by its pipeline alone without additional inputs.
5 Summary
The main results of this work are:
- •
A large set of RV measurements spanning three decades.
- •
Determination of 57 spectroscopic orbits, 53 of those for the first time.
- •
Discovery of 20 new nearby hierarchical systems.
- •
Discovery of interesting stellar systems. For example, in the young triple HIP 47110 the inner orbit with d and is still circularizing, apparently.
Most orbits presented here refer to nearby K- and M-type dwarfs and result from the long-term RV monitoring. Our sample includes 857 stars from the McCormick catalog and 188 stars from the Gliese catalog. Observational data on this sample are given in Table 4 of Sperauskas et al. (2016). A total of 67 spectroscopic orbits are known for these stars, including 35 determined here. In addition, there are 70 stars with variable RV without orbital elements identified from our data, from the literature (e.g. Halbwachs et al., 2018), or by comparing our RVs with those from Gaia DR2. The latter group counts 30 objects where the RV difference exceeds 2.5 km s*-1* (3). For stars with constant RV, the mean RV difference between our CORAVEL and Gaia RVs is 0.21 km s*-1* with the rms scatter of km s*-1* . Figure 7 illustrates the contribution of this work to the census of spectroscopic binaries among K- and M-dwarfs.
We continue observations of the identified RV variables with the VUES spectrograph in order to detect double-lined spectroscopic binaries among them and to calculate their orbital parameters. Such type of stars may not be recognized by Gaia due to rather low resolution of its spectrometer.
Acknowledgements.
It is a pleasure to thank an anonymous referee for careful reading and valuable comments. We used the Simbad service operated by the Centre des Données Stellaires (Strasbourg, France). This work also made use of data from the European Space Agency (ESA) mission Gaia333https://www.cosmos.esa.int/gaia, processed by the Gaia Data Processing and Analysis Consortium (DPAC, https://www.cosmos.esa.int/web/gaia/dpac/consortium). Funding for the DPAC has been provided by national institutions, in particular the institutions participating in the Gaia Multilateral Agreement.
The reference list from the paper itself. Each links out to its DOI / PubMed record.
- 1Albareti et al. (2017) Albareti, F. D., Allende Prieto, C., & Almeida, A. 2017, Ap JS, 233, 48
- 2Alonso-Floriano et al. (2015) Alonso-Floriano, F. J., Caballero, J. A., Cortès-Contreras, M., Solano, E., & Montes, D. 2015, A&A, 583, 85
- 3Balega et al. (2007) Balega, I. I., Balega, Y. Y., Maksimov, A. F., et al. 2007, Astrophys. Bull., 62, 339
- 4Baranne et al. (1979) Baranne, A., Mayor, M., & Poncet, J. L. 1979, Vistas in Astron., 23, 279
- 5Beuzit et al. (2014) Beuzit, J.-L., Ségransan, D., Forveille, T., et al. 2014, A&A, 425, 997
- 6Bressan et al. (2012) Bressan, A., Marigo, P., Girardi, L., et al. 2012, MNRAS, 427, 127
- 7Chanamé & Ramirez (2012) Chanamé, J. & Ramirez, I. 2012, Ap J, 746, 102
- 8Fekel & Marschall (1991) Fekel, F. C. & Marschall, L. A. 1991, AJ, 102, 1439
