Fine structure in the $\alpha$ decay of $^{223}$U

TL;DR

This study observed fine structure in the alpha decay of uranium-223, identifying decay branches and updating decay energy and half-life, while discussing nuclear structure evolution and deformation effects in isotones.

Contribution

It reports the first observation of fine structure in $^{223}$U alpha decay, with precise energy and half-life measurements, and insights into nuclear shape evolution.

Findings

Alpha decay branches to ground and excited states identified.

Alpha particle energy for $^{223}$U decay measured at 8993 keV.

Half-life of $^{223}$U updated to 62 microseconds.

Abstract

Fine structure in the $\alpha$ decay of $^{223}$U was observed in the fusion-evaporation reaction $^{187}$Re($^{40}$Ar, p3n) by using fast digital pulse processing technique. Two $\alpha$-decay branches of $^{223}$U feeding the ground state and 244 keV excited state of $^{219}$Th were identified by establishing the decay chain $^{223}$U $\xrightarrow{\alpha_{1}}$ $^{219}$Th $\xrightarrow{\alpha_{2}}$ $^{215}$Ra $\xrightarrow{\alpha_{3}}$ $^{211}$Rn. The $\alpha$-particle energy for the ground-state to ground-state transition of $^{223}$U was determined to be 8993(17) keV, 213 keV higher than the previous value, the half-life was updated to be 62$^{+14}_{-10}$ $\mu$s. Evolution of nuclear structure for $N$ = 131 even-$Z$ isotones from Po to U was discussed in the frameworks of nuclear mass and reduced $\alpha$-decay width, a weakening octupole deformation in the ground state of $^{223}$U relative to its lighter isotones $^{219}$Ra and $^{221}$Th was suggested.

Tables

Table 1. Table 1: Rows 2 and 3: Two α 𝛼 \alpha -decay branches of 223 U observed in this study. The α 𝛼 \alpha -particle energy ( E α subscript 𝐸 𝛼 E_{\alpha} ), half-life ( T 1 / 2 subscript 𝑇 1 2 T_{1/2} ), intensity ( I α subscript 𝐼 𝛼 I_{\alpha} ), reduced α 𝛼 \alpha -decay width ( δ 2 superscript 𝛿 2 \delta^{2} ) and hindrance factor (HF) for each branch of 223 U, and α 𝛼 \alpha -particle energies and half-lives for the daughters 219 Th and 215 Ra, are listed. Our results are compared with the literature values  [ 16 , 17 ] shown in the last row. The new half-life 62 − 10 + 14 subscript superscript absent 14 10 {}^{+14}_{-10} μ 𝜇 \mu s of 223 U was used for δ 2 superscript 𝛿 2 \delta^{2} and HF calculations. See text for more information.

Branch	na)	$E_{\alpha }$(223U)	$I_{\alpha }$	${\delta }^2$	HF	$E_{\alpha }$(219Th)	$E_{\alpha }$(215Ra)	$T_{1/2}$(223U)	$T_{1/2}$(219Th)	$T_{1/2}$(215Ra)
		[keV]	[%]	[keV]		[keV]	[keV]	[$\mu$s]	[$\mu$s]	[ms]
1	17-11-9	8753(16)	65(20)	198(61)	1.6(5)	9340(18)	8695(4)	50${}_{-10}{}^{}{}_{}{}^{+16}$	0.75${}_{-0.15}{}^{}{}_{}{}^{+0.24}$	1.50${}_{-0.35}{}^{}{}_{}{}^{+0.65}$
2	9-6-7	8993(17)	35(13)	25(9)	12(5)	9336(18)	8693(4)	78${}_{-20}{}^{}{}_{}{}^{+39}$	1.24${}_{-0.31}{}^{}{}_{}{}^{+0.62}$	1.60${}_{-0.40}{}^{}{}_{}{}^{+0.80}$
All	26-20-24	-	-	-	-	9338(16)	8696(3)	62${}_{-10}{}^{}{}_{}{}^{+14}$	0.94${}_{-0.15}{}^{}{}_{}{}^{+0.21}$	1.51${}_{-0.26}{}^{}{}_{}{}^{+0.40}$
Lit.	-	8780(40)	100	178(32)	1.1(2)	9340(20)	8700(5)	18${}_{-5}{}^{}{}_{}{}^{+10}$	1.05(3)	1.66(2)

Full text

††journal: Physics Letters B

1 Introduction

Light actinide nuclei with neutron number $N$ $\sim$ 134 are susceptible to effects of octupole deformation [1, 2]. Alpha decay is long known as one of the tools to search for the effects of octupole correlations in nuclei. In particular, the first experimental evidence for octupole deformation in the actinides came from fine structure $\alpha$ decays feeding low-lying 1- and 3- states in the $A$ = 220-224 isotopes of Ra [3] and Rn [4]. Static or dynamic octupole deformations were expected to exist in light actinides with mass number $A$ between 219 and 229 [5]. The strongest octupole coupling for actinides was supposed to occur at $Z$ $\sim$ 88 and $N$ $\sim$ 134 [2], heavier than the doubly magic nucleus 208Pb in the chart of the nuclides. When going towards 222Ra from 208Pb, nuclear ground-state shape undergoes three phases: spherical, quadrupole-octupole and quadrupole deformed shapes. The $N$ = 131 isotones are situated in a transitional region between $N$ = 126 spherical and $N$ = 134 octupole deformed nuclei.

The $N$ = 131 isotones of $Z$ = 84 and 86, i.e., 215Po and 217Rn, have nearly spherical ground states with Jπ = 9/2*+*, corresponding to the odd neutron in the $\nu g_{9/2}$ orbital. In the $\alpha$ decay of 215Po and 217Rn, ground-state to ground-state transition comprises nearly 100% of the total $\alpha$-decay intensity, reflecting the remarkable similarity between the parent and daughter configurations.

In heavier $N$ = 131 isotones 219Ra ($Z$ = 88) and 221Th ($Z$ = 90), experimentally fine structure in the $\alpha$ decays were observed. Onset of quadrupole-octupole correlations was predicted in the framework of the reflection-asymmetric rotor model [6]. Moreover, dynamic octupole correlations were indicated in the $\gamma$ spectroscopy in 219Ra [7] and 221Th [8].

Nonzero octupole deformation was predicted in the ground state of 223U ($Z$ = 92) by macroscopic-microscopic model [9], while the octupole-deformed minimum is not the lowest in energy according to covariant density functional theory [10]. Experimental study of 223U will shed new light on the shape evolution of $N$ = 131 and 129 ($\alpha$-decay daughter) isotones.

Isotope 223U was first identified by the Dubna group at the electrostatic separator VASSILISSA in the reaction of 208Pb(20Ne, 5n) [11]. Based on $\alpha$-$\alpha$ correlation technique and by searching for the decay chains of 223U $\xrightarrow{\alpha}$ 219Th $\xrightarrow{\alpha}$ 215Ra $\xrightarrow{\alpha}$ 211Rn, an $\alpha$-particle energy of 8780(40) keV and a half-life of 18${}^{+10}_{-5}$ $\mu$s were reported for 223U. The decay energy was extracted by subtracting the known $\alpha$-particle energy of 219Th from the sum energy (full pile-up) of $\alpha$ decays of 223U and its fast-decaying daughter 219Th ($T_{1/2}$ = 1.05 $\mu$s) measured by using traditional analog electronics.

In the present work, we report a new experimental study of 223U using a fast digital pulse processing technique which allows to clearly separate the fast sub-microsecond decays, which was the main difficulty in the previous studies. Thanks to the use of this method, fine structure in the $\alpha$ decay of 223U was observed for the first time. Structural evolution in $N$ = 129 and 131 isotones will be discussed in the framework of the reduced $\alpha$-decay width.

2 Experiment and results

The experiment was performed at the gas-filled recoil separator SHANS [12] at IMP (Lanzhou, China). Isotope 223U was produced in the fusion-evaporation reaction 187Re(40Ar, p3n) at a beam energy of 188 MeV with an average beam intensity of 320 pnA in 110 hours. Targets of 187Re with a thickness of 460 $\mu$g/cm2 were sputtered on 80 $\mu$g/cm2-thick carbon foils, which were facing the beam. Evaporation residues (ERs) were separated in-flight from the beam particles and implanted into a double-sided silicon strip detector (DSSD) with 48 horizontal and 128 vertical strips. The width of each strip was $\sim$1 mm, while the separation distance between them was $\sim$50 $\mu$m. Preamplifiers with fast rising time ($\sim$40 ns) were used in the experiment. Noise was reduced by cooling the preamplifiers and DSSD with (-6 to -15 ${}^{\textrm{o}}\textrm{C}$) alcohol and improving the grounding of the DAQ system. Details about the experimental setup can be found in Refs [13, 14].

In order to resolve short-lived products with lifetime $\leq$1 $\mu$s, a fast digital pulse processing technique was used in the experiment. Preamplified signals from each strip of DSSD were recorded in 15 $\mu$s-long traces (including nearly 2.5 $\mu$s baseline before the trigger point) with sampling frequency of 50 MHz [13]. Signals from the same strip with time difference shorter than $\sim$12 $\mu$s will pile up and are stored in a single trace. Amplitudes of pileup pulses were extracted by two algorithms according to the time differences $\bigtriangleup T$ between them, i.e., trapezoidal algorithm [15] for $\bigtriangleup T$ $\geq$ 0.5 $\mu$s and average difference algorithm [13] for $\bigtriangleup T$ $<$ 0.5 $\mu$s. Energy resolutions (FWHM) of all the vertical strips summed up for double/triple pileup events with time differences down to 0.5 $\mu$s and 0.2 $\mu$s were around 55 and 70 keV, respectively. For non-pileup $\alpha$-decay events, the energy resolution of DSSD was 22 keV.

Isotope 223U was unambiguously identified by establishing time-position correlated chains of 223U(ER) \underset{\text{18~{}\mu s}}{\overset{\text{\alpha_{1}}}{\longrightarrow}} 219Th \underset{\text{1.05~{}\mu s}}{\overset{\text{\alpha_{2}}}{\longrightarrow}} 215Ra \underset{\text{1.66~{}ms}}{\overset{\text{\alpha_{3}}}{\longrightarrow}} 211Rn, where the half-lives were taken from the quoted literature [16, 17]. Correlated implantation and $\alpha$-decay events were found in the same 1 $\times$ 1 mm2 pixel in DSSD. Due to the short half-life of 219Th, $\alpha_{1}$ and $\alpha_{2}$ signals will pile up. The digital pulse processing of the recorded traces allows to resolve the two overlapping decay signals, to determine their energies and the time difference between them. A two-dimensional plot of $\alpha$-$\alpha$ correlations is shown in Fig. 1, which includes all possible pairs of correlated decays whether the third one exists or not. The time window between recoil and $\alpha$ decay is 200 ns $\leq$ $\Delta T(ER-\alpha)$ $\leq$ 0.6 ms and that between any two $\alpha$ decays is 200 ns $\leq$ $\Delta T(\alpha-\alpha)$ $\leq$ 20 ms, selected to highlight the identification of 223U. Another point in Fig. 1 is that $\alpha$-$\alpha$ correlations of 220Th-216Ra (produced in the $\alpha$p2n evaporation channel) resemble some of 223U in the $\alpha$-particle energies. In such case, 223U was distinguished from 220Th by the $\alpha$ decay of the granddaughter 215Ra or by the half-lives of parent ($T_{1/2}$(223U) = 18 $\mu$s and $T_{1/2}$(220Th) = 9.7 $\mu$s) and daughter ($T_{1/2}$(219Th) = 1.05 $\mu$s and $T_{1/2}$(216Ra) = 182 ns) nuclei if the third $\alpha$ particle escaped.

Besides the full-energy $\alpha$ decays of 223U and its daughter products, some partial escapes of them were also included in the analysis, as shown in the summary of measured decay chains in Table 1. For partially escaping decays, the corresponding energies can not be used, but their timing information is intact. Thirty-four $\alpha$-decay events were attributed to 223U. For eight of them, only partial energies of $\alpha$ particles emitted from 223U were recorded, but their daughters or granddaughters are full energy decays.

The $\alpha$ spectra of isotopes 223U, 219Th and 215Ra identified in these $\alpha$-decay chains are shown in Fig. 2. Three $\alpha$ peaks at 8753(16), 8898(18) and 8993(17) keV are observed in 223U as shown in Fig. 2 (a), with intensities of 46(15)%, 19(9)% and 35(13)%, respectively, where the errors are from the statistical only. However, as will be shown below, some of these intensities will need to be corrected for the possible effect of $\alpha$ + e- summing. One 8212 keV (in vertical strip of DSSD) $\alpha$-decay event of 223U was attributed to a crosstalk, because a 8602 keV energy produced by the same event in horizontal strip was recorded. Moreover, based on GEANT4 Monte Carlo simulations, the 8212 keV event is very unlikely to result from partially escaping 8753, 8898 and 8993 keV $\alpha$ particles, as in the region of (8212 $\pm$ 70) keV only 0.03 event is expected corresponding to the 26 full energy events of these three peaks. The $\alpha$-particle energies for 219Th and 215Ra were determined to be 9338(16) and 8696(3) keV, respectively, consistent with literature values.

Half-lives for the 8753, 8898 and 8993 keV $\alpha$ peaks of 223U were extracted to be 60${}^{+24}_{-13}$, 28${}^{+23}_{-9}$ and 78${}^{+39}_{-20}$ $\mu$s, respectively, by taking into account types of $\alpha_{1}$-$\alpha_{2}$-$\alpha_{3}$, $\alpha_{1}$-$\alpha_{2}$, $\alpha_{1}$-$\alpha_{3}$, and $\alpha_{2}$-$\alpha_{3}$ correlations. Due to their very low statistics, the errors of half-lives were calculated using the maximum likelihood method described in Ref. [18]. These half-lives are consistent within the error bars. So all these three $\alpha$-decay groups are assigned as originated from the ground-state decay of 223U, feeding different levels of 219Th. Combining all the thirty-four events together, the half-life of 223U was determined to be 62${}^{+14}_{-10}$ $\mu$s, larger than the previous measurement [11]. The decay scheme of 223U is shown in Fig. 3. To determine the excitation energies of the populated levels in 219Th, $Q_{\alpha}$ values of 223U were calculated.

In the previous measurements of 223U using analog electronics [11], a single $\alpha$-decay branch at 8780 keV was reported based only on the full-energy summing signals from 223U + 219Th decay. This $\alpha$-particle energy seemed to be a ground-state to ground-state transition as the evaluation in the latest A = 223 Nuclear Data Sheets [17]. Our new results suggest that the 8780 keV value most likely corresponds to the strongest 8753 keV ground-state to 244 keV excited state transition in this work.

A comment on the 8898 keV decay, which would establish an excited state at 97 keV in 219Th, should be presented here. We cannot exclude that this peak is due to the summing of the 8753 keV $\alpha$ particle with the subsequent conversion electron, originated from internal conversion of the 244 keV $\gamma$-ray transition. Indeed, if $\alpha$ decay feeds a low-lying excited state, which de-excites by a strongly converted $\gamma$-ray transition, a well-known effect of energy summing of $\alpha$ decay and subsequent conversion electron can happen, if both $\alpha$ particle and conversion electron are measured in the DSSD [19, 20]. This would lead to the appearance of ‘artificial’ summing $\alpha$ lines in the spectra. The total conversion coefficients of the 244 keV transition are: $a_{tot}$(M1) = 1.5, $a_{tot}$(E1) = 0.06 and $a_{tot}$(E2) = 0.33 [21]. Therefore, in case of E1 or E2 multipolarity, the conversion of the 244 keV transition is negligible, thus no $\alpha$(8753 keV) + e- summing can be observed, and the 8898 keV will be a real $\alpha$ peak. For M1 the K-conversion is dominant ($a_{K}$(M1) = 1.19), resulting in K-electron energy of 134 keV. The $\alpha$(8753 keV) + e-(134 keV) summing would indeed give rise to a summing peak around 8887 keV, close to the observed peak at 8898 keV.

Based on the GEANT4 Monte Carlo simulations for $\alpha$ + e- summing in DSSD (see Fig. 4), we estimated that the whole $\sim$8898 keV decay can be explained as an artificial peak being due to $\alpha$(8753 keV) + e- summing of the 134 keV conversion electron from the 244 keV transition if it is of pure M1 multipolarity. In the simulation, ratio between source intensities of electron and $\alpha$ particle was set to be 0.54, defined by the conversion coefficient $a_{K}$(M1) = 1.19. A relative intensity of 26% between $\alpha$ + e- peak and pure $\alpha$ peak was obtained, which is nearly consistent with the experimental result 41(24)%. So there seems no level at 97 keV in 219Th and the intensity of the 8753 keV $\alpha$ decay should be 65(20)%111The earlier extracted half-life of 223U should not be affected by the conversion-electron process, which is assumed to be comparatively short., where the reported error is statistical only, see Table 1. We will return to this issue in the Discussion section. Moreover, since the known lowest excited states of $N$ = 129 isotones 215Rn and 217Ra are above 200 keV, the 97 keV excited state of 223U seems too low.

3 Discussion

To understand the observed fine structure decays of 223U, we also show the $\alpha$-decay schemes of $N$ = 131 isotones 219Ra and 221Th in Fig. 3. These two isotones are located at the edge of the region where octupole deformation was predicted [9]. A 7/2+ ground state was reproduced for each of 219Ra and 221Th by reflection-asymmetric rotor model [6] at $\beta_{2}$ = $\beta_{3}$ = 0.1 deformation.

Spins and parities have been tentatively assigned to the populated excited states in 215Rn [17] and 217Ra [22]. Even though (7/2)+ and (11/2+) are assigned to the 315 keV level in 215Rn and 333 keV level in 217Ra, respectively, both spins are possible for each of them. The possible spins of the 315 keV state in 215Rn are (7/2, 11/2)+ according to the measured $\gamma$ transition mode [23, 24], the same applies for the 333 keV state in 217Ra. Decays to these two levels are weakly hindered with HF $<$ 5, implying similar configuration between initial and final states. The (7/2+) and (11/2+) assignments were interpreted to be of octupole configuration in the reflection-asymmetric rotor model, while in the shell model framework they were supposed to be originated from the same configuration $\nu g_{9/2}^{2}i_{11/2}$ [25]. Branches feeding the spherical 9/2+ ground states of 215Rn and 217Ra were strongly hindered with HF = 90 and 53, respectively, echoing the non-spherical octupole configuration of the ground states in 219Ra and 221Th.

In the $\alpha$ decay of 223U, the 8753 keV transition feeding the 244 keV (‘apparent intensity’ $I_{\alpha}$ = 46%) level in 219Th is unhindered and shows hindrance factor of 2.2. In case the 8898 keV peak is due to $\alpha$ + e- summing, as proposed in the previous section, the intensity of 8753 keV decay increases to 65%, leading to HF(8753 keV) = 1.6. We use this intensity value in Table 1 and Fig. 3. Thus in either scenario (with or without $\alpha$ + e- summing), the 8753 keV decay is unhindered. The 8993 keV ground-state to ground-state transition of 223U is hindered with HF = 12. Based on these HF values, spin of the ground state of 223U should be the same as that of the 244 keV excited state of 219Th, while is different from the (9/2+) ground state of 219Th. Based on the intensities and hindrance factors, (7/2+) and (7/2+, 11/2+) are tentatively assigned to the ground state of 223U and the 244 keV excited state of 219Th by following the systematics, respectively. These assignments are also beneficial to the discussion of the evolution of systematics.

In the in-beam $\gamma$ spectroscopy of 219Th [26], a 362 keV level with a tentative assignment of Jπ = (11/2+) was thought to correspond to the (11/2+) level at 333 keV in 217Ra. This level was observed in both $\alpha$ decay and in-beam $\gamma$ spectroscopy, while the 362 keV level in 219Th was observed only in the in-beam $\gamma$ spectroscopy. Because fusion-evaporation reactions like that in Ref. [26] are tend to populate near-yrast levels whereas the $\alpha$-decay don’t, it is possible both the 362 and 244 keV levels exist in 219Th. Another possible explanation is the onset of structure change in the ground state of 223U.

The mass of 223U was deduced from the ground-state to ground-state $Q_{\alpha}$ obtained in the present work. In Fig. 5, the experimental masses of $N$ = 131 isotones up to 223U were compared with two versions of theoretical calculations, one taking into account the octupole correlations [9] while another not [27]. For 219Ra($Z$ = 88) and heavier isotones, the theoretical masses with octupole correlations around $\beta_{3}$ = -0.134 [9] become favorable and reproduce the experimental data better, suggesting the onset of octupole deformation at $Z$ = 88. Until to $Z$ = 92, both models do equally poor job for 223U, the weakening of octupole deformation is implied.

To understand the evolution of nuclear structure, reduced $\alpha$-decay width ($\delta^{2}$) is used. It can probe the overlap between the wave functions of the initial and final states of $\alpha$ decay. It is calculated using the relation $\lambda$ = $\delta^{2}P/h$ [28, 29], where $\lambda$ is the measured partial decay constant, $h$ is the Planck’s constant and $P$ is the penetration probability of $\alpha$ particle with angular momentum $L$ through the Coulomb and centrifugal barriers. The reduced $\alpha$-decay widths for $N$ = 131 and 129 isotones are shown Fig. 6. No obvious fine structure are observed in the $\alpha$ decays of the $N$ = 129 isotones and their reduced widths remain nearly constant around 80 keV, reflecting similar spherical $\nu g_{9/2}$ configurations in the ground states of $N$ = 129 parents and $N$ = 127 daughters.

For the first two $N$ = 131 isotones, 215Po and 217Rn (see Fig. 6 (a)), the ground-state to ground-state decays proceed between the $\nu g_{9/2}$ configurations with $\delta^{2}$ values of $\sim$100 keV, in agreement with the very similar spherical structures between parent and daughter nuclei. From $Z$ = 88 on, fine structure with competing branches appear and the reduced widths for the ground-state to ground-state transitions drop suddenly. Decays of 219Ra and 221Th show strong hindrance with $\delta^{2}$ $\sim$ 5 keV, indicating very different structure between the ground states of parent and daughter nuclei. New $\delta^{2}$ value for the ground-state to ground-state transition of 223U continues the rising trend in 219Ra and 221Th, but still shows hindrance with $\delta^{2}$ = 25 keV. If other assignment rather than (7/2+) to the ground state of 223U is used, the rising trend can not be changed. A reverse movement is revealed in the hindrance factors.

The rising trend of reduced $\alpha$-decay width for the ground-state transitions of $N$ = 131 isotones from $Z$ = 88 to 92, combining with the behavior of nuclear masses in Fig. 5, may indicate a weakening octupole deformation in the ground state of 223U.

The $\delta^{2}$ values for the most dominant branch with possible assignments of (7/2*+,11/2+*) are shown in Fig. 6 (a), the relative large values imply that octupole correlations are developing in the excited levels of the $N$ = 129 daughter nuclei. This is in agreement with the evidences of octupole deformation in the in-beam $\gamma$-spectroscopy studies of 217Ra [30, 31] and 219Th [26].

4 Summary and outlook

Two $\alpha$-decay branches of 223U feeding the ground state and 244 keV excited state of 219Th are reported. An $\alpha$-particle energy of 8993 keV and a half-life of 62${}^{+14}_{-10}$ $\mu$s are assigned to the ground-state decay of 223U. Evolution of nuclear structure for $N$ = 131 isotones is discussed in terms of nuclear mass and reduced $\alpha$-decay width, structure in the ground state of 223U may go through a weakening octupole deformation relative to its lighter isotones 219Ra and 221Th.

5 Acknowledgements

The authors would like to thank the accelerator crew of HIRFL for providing the stable 40Ar7+ beam of high intensity. This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant Nos. 11635003, 11675225, U1632144, 11405224, 11435014, 11505035 and 11375017), the National Key R&D Program of China (Contract No. 2018YFA0404400), the Hundred Talented Project of the Chinese Academy of Sciences and the Key Research Program of the Chinese Academy of Sciences (Grant No. XDPB09), Science and Technology Facilities Council (STFC) of the United Kingdom.