Chemical analysis of CH stars - III: Atmospheric parameters and elemental abundances
Meenakshi Purandardas, Aruna Goswami, Partha Pratim Goswami, J., Shejeelammal, Thomas Masseron

TL;DR
This study provides detailed chemical abundance analyses of 12 potential CH stars, expanding the scarce data available and identifying their metallicity, carbon enrichment, and classification, which aids understanding stellar nucleosynthesis.
Contribution
First-time abundance analysis for four stars and detailed chemical profiling of 12 CH star candidates, creating a homogeneous elemental abundance database.
Findings
CD-28 1082 is a very metal-poor, carbon-rich CEMP-r/s star.
HD 30443 and CD-38 2151 exhibit properties of CH stars.
Some objects show spectral features typical of barium stars.
Abstract
Elemental abundances of CH stars can provide observational constraints for theoretical studies on the nucleosynthesis and evolution of low- and intermediate-mass stars. However, available abundance data in literature are quite scanty. In our pursuit to generate a homogeneous database of elemental abundances of CH stars we have performed a detailed chemical abundance study for a sample of 12 potential CH star candidates based on high resolution spectroscopy. We present first time abundance analysis for the objects HE 0308-1612, CD-28 1082, HD 30443, and HD 87853. For the other objects, although limited information is available, detailed chemical composition studies are missing. Our analysis shows CD-28 1082 to be a very metal-poor object with [Fe/H] = -2.45 and enriched in carbon with [C/Fe] = 2.19. With a ratio of [Ba/Eu] ~ 0.02 the star satisfies the classification criteria of a…
| Wavelength(Å) | Element | (eV) | log gf | HD 30443 | HE 0308-1612 | HD 87853 | References |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4114.446 | Fe I | 2.831 | - | - | - | 1 | |
| 4139.927 | 0.990 | - | - | - | 1 | ||
| 4147.669 | 1.485 | - | - | 83.6(6.82) | 1 | ||
| 4184.891 | 2.831 | - | - | 83.8(6.79) | 1 | ||
| 4187.039 | 2.449 | - | - | 108.4(6.78) | 1 |
| Wavelength(Å) | Element | (eV) | log gf | CD 1082 | HD 29370 | CD 2151 | HD 50264 | HD 87080 | HD 123701 | HD 176021 | HD 188985 | HD 202020 | Reference |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5682.633 | Na I | 2.102 | - | 129.7(6.32) | - | - | 70.2(5.92) | - | 54.5(5.81) | - | 93.2(6.41) | 1 | |
| 5889.951 | 0.000 | 0.100 | 166.7(4.56) | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | 1 | |
| 6154.226 | 2.102 | - | - | - | - | - | 55.6(6.36) | - | - | 35.2(6.35) | 1 | ||
| 6160.747 | 2.104 | - | - | - | - | 30.2(5.79) | 76.8(6.38) | 24.2(5.79) | - | 48.4(6.28) | 1 | ||
| 4571.096 | Mg I | 0.000 | 56.6(5.89) | - | 170.4(6.64) | 92.9(7.60) | - | - | 86.1(7.42) | - | 108(7.95) | 2 | |
| 4730.029 | 4.346 | - | - | - | 52.5(7.68) | - | - | - | 50.3(7.83) | 66.(7.95) | 3 |
Peer Reviews
No public reviews on file for this paper yet. If you reviewed it on a platform where reviews are public (OpenReview, ICLR, NeurIPS, ICML), you can paste yours below so the community can read it here.
Videos
No videos yet. Explain this paper in a talk, walkthrough, or lecture? Add one.
Chemical analysis of CH stars - III: atmospheric parameters and elemental abundances
Meenakshi Purandardas1,2, Aruna Goswami1 , Partha Pratim Goswami1, Shejeelammal J1, Thomas Masseron3,4
1Indian Institute of Astrophysics, Koramangala, Bangalore 560034, India; [email protected]
2 Department of physics, Bangalore university, Jnana Bharathi Campus, Karntaka 560056, India
3 Instituto de Astrofisica de Canarias, E-38205 La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain
4 Departamento de Astrofisica, Universidad de La Laguna, E-38206 La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain E-mail: [email protected]
( Accepted —; Received —; in original form — )
Chemical analysis of CH stars - III: atmospheric parameters and elemental abundances
Meenakshi Purandardas1,2, Aruna Goswami1 , Partha Pratim Goswami1, Shejeelammal J1, Thomas Masseron3,4
1Indian Institute of Astrophysics, Koramangala, Bangalore 560034, India; [email protected]
2 Department of physics, Bangalore university, Jnana Bharathi Campus, Karntaka 560056, India
3 Instituto de Astrofisica de Canarias, E-38205 La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain
4 Departamento de Astrofisica, Universidad de La Laguna, E-38206 La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain E-mail: [email protected]
( Accepted —; Received —; in original form — )
Abstract
Elemental abundances of CH stars can provide observational constraints for theoretical studies on the nucleosynthesis and evolution of low- and intermediate-mass stars. However, available abundance data in literature are quite scanty. In our pursuit to generate a homogeneous database of elemental abundances of CH stars we have performed a detailed chemical abundance study for a sample of 12 potential CH star candidates based on high resolution spectroscopy. We present first time abundance analysis for the objects HE03081612, CD281082, HD30443, and HD87853. For the other objects, although limited information is available, detailed chemical composition studies are missing. Our analysis shows CD281082 to be a very metal-poor object with [Fe/H]=2.45 and enriched in carbon with [C/Fe] = 2.19. With a ratio of [Ba/Eu]0.02 the star satisfies the classification criteria of a CEMP-r/s star. The objects CD382151 with [Fe/H]=2.03 and HD30443 with [Fe/H]{\sim}$$-1.68 are found to show the characteristic properties of CH stars. HE03081612 and HD87853 are found to be moderately metal-poor with [Fe/H]{\sim}$$-0.73; while HE03081612 is moderately enhanced with carbon ([C/Fe]0.78) and shows the spectral properties of CH stars, the abundance of carbon could not be estimated for HD87853. Among the two moderately metal-poor objects, HD87080 ([Fe/H]=0.48) shows near solar carbon abundance, and HD176021 ([Fe/H]=0.63 ) is mildly enhanced in carbon with [C/Fe]=0.52. HD176021 along with HD202020 a known binary, exhibit the characteristic properties of CH stars as far as the heavy element abundances are concerned. Five objects in our sample show spectral properties that are normally seen in barium stars.
keywords:
stars: abundances - stars: chemically peculiar - stars: carbon
††pagerange: LABEL:firstpage–LABEL:lastpage††pubyear: 2014
1 Introduction
In a recent study by Cristallo et al. (2016), a homogeneous set of abundance data from CH stars (Goswami et al. 2006; Goswami, Karinkuzhi & Shantikumar 2010; Karinkuzhi & Goswami 2014, 2015; Goswami, Aoki & Karinkuzhi 2016) are used in an attempt to constrain the physics and the nucleosynthesis occurring in low-mass AGB stars. The scope of enhancing such studies based on a larger homogeneous abundance data was highlighted. Particularly, the data corresponding to the lower metallicity regime were found to be scanty. In our efforts to provide tighter observational constraints we have undertaken to conduct chemical composition study for a larger sample selected from the CH star catalogue of Bartkevicius (1996), and our previous work (Goswami 2005, Goswami et al. 2007, 2010). In this work we report results for twelve objects. As will be shown later in detail, we have found two objects to be very metal-poor stars with [Fe/H] 2 and enhanced in carbon with [C/Fe] 1. Five objects exhibit characteristic properties of CH stars, and the other five show spectral properties that are normally seen in barium stars.
CH stars characterized by iron-deficiency and carbon enhancement (with 2 [Fe/H] , [C/Fe] 0.7, [Ba/Fe] 1.0) are a distinct group of stars (Keenan 1942) that are long been used as halo tracers. CEMP-s stars as defined in Beers & Christlieb (2005), classified as stars with [C/Fe] 1 and [Fe/H] 2 are more metal-poor counterparts of CH stars and believed to be extrinsically enriched with carbon and s-process elements. From observational evidences, CH stars are known to be binary systems (McClure 1983, 1984, McClure & Woodsworth 1990), with a now invisible white dwarf companion. Until recently, the CEMP-s stars with enhanced abundances of heavy s-process elements and carbon are also thought to be binary systems (Lucatello et al. 2005, Bisterzo et al. 2011, Starkenburg et al. 2014, Jorissen et al. 2016) and inferred to have a similar origin as that of the CH stars. However, based on a long-term campaign of precision radial-velocity monitoring of a sample of 22 CEMP-s and CEMP-r/s stars, Hansen et al. (2016) reported 18 of them (82 percent 26 percent) to be bonafide binary systems; the rest are either single or objects with extremely long period. If single, with carbon and barium enhancement these objects draw special attention for an intrinsic origin. Among many scenarios, the ones involving massive stars producing barium and other heavy elements through a weak s-process mechanism are suggested by many authors as possible mechanism(s) (Frischknecht et al. 2016, and references therein). These suggestions however require detailed investigation and larger samples are clearly desirable. The enhanced abundances of heavy elements observed in the (secondary) star of the CH binary star systems that are in the giant phase of evolution are attributed to a now invisible white dwarf companion (primary) which has evolved through the Asymptotic Giant Branch (AGB) phase. During the AGB phase the heavy elements were synthesized and the synthesized materials are transferred through mass transfer mechanisms to the secondary. Although the mass transfer mechanism(s) are not well understood despite several dedicated studies (e.g., Abate et al. 2013, 2015a,b, and references therein) the surface chemical composition of the secondaries can be used as important diagnostics for s-process nucleosynthesis in the primary.
The 12 CH star candidates analysed in this study cover a wide range in metallicity from near solar to [Fe/H] = 2.4. While CD 1082, and CD 2151 are found to be very metal-poor with [Fe/H] 2.0, HD 176021 and HD 87080 are found to be mildly metal-poor with metallicities 0.63 and 0.48 respectively. We have investigated anew the elemental abundances of two objects (HD 87080, HD 188985) previously studied by Allen & Barbuy (2006a) and another two objects (HD 29370, HD 123701) previously studied by de Castro et al. (2016) that allowed us to make a direct comparison with ours and verify our estimates. HD 87080 was also analysed by Pereira & Junqueira (2003); they found that iron group, -elements, manganese, as well as sodium and aluminium of HD 87080 follow the abundance pattern of the Galactic disk stars. Analysis of North, Berthet & Lanz (1994a,b) have confirmed HD 188985 to be a barium dwarf. We have also presented abundances for C, N, and O for these objects that were not reported in their previous studies. In section 2, we briefly describe the source of the spectra used in the present study and present estimates of radial velocities. Section 3 gives the estimates of photometric temperature. Section 4 describes the methodology used for determination of atmospheric parameters and estimates of the elemental abundances. This section also provides a discussion on the estimates of stellar masses and age of the programme stars. A comparison between the estimates obtained from spectra using VBT echelle and FEROS is presented in section 5. In section 6 we discuss the abundance analysis. In section 7, we discuss the kinematic analysis. stars are presented in section 8 and conclusions are drawn in section 9.
2 Observations and data reduction
For the objects HD 29370, CD38 2151, HD 50264, HD 87080, HD 123701, and HD 188985, high resolution ( 72000) spectra were obtained during 2018 March - May using the high resolution fiber fed Echelle spectrometer attached to the 2.34 m Vainu Bappu Telescope (VBT) at the Vainu Bappu Observatory (VBO), Kavalur. The wavelength coverage of these spectra spans from 4100 to 9350 Å with gaps between orders. The data-reduction is done following the standard procedures using IRAF111IRAF is distributed by the National Optical Astronomical Observatories, which is operated by the Association for Universities for Research in Astronomy, Inc., under contract to the National Science Foundation spectroscopic data reduction package. A few high-resolution spectra obtained with the FEROS (Fiber-fed Extended Range Optical Spectrograph) of the 1.52 m telescope of ESO at La Silla, Chile are also used in the present study. The wavelength coverage of FEROS spectra spans from 3500 - 9000 Å and the spectral resolution is 48000. For the objects HD 30443 and HE 03081612, the high resolution () spectra were obtained during 2017 November and 2018 January using the high-resolution fiber fed Hanle Echelle SPectrograph (HESP) attached to the 2 m Himalayan Chandra Telescope (HCT) at the Indian Astronomical Observatory, Hanle. The wavelength coverage of these spectra spans from 3530-9970 Å. Table 1 lists the basic data for the programme stars and details of the source of spectra. A few sample spectra are shown in Figure 1.
3 Photometric temperatures
The photometric temperatures of our programme stars are estimated using the calibration equations of Alonso, Arribas & Martinez-Roger(1999, 2001) and following the detailed procedures as given in our earlier papers (Goswami et al. 2006, 2016). As our programme star sample consists of both main-sequence stars and giants, we have made use of the corresponding calibration equations separately for each group. J, H, K magnitudes of the objects required for temperature estimates are taken from SIMBAD database which came from 2MASS (Cutri et al. 2003). We have used the estimated photometric temperatures as the initial guess for the estimation of spectroscopic temperature of the objects. The estimated photometric temperatures are presented in Table 2.
4 Spectroscopic stellar parameters
Equivalent widths of a set of clean and unblended Fe I and Fe II lines are used for the estimation of atmospheric parameters. The lines are selected to have the excitation potential in the range 0.0-5.0 eV and the equivalent widths in the range 20-180 mÅ. The number of Fe II lines measured is small in number as it is difficult to get clean Fe II lines in the spectra. We have made use of Local Thermodynamic Equilibrium (LTE) analysis of the measured equivalent widths using a recent version of MOOG of Sneden (1973). Model atmospheres used are selected from Kurucz grid of model atmospheres with no convective overshooting (http://cfaku5.cfa.hardvard.edu/). Solar abundances are adopted from Asplund, Grevesse & Sauval (2009).
A trend between the iron abundance derived from the Fe I lines and the excitation potential of these lines with a zero slope defines the effective temperature. The microturbulent velocity is taken to be that value for which the abundances derived from the Fe I lines do not show any dependence on the reduced equivalent width (). The surface gravity log g is determined corresponding to the adopted values of the effective temperature and microturbulent velocity for which Fe I and Fe II lines give near equal abundance values. The estimated abundances from Fe I and Fe II lines as a function of excitation potential and equivalent widths, respectively, are shown in figures that are made available as on-line materials. The derived atmospheric parameters are listed in Table 3.
We have estimated the mass of our programme stars from their postion in the HR diagram, log versus spectroscopic Teff plots (Figs 2-4). The visual magnitude V is taken from SIMBAD and the parallaxes are taken from Gaia (Gaia collaboration 2016, 2018b, https://gea.esac.esa.int/archive/) whenever possible. The bolometric corrections are determined separately for main-sequence and subgiants/giants using the empirical calibrations of Alonso et al.(1999). Interstellar extinction (Av) for objects with Galactic latitude b 50 degree are calculated based on formulae by Chen et al (1998). We made use of Girardi et al. (2000) database (http://pleiadi.pd.astro.it/) of evolutionary tracks to estimate the mass of the stars. For near solar objects evolutionary tracks corresponding to Z = 0.019 are chosen. Surface gravity log g is calculated from the estimated mass using the relation
log(g/g*⊙) = log(M/M⊙) + 4log(Teff*/Teff⊙) + 0.4(Mbol Mbol⊙)
The adopted values for the Sun are log g*⊙* = 4.44, Teff⊙ = 5770K, and Mbol⊙ = 4.75 mag (Yang et al. 2016).
We have also determined the age of our programme stars from their locations in the HR diagram. We have made use of the Girardi et al. (2000) database of isochrones. We used isochrones corresponding to z = 0.0004 for CD 1082, and z = 0.004 for HD 176021, HD 87080 and HD 87853. For objects with near solar metallicity, the isochrones corresponding to z = 0.019 are adopted. These are illustrated in Figures 5-7. The age estimates are presented in Table 4.
5 Comparison with literature
To verify our estimates measured from the VBT spectra we have analyzed anew the FEROS spectra of HD 87080 and HD 188985 which were previously studied by Allen & Barbuy (2006a,b), and HD 123701 and HD 29370 previously studied by de Castro et al. (2016) and compared their results with those obtained by us from VBT spectra. Our estimates of atmospheric parameters and metallicity for these stars match closely with those obtained by Allen & Barbuy (2006a,b) and de Castro et al. (2016) within the error limits. As a check to our estimates we have randomly selected a few lines, and performed spectrum synthesis calculation using our estimates of atmospheric parameters as well as the parameters obtained by Allen & Barbuy (2006a) and de Castro et al. (2016) for the respective stars. The fits match quite well. As an example we have shown the best fits obtained in a few cases (Fe I 5434.523 Å, Fe II 4620.521 Å and Ba II 5853.67 Å ) in Fig. 8. We have adopted our estimates for further analysis of the objects. Table 5 presents a comparison of our estimates with those of Allen & Barbuy (2006), de Castro et al. (2016) and other literature values. In Fig. 9, we have shown a comparison of VBT Echelle spectrum of CD38 2151 with the FEROS spectrum. The spectral features match well. Fig. 10 illustrates a comparison of equivalent widths measured in FEROS spectrum with those measured on VBT spectrum; the measurements match closely. Such comparisons were performed for all the stars for which both VBT and FEROS spectra are available; here for illustration purpose we have shown the comparison for one case.
6 ABUNDANCE ANALYSIS
Elemental abundances are measured using equivalent widths of good lines as well as using spectral synthesis calculation whenever applicable. Lines due to different elements are identified by overplotting the Arcturus spectra on the spectra of our programme stars. A master line list with the measured equivalent widths, and line information such as lower excitation potential and log gf values of the lines due to different elements considered for abundance estimates is prepared using the Kurucz database. Only symmetric and clean lines are considered for the measurement of equivalent widths. Abundances of light elements, C, N O, odd-Z element Na, and Fe-peak elements Mg, Si, Ca, Sc, Ti, V, Cr, Mn, Co, Ni and Zn are measured. Among the neutron-capture elements we have estimated the abundances of elements Sr, Y, Zr, Ba, La, Ce, Pr, Nd, Sm, and Eu. For elements Sc, V, Mn, Ba, La and Eu, we have also used spectrum synthesis calculation taking into account their hyperfine structures.
The abundance results are presented in Tables A1 through A4 and the lines used for the abundance determination are presented in Tables A5-A8.
6.1 Carbon, Nitrogen, Oxygen
Oxygen abundance is determined using spectrum synthesis calculation of the oxygen forbidden lines [OI] 6300.3 Å and 6363.8 Å lines for the objects CD38 2151, HD 30443, HD 123701, HD 202020. Some examples of spectrum synthesis fits are shown in Fig. 11. In case of the objects HD 188985, HD 50264, HD 87080 and HD 87853 where these lines could not be measured we have determined the oxygen abundance using spectrum synthesis calculation of the triplet lines around 7774 Å region (Fig. 12). These lines are influenced by non-LTE effects. Non-LTE corrections are estimated using the equation given in Bensby, Feltzing & Lundstrom (2004). The NLTE effects on oxygen triplet decreases in objects, such as K giants with higher gravities, and it vanishes for lines with equivalent widths below 45 mÅ (Eriksson & Toft 1979). As in most of the stars the O I triplet lines are found to be stronger with equivalent width slightly larger than 45 mÅ, and hence we have applied non-LTE corrections to the estimated abundances. Oxygen is found to be near solar in HD 188985, whereas it is underabundant in HD 202020 with [O/Fe] 0.33. For HD 50264 and HD 87080 the estimated [O/Fe] 0.37. Oxygen is moderately enhanced in HD 87853, HD 123701 and CD 2151. In the rest of the objects the oxygen lines are found to be blended and not usable for abundance estimates.
Abundance of carbon is determined from spectrum synthesis calculation of the wavelength region 5162 to 5176 Å, including the C2 bandhead at 5165 Å. In this wavelength region there are no molecular features due to MgH, CN bands. Atomic analysis of warm K and M dwarfs, shows that the molecular absorption is not strongly pronounced in spectra of stars at temperatures Teff 3500 K (Woolf and Wallerstein 2005). The molecular lines used for the synthesis is taken from Kurucz database. Spectrum synthesis fits for a few programme stars are shown in Fig. 13.
CD 1082, HD 30443 and CD 2151 show carbon enhancement with [C/Fe] 1 while HE 03081612 and HD 176021 are moderately enhanced with [C/Fe] 0.78 and 0.52, respectively. Abundance of carbon could not be estimated for HD 87853. In the remaining stars, [C/Fe] 0.23 or near solar.
The carbon isotopic ratio 12C/13C is determined from the spectrum synthesis calculation of the CN band at 8005 Å (Fig. 14). We could estimate 12C/13C ratios for six objects HE 03081612, CD 1082, HD 29370, HD 30443, CD 2151 and HD 123701; the values are 15.6, 16, 7.4, 9.3, 11.2 and 10, respectively. In the rest of the stars this band is found to be either too weak or absent. While in CD 2151, HD 30443 and HD 202020, C/O is found to be 1 as normally seen in CH stars, HD 50264, HD 87080, HD 123701 and HD 188985 show C/O 1.
Nitrogen is estimated using the spectrum synthesis calculation of the CN band at 4215 Å (Fig. 15). Nitrogen is enhanced in CD 1082 and CD 2151 with [N/Fe] 2.73 and 1.40, respectively. The rest of the stars show moderate enhancement in nitrogen relative to iron. HE 03081612 and HD 29370 show near solar values. Abundance of Nitrogen could not be estimated for HD 87853.
6.2 Na, Mg, Si, Ca, Sc, Ti, V
The estimated Na abundances lie in the range 0.07-0.78. While five objects, HD 29370, HD 87080, HD 123701, HD 176021 and HD 202020 show solar values. CD 28 1082 shows an enhancement with [Na/Fe] 0.78. Such an enhancement is not uncommon for stars at the metallicity of this star (Aoki et al. 2007). The lines used for abundance estimates are presented in Tables A7 and A8. We could not estimate the abundance of sodium in CD 2151, HD 50264 and HD 188985 as no suitable lines were found for abundance estimates.
Abundance of Mg is determined using lines Mg I 4571.10, 4730.03, 5172.684, 5528.405, and 5711.09 Å whenever possible using spectrum synthesis calculations. For all the stars, the lines used for abundance analysis have equivalent widths in the range 20 - 180 mÅ . In the case of HE 0308-1612 since only two Mg lines, Mg I 5528.405, and 4702.99 Å are found to be useful for abundance analysis, we have used both the lines although Mg I 5528.405 has equivalent width slightly larger than 180 mÅ (i.e., 190.6 mÅ ). In CD 1082, Mg is found to be enhanced with [Mg/Fe] 0.45. In CD 2151, this value is slightly higher with [Mg/Fe] 0.63. HD 87853 also shows a similar value with [Mg/Fe] 0.68. A value of 0.38 is obtained for HD 176021. For the rest of the objects we have obtained near solar values (Tables A1 - A4).
Abundance of Si is determined using lines, Si I 6145.02, 6155.13 and 6237.32 Å whenever possible. While HD 29370 and HD 87080 show a mild deficiency with [Si/Fe] = 0.36 and 0.44 respectively. CD 2151 and HD 30443 give values of [Si/Fe] = 1.62 and 0.82 respectively. In the rest of the objects abundance of Si could not be determined as no good lines were found for abundance determination.
Ca shows a mild enhancement of [Ca/Fe] = 0.27, 0.37, 0.29 in CD 1082, HE 03081612, HD 87853. Ca is also moderately enhanced in HD 30443 and CD 2151 with values 0.51 and 0.58 respectively. HD 176021 shows a near solar value, and for the remaining six objects the [Ca/Fe] lies in the range from 0.25 to 0.08.
Abundance of Sc determined using the equivalent width measurements of the lines Sc II 4431.35, 5239.81Å and 5526.79 Å give near solar values for CD38 2151 and HD 29370 with [Sc/Fe] 0.18 and 0.19 respectively. Spectrum synthesis of Sc II 6245.63 Å is used to estimate the abundance of Sc in HE 03081612, that gives [Sc/Fe] 0.53, and near solar values for HD 30443, HD 50264, HD 87080, HD 123701, HD 176021, and HD 202020. The objects HD 188985 and HD 87853 show mild deficiencies with [Sc/Fe] 0.21 and 0.39 respectively. The hyperfine structure of Sc is taken from Prochaska and McWilliam (2000). Abundance of Sc could not be measured in CD 1082 as no good lines were found for abundance determination.
Abundance of Ti is measured using the equivalent width measurements of several Ti I lines (Tables A7, A8). [Ti/Fe] covers a range 0.28 to 0.32, in these objects except for CD 2151 where [Ti I/Fe] is 0.71. The estimates of [Ti II/Fe] covers a range 0.28 to +0.42. We could not estimate abundance of Ti for CD 1082 as no good lines were found.
The abundance of V measured from V I 6119.52, and 6251.83 Å lines give a very high value with [V/Fe] 1.16 for CD 2151. The reason for such a high value is not understood. For HD 29370 and HD 123701 we get [V/Fe] values as 0.29 and 0.12. The spectrum synthesis calculation of the lines V I 5727.048, 5727.652, and 5737.06 Å taking hyperfine splitting into considerations returns [V/Fe] values 0.29, 0.64, 0.43 and 0.18 for HE 03081612, HD 30443, HD 176021 and HD 202020 respectively. Hyperfine structure is taken from Prochaska & McWilliam (2000). The abundance of V could not be estimated for the remaining four objects.
6.3 Cr, Co, Mn, Ni, Zn
The abundance of Cr is derived using equivalent width measurements of several Cr I lines; [Cr I/Fe] ranges from 0.39 to 0.30 in these objects. We could also estimate abundance of Cr using Cr II lines in HD 29370, HD 50264, HD 87080, HD 87853 and HD 176021; [Cr II/Fe] ranges from 0.18 to 0.03 in these objects. Cromium abundance could not be estimated for CD28 1082 and HD 30443.
The abundance of Mn is determined using the spectrum synthesis calculation of the Mn I 6013.51 Å considering the hyperfine structure from Prochaska & McWilliam (2000). CD 1082 shows a large enhancement of Mn with [Mn/Fe] 1.48. HD 30443 shows near solar value. HD 29370 and HD 176021 give a mild enhancement with [Mn/Fe] values 0.32 and 0.17 respectively. Spectrum synthesis calculation of Mn I 4041.355 Å gives a value 0.37 for HD 87853. Abundance of Mn derived using equivalent width measurements of lines, Mn I 4739.087, 4766.418 and 4783.427 Å is found to be 0.29 with respect to iron for HE 03081612. In the rest of the stars [Mn/Fe] ranges from 0.38 to 0.2.
Abundance of Co is measured using the Co I 4121.31, 4792.85, 4813.47, 5483.34 and 6632.43 Å lines whenever possible. For CD 2151, HD 30443, HD 87853 and HD 123701, abundance of Co is found to be near solar. For HD 176021 and HD 188985 [Co/Fe] values are found to be mildly enhanced with [Co/Fe] 0.29 and 0.33 respectively. For all other stars [Co/Fe] ranges from 0.01 to 0.11. The abundance of Co could not be estimated for HE 03081612 and CD28 1082 as no good lines could be measured.
Abundance of Ni is measured using several Ni I lines (Tables A7 and A8). [Ni/Fe] ranges from 0.59 to 0.13. The abundance of Ni could not be estimated for CD28 1082.
Abundance of Zn measured using only one line at 4810.53 Å gives near solar values for HD 29370, HD 87080, HD 87853 and HD 123701. For stars HD 30443, HD 50264, HD 87853, HD 176021, HD 188985, and HD 202020 the [Zn/Fe] values are found to lie in the range 0.21-0.40. HE 03081612 gives a value 0.19. We could not estimate the abundance of Zn for CD28 1082 and CD38 2151 as no good lines are available in their spectra.
6.4 Sr, Y, Zr
Abundance of Sr is determined from spectrum synthesis calculation of Sr I 4607.33 Å. Strontium is enhanced in most of the stars with [Sr/Fe] 1. In HD 29370 and HD 30443, Sr is moderately enhanced with [Sr/Fe] 0.82 and 0.74 respectively. A few examples of the spectrum synthesis fits for Sr is shown in Fig. 16. Abundance of Sr could not be estimated for HD 87853.
Abundance of Y is measured using several lines of Y II (Tables A7, A8). In HD 29370 and CD 2151 yttrium is enhanced with [Y/Fe] values 0.87 and 0.57 respectively. In HD 87853 yttrium is underabundant with [Y/Fe] 0.48. In all other stars yttrium is enhanced with [Y/Fe] 1.0; with highest enhancement seen in CD 1082 with [Y/Fe] 1.61.
Abundance of Zr is determined using the measured equivalent width of Zr II 4210.631 Å . Zr is found to be enhanced in HD 29370, CD 2151, HD 123701 and HD 202020 with [Zr/Fe] values 1.64, 2.0, 0.83 and 0.48 respectively. Spectrum synthesis calculation of Zr I 6134.59 Å gives [Zr/Fe] 1.60 for HD 30443. In the rest of the objects the abundance of Zr could not be estimated as no good lines of Zr was found.
6.5 Ba, La, Ce, Pr, Nd, Sm, Eu
The abundance of barium is determined from the spectrum synthesis calculation of the Ba II 5853.668 Å (Fig. 17) considering the hyperfine structure from McWilliam (1998). For HD 30443 we have used spectrum synthesis calculation of Ba II 6141.713 Å . Except for HD 87853 where barium is underabundant, all of our programme stars show Ba enhancement with [Ba/Fe] in the range 0.8-2.1.
Abundance of La is also determined from spectral synthesis calculation of La II 4921.778 Å with the hyperfine structure taken from Jonsell et al. (2006). La is overabundant in most of the stars with [La/Fe] ranging from 0.75 to 1.75. Abundance of La could not be estimated for HD 30443 and HD 87853.
The abundance of cerium is estimated using the equivalent width measurements of several Ce II lines (Tables A7, A8). The [Ce/Fe] values are found to lie in the 0.8-1.97. We could not estimate Ce abundance for HD 87853.
The abundance of Pr is measured using the equivalent width measurements of Pr II lines (A7, A8) that show enhancement in HE 03081612, CD28 1082, HD 30443, CD38 2151, HD 123701, and HD 87080 with [Pr/Fe] in the range 1.52-2.67. Abundance of Pr could not be measured for HD 29370, HD 50264, HD 87853, HD 176021, HD 188985 and HD 202020.
Abundance of Nd is measured using equivalent width measurements of several Nd lines (Tables A7, A8). Neodimium is found to be enhanced with [Nd/Fe] 1, in all the stars except for HD 87853 and HD 202020.
The abundance of Sm is measured using equivalent width measurements of a maximum of five samarium lines. Sm is enhanced in CD 1082 and HD 30443 with [Sm/Fe] 2.29 and 2.24 respectively. HE 03081612, HD 29370, CD 2151, HD 87080, HD 123701 and HD 176021 show enhancement with [Sm/Fe] in the range 1.41-1.68. Abundance of Sm could not be estimated for HD 50264, HD 87853, HD 188985, and HD 202020 as no good lines of Sm were available for abundance estimation.
Eu abundance is determined for six objects using spectrum synthesis calculation of lines Eu II 4129.71 Å, 6437.63 Å, and 6645.11 Å considering hyperfine structure from Worley et al. (2013). CD 1082 shows enhancement with [Eu/Fe] 2.07 measured using only one line Eu II 6437.63 Å. In HD 123701, this line shows a marginal enhancement with [Eu/Fe] = 0.15. For HE 03081612 and HD 87080 we have used the Eu II 6645.11 Å that gives [Eu/Fe] 0.36. Abundance of Eu estimated using the line Eu II 4129.71 Å gives [Eu/Fe] values 0.38, 0.10 and 0.07 for HD 176021, 188985 and HD 202020. Abundance of Eu measured using equivalent width measurement of Eu II 4205.042 Å gives [Eu/Fe] 0.34 for HD 87853. Abundance of Eu could not be estimated for HD 29370, HD 30443, CD 2151, and HD 50264 as no good lines are available for abundance estimation.
We have estimated [ls/Fe], [hs/Fe] and [hs/ls], where ls stands for the light s-process elements (Sr, Y, Zr) and hs stands for the heavy s-process (Ba, La, Ce, Nd, Sm) elements; these values are presented in Table 6.
7 KINEMATIC ANALYSIS
Space velocity of the programme stars are calculated using the method described in Bensby, Feltzing & Lundstrom (2003). The space velocity with respect to the Local Standard of Rest (LSR) is given by
km/s.
where, km/s (Schönrich et al., 2010) is the solar motion with respect to LSR , and
[TABLE]
where B = T.A, k = 4.74057 km s*-1*, is the proper motion in right ascension, in arcsec yr*-1*, is the proper motion in declination, in arcsec yr*-1*, is the radial velocity in kms*-1* and is the parallax in arcsec.
The transformation matrix connecting Galactic coordinates and equatorial coordinates is:
[TABLE]
Coordinate matrix A can be defined as:
[TABLE]
Where is the right ascension and is the declination in degrees. We are using a right-handed coordinate system for U,V and W. Hence they are positive in the directions of the Galactic center, Galactic rotation, and the North Galactic Pole (NGP) respectively (Johnson & Soderblom (1987)).
The estimates for proper motion are taken from SIMBAD. Distances are measured taking parallax values from SIMBAD and Gaia (Gaia Collaboration 2016, Gaia Collaboration et al. 2018b) whenever available. We have used the radial velocity estimates and the corresponding error estimates as measured by us.
The total spatial velocity of a star is given by,
The probability for a star’s membership into the thin disk, the thick disk or the halo population are also calculated following the procedures of Reddy, Lambert & Priesto (2006), Bensby et al. (2003, 2004), Mishenina et al. (2004), and presented in Table 7, along with the estimated components of spatial velocity and the total spatial velocity. The selection of the thick or thin disk stars and halo stars are based on the assumption that the Galactic space velocities of these stars have Gaussian distributions.
where
The values of the characteristic velocity dispersion , and and the asymmetric drift are adopted from Reddy et al. (2006).
8 DISCUSSION
In the following, we discuss the abundance patterns and other properties of the individual stars.
HE 0308-1612 - This object is listed among the 403 faint high latitude carbon stars of Hamburg/ESO survey(HES; Christlieb et al. 2001). From low-resolution spectroscopic analysis Goswami (2005) confirmed this object to be a potential CH star. In this work we have conducted a detailed chemical analysis based on a high resolution spectrum. The object is found to be mildly metal-poor with a metallicity of 0.73. Further, with its estimated [C/Fe]0.78, [Ba/Fe]1.63 and [Ba/Eu]1.28, the star may be placed in the group of CEMP-s stars. As the oxygen abundance could not be estimated, this object could not be classified on the basis of C/O ratio. The star has a low value of 15.6 for 12C/13C ratio.
CD28 1082 - This star belongs to the CH star catalogue of Bartkevicius (1996). This work presents the first time abundance analysis for this object. The object is found to be a very metal-poor with a metallicity of 2.45. Carbon is highly enhanced with [C/Fe] 2.19. Barium as well as europium are also found to be enhanced relative to iron. The star satisfies the classification criteria for CEMP-r/s stars ([C/Fe] 1, [Ba/Fe] 1 and 0.0 [Ba/Eu] 0.50) of Beers & Christlieb (2005)).
A comparison of the the abundance ratios of light and heavy elements in CD 1082 with those observed in CEMP-r/s and CH stars from literature (Figs 18 and 19) shows a good match with the CEMP-r/s stars. Three CEMP-r/s stars from Aoki et al.(2007) exhibit very high Mg abundances (CS 29497-034 ([Mg/Fe] = 1.31), CS 29528-028 ([Mg/Fe] = 1.69), and HE 1447+0102 ([Mg/Fe] = 1.43)). The astrophysical processes that could produce such high enhancement of Mg are not clearly understood (Aoki et al. 2007). Our estimated value of [Mg/Fe] (= 0.45) for CD 28 1082 is close to that found by Magain (1989), who had obtained a mean value of [Mg/Fe] = 0.480.09 dex from an analysis of 20 extremely metal-poor halo dwarfs in the metallicity range [Fe/H] .
Analysis of extremely metal-poor field giants in the metallicity range [Fe/H] by Gratton & Sneden (1988) suggested a mean value of [Mg/Fe] = 0.27 dex with a star-to-star scatter of 0.14 dex. [Mg/Fe] is found to be increasing with decreasing [Fe/H]. The analysis of Edvardsson et al. (1993) shows [Mg/Fe] 0.5 dex at [Fe/H] = dex and attains near solar value at [Fe/H] = 0.0 dex. They also report anomalously large value of [Mg/Fe] for a few of the disk dwarfs in their sample. de Castro et al. (2016) analysed the variation of [Mg/Fe] with [Fe/H] for both barium and field giants that lie in a range from 0.0 to 0.5-0.6 at [Fe/H] . In the log(12C/13C) versus [C/N] plot of Masseron (2010), this object falls well within the region occupied by CEMP stars (Fig 20).
From kinematic analysis, CD 1082 is found to be a thick disk star with a probability of nearly 73 percent. The estimated spatial velocity ( 180 km s*-1*) is similar to that expected for halo objects (Chen, Nissen & Zhao 2004). This object also satisfies the condition for VLSR -120Km s*-1* for it to be a halo star (Eggen 1997).
There exist several physical scenarios on the formation of CEMP-r/s stars (Jonsell et al. 2006, Bisterzo et al. 2011 and references there in). One of the possible scenarios is that, the CEMP-r/s stars are formed in a medium enriched in r-process elements which is produced by a supernovae explosion in the past. Argast et al. (2004) studied the interstellar enrichment of r-process elements in the context of inhomegenous chemical evolution. Their studies show that core collapse supernovae are the dominant source of r-process elements compared to neutron star mergers. Calculations of Rosswog et al. (1999, 2000) show that although the amount of r-process matter ejected in neutron star merger is much larger than that in supernovae collapse, the rate of neutron star merger in the galaxy is less than the Type II SNe (Tammann, Lffler & Schrder 1994; Belczynski, Kalogera & Bulik 2002 ). Hence it is likely that both of these sources might contribute to the r-process elements in the Galaxy (Qian & Woosley 1996; Rosswog et al. 1999; Rosswog & Davies 2002; Thielemann et al. 2002).
Bisterzo et al. (2011) suggest that the molecular cloud from which the binary system formed was previously polluted in r-process elements by some r-process sources, believed to have occurred during supernovae explosions and /or neutron star mergers (Thielemann et al. 2011, Wehmeyer et al. 2015). Argast et al. (2004) rule out neutron star merger as a dominant source of r-process since the expected r-process enrichment by neutron star merger is not found to be consistent with the observations at very low metallicity stars. However, Van de Voort et al. (2015) studied the abundance pattern of r-process elements using cosmological zoom-in simulations of a Milky Way-mass galaxy using various models for the rate and delay time of neutron star mergers and obtained results that are in contrast to those of Argast et al. (2004).
It was shown in Van de Voort et al. (2015) that the neutron star mergers can produce [r-process/Fe] abundance ratios and scatter, consistent with the observations for stars with metallicity in the range [Fe/H] 0. Despite some uncertainties in their model calculations, it was concluded that neutron star mergers can be an important source of the majority of the r-process elements. Investigation of the production sites of r-process elements in the Galaxy by Shen et al. (2015) based on the high resolution cosmological zoom-in simulation also concludes that neutron star mergers can be a dominant production site of r-process elements even at low metallicity. Haynes et al. (2018) studied the distribution of elemental abundance ratios using chemodynamical simulations including various neutron capture processes such as magneto-rotational supernovae, neutron star mergers, neutrino driven winds and electron capture supernovae. A comparison of their predicted trend between [Eu/Fe] and [Eu/O] as a function of metallicity with the observational data shows that neither electron capture supernovae nor neutrino driven winds could explain the observed Eu levels; however, neutron star mergers and magneto-rotational supernovae are able to justify the observed Eu abundances.
The possible explantion for the observed s-process enhancemet is attributed to a binary companion. Another scenario of CEMP-r/s stars formation is that it is born in a triple system (Cohen et al. 2003), in which one of the companions explodes as supernova. The tertiary star accretes the r-process rich material from this companion. The enhancement in carbon and s-process elements are explained by the accretion of materials from its secondary AGB companion. Cohen et al. (2003) also suggested another mechanism in which the CEMP-r/s stars are initially polluted by its binary companion which later becomes a white dwarf. At some point the reverse mass transfer can take place from the secondary star to the white dwarf. This may induce accretion induced collapse of the white dwarf if it is an O-Ne-Mg dwarf. The resultant neutrino driven wind is sufficient to contribute r-process elements on the surface of the secondary star. Yet another possible scenario is that the CEMP-r/s star is in a binary system and accretes material from its primary companion. Later the companion explodes as a type 1.5 supernova (Zijlstra, 2004). Low metallicity stars with initial mass 3-4 M undergo this type of evolution (Zijlstra 2004). Abate, Stancliffe & Liu (2016) have examined the possibility of different mechanisms of formation of CEMP-r/s stars but could not reproduce the observed frequency of CEMP-r/s stars by their simulations.
Several authors (Hansen et al. 2016; Hampel et al. 2016 and references therein) have discussed the possibilities of i-process in low metallicity AGB stars as the origin of CEMP-r/s stars. The neutron density associated with the i-process is sufficient to produce both the s and r process elements in AGB stars. Hampel et al. (2016) showed that the observed abundance pattern in many of the CEMP-r/s is consistent with the model calculations for i-process within the observational errors. It would be worthwhile to check in the future if the abundance pattern observed in CD28 1082 can be explained on the basis of the i-process.
CD38 2151 - ** This star belongs to the CH star catalogue of Bartkevicius (1996). Our abundance estimates are also characteristic of giant CH stars. The probability estimate shows this to be a thick disk object. With the lower bound, the spatial velocity estimate supports the inclusion of the star into the disk population while the upper bound in spatial velocity and the metallicity estimate shows this to be a halo object. It also satisfies the condition VLSR 120 Kms-1 for it to be a halo star (Eggen 1997).
Previous studies on this object include an abundance analysis by Vanture (1992) who had performed abundance estimates for six heavy elements based on spectra with typical resolution of 20000. Our detailed abundance analysis for both heavy and light elements are based on higher resolution spectra. The star is found to be very metal-poor with a metallicity ( 2.0). Carbon is enhanced with [C/Fe] 1.50. The heavy s-process element barium is also enhanced. However, as we could not estimate the Eu abundance, its membership for CEMP-r/s class of objects could not be examined based on the CEMP stars classification scheme of Beers & Christlieb (2005). A comparison of our elemental abundance ratios with literature values including Vanture’s are presented in Table 8. Although our Teff estimate is close to Vanture’s, log g value differs from his. While for La and Ce our estimates are lower than Vanture’s, for Nd and Sm our estimates are higher. Spectrum synthesis calculation of La II 4921.77 Å gives a better fit with our adopted La abundance than that obtained using Vanture’s atmospheric parameters and abundance value of La. In the log(/) versus [C/N] plot (Fig. 20), CD 2151 falls in the region occupied by the CEMP stars. Estimated C/O 1.26 is similar to values seen in CH stars.
**HD 30443 - ** This star belongs to the CH star catalogue of Bartkevicius (1996). Yamashita (1975) also had classified this object as a CH star. This work presents for the first time a detailed abundance analysis for this object. The estimated metallicity is . The star is enhanced in Carbon with [C/Fe]1.68 as well as in other heavy elements. The abundance estimates of the star are characteristic of CH giants. The estimated C/O 1.02 is similar to values seen in CH stars. From the kinematic analysis, HD 30443 is found to be a thin disk star with a probability of 98 percent. The estimated spatial velocity is 62.04 km , which is similar to that expected for thin disk objects (Chen et al. 2004).
**HD 29370 and HD 123701 - ** These two objects are listed in both the CH star catalogue of Bartkevicius (1996) and the barium star catalogue of Lü (1991). Sleivyte & Bartkevicius (1990) based on photometric analysis included HD 29370 in the category of metal-deficient barium stars. However, Catchpole, Robertson & Warren (1977) classified HD 29370 as a metal weak CH star. Mennessier et al. (1997) suggested this object to be either a subgiant or a giant star. From our estimates of luminosity and temperature, we have confirmed it to be a giant star from its location in the H-R diagram. de Castro et al. (2016) have estimated the abundance of the Na, Al, -elements, iron-peak elements, and s-process elements Y, Zr, La, Ce, and Nd for these two objects. In addition to these elements we have derived abundances for elements C, N and O for HD 123701 and C and N for HD 29370 which were not presented in de Castro et al. (2016). Our analysis confirms the object HD 123701 to be a barium star with C/O 0.15. As the oxygen abundance could not be estimated for HD 29370, it could not be classified based on estimates of the C/O ratio.
HD 50264 - This object is listed in both the CH star catalogue of Bartkevicius (1996) and the barium star catalogue of Lü (1991). While Bond (1974) considered this star as a CH subgiant, Mennessier et al. (1997) grouped HD 50264 as a dwarf. According to the analysis of Pereira & Junqueira (2003) both HD 50264 and HD 87080 are CH subgiants. Our analysis shows the object to exhibit characteristic properties of barium stars with C/O ratio 0.41.
HD 87080 - This object is listed in both the CH star catalogue of Bartkevicius (1996) and the barium star catalogue of Lü (1991). Mennessier et al. (1997) assigned HD 87080 to group of subgiants. Our work confirms the same. A comparison of our estimates of elemental abundance ratios with those of Allen & Barbuy (2006a,b) is presented in Table 8. For most of the elements we find a good agreement. This object shows the characteristic properties of barium stars with C/O ratio 0.29.
**HD 87853 - ** This star is found to be mildly metal-poor with an estimated metallicity of 0.73. All the elements show abundances as expected for normal metal-poor star of similar metallicity. This is true for -elements as well as for heavy neutron capture elements. The position of the star on the HR diagram indicates that the star has just left the main-sequence, approaching the subgiant stage.
HD 176021 - Bond (1970) considered this star as a subgiant CH star. This star belongs to the CH star catalogue of Bartkevicius (1996). While Bensby, Feltzing & Oey (2014) derived abundances for a few elements, Battistini & Bensby (2015) determined the abundances of Sc, V, Mn and Co to study the origin and evolution of these elements in a homogenous sample of stars. According to our abundance estimates, the star qualifies to be a sub-giant CH star. We have also measured abundances of carbon and nitrogen, and both are found to be similarly enhanced. The ratio of C/O could not be estimated for this object.
HD 188985 - This object is listed in both the CH star catalogue of Bartkevicius (1996) and the barium star catalogue of Lü (1991). North et al. (1994) and Mennessier et al. (1997) placed this object as a barium dwarf. Our analysis confirms the same. Our abundance estimates match closely with those of Allen & Barbuy (2006a,b). Estimated C/O ratio for this object is 0.89.
HD 202020 - From radial velocity monitoring, McClure (1997) confirmed HD 202020 to be a binary with an orbital period of 2064 d. The first abundance analysis for this star was performed by Luck & Bond (1991); however abundances of elements such as carbon, Nitrogen, Strontium and Barium were not presented. We have estimated the abundances of these elements in the present work. HD 202020 is listed in Bartkevicius (1996). There is a discrepancy regarding the oxygen abundance in this star. If we consider the value of oxygen abundance obtained using the line at 6300.3 Å, estimated C/O ratio turns out to be 1, a value generally seen in case of CH stars. With C/O 1.99, the star qualifies to be a CH star. We get a value much lower than one, if we consider the non-LTE corrected abundance value of oxygen obtained from the oxygen triplet lines. We note that, a value of C/O 1 is generally seen for barium stars.
The position of our programme stars in the colour-magnitude diagram is shown in Fig. 21. A comparison of the abundances of both light and heavy elements of our programme stars with those of Ba stars, CH stars and CEMP stars from literature is shown in Figs 22 and 23, respectively.
9 Conclusion
Abundance analysis results of 12 potential CH star candidates, 11 from the CH stars catalogue of Bartkevicious (1996) and one object HE 03081612 from Goswami et al. (2010) are presented. Detailed analysis shows two of them, CD28 1082 and CD38 2151 to be very metal-poor and highly enhanced in carbon. Five objects HE 03081612, HD 30443, HD 87853, HD 176021 and HD 202020 show characteristic properties of CH stars. Estimated C/O ratios for these objects are similar to those generally noticed in CH stars. While HE 03081612 and HD 30443 are CH giants, HD 87853 and HD 176021 are CH subgiants, and HD 202020 is in turn off stage. The abundance patterns of these stars match well with the abundance patterns of CH stars from literature.
While HE 03081612, and HD 176021 show moderate enhancement of carbon, HD 202020 shows near solar carbon abundance. Among the CH stars, HD 30443 shows the highest carbon enhancement with [C/Fe] 1.68. The remaining five objects, HD 29370, HD 50264, HD 87080, HD 123701 and HD 188985 are found to show the characteristic properties of barium stars. Among the barium stars, only one object HD 87080 is found to be moderately metal-poor ([Fe/H] = 0.47), the rest four are near solar. Barium stars with [Ba/Fe] 0.60 are classified as strong Ba stars (Yang et al. 2016). All the Ba stars in our sample show [Ba/Fe] 1 and are Ba strong. The abundance patterns of the Ba stars match well with the abundance patterns of strong Ba stars in the sample of de Castro et al. (2016) and Yang et al. (2016). de Castro et al. (2016) shows that 90 percent of the Ba stars in their sample belong to thin disk population. From kinematic analysis, all the five Ba stars are found to belong to thin disk population.
We could estimate the carbon isotopic ratio 12C/13C only for six objects, two CEMP, two CH and two barium stars. The values are found to be in the range 7.4-16. The stars for which we could estimate 12C/13C are either in the giant or the subgiant phase of evolution. During the H burning stage of the main-sequence stars, proton capture of a 12C can take place leading to the production of 13C. According to the standard evolutionary theory, the convective envelope of the star, which is ascending the giant branch, can expand inward and mix the CNO processed material from the burning shell to the outer envelope. As a result of this first dredge up, the carbon isotopic ratio on the surface of the star may decrease. This may explain the low 12C/13C values estimated for our programme stars. The low values of 12C/13C ( 15) may also be explained by certain nucleosynthesis of the material contributed by the donor star, in which the accreted material is mixed into the hydrogen burning region either during the main-sequence or the first ascent of the giant branch (Vanture, 1992).
Nitrogen is enhanced in all the stars other than HD 29370. Nitrogen production is believed to be mostly through CN cycling. First dredge up brings the CNO processed nitrogen to the surface as the star evolves to the red giant branch. Because of this, in normal giants the nitrogen is found to be enhanced and 12C/13C reduced. A second distinct mixing episode can happen when the star becomes brighter than the RGB bump (Gratton et al. 2000). This can also reduce the observed 12C/13C ratio to nearly 6-10 and the abundance of nitrogen can raise by nearly a factor of 4. The abundance pattern is expected to be the same until the AGB phase of evolution where the second/third dredge-up can cause changes in the surface chemical compositions. Contrary to this, observations show that the abundances of light elements such as C, N, O and the carbon isotopic ratio are modified at the RGB bump. This is exhibited by more than 95 percent of the low-mass stars and it is found to be independent of the stellar environment (Charbonnel & do Nascimento, 1998). Zahn (1992) proposed that the interaction between meridional circulation and turbulence induced rotation can be the cause of mixing and the subsequent changes in the surface chemical compositions. Charbonnel (2005) suggested that this extra mixing may be rotation induced. But none of these processes alone could explain the observations. Based on the 3D modelling of low-mass RGB stars (Dearborn, Lattanzio & Eggleton 2006), Eggleton, Dearborn & Lattanzio (2006) suggested that the molecular-weight inversion created by 3He(3He, 2p) 4He reaction in the outer regions of H burning shell can cause a transport mechanism often referred as thermohaline mixing that may cause a change in the surface chemical compositions of C, N, O, and Na. The effect of thermohaline mixing on the surface abundances of a low-metallicity, low-mass star that has accreted material from a carbon rich companion has also been investigated by Stancliffe et al. (2007) based on binary models. It is commonly assumed that a star that accreted material keep it on the surface without any mixing with the interior until the first dredge up; however, thermohaline mixing can happen that causes the mixing of accreted material with the rest of the star as it has a higher mean molecular weight.
All the stars in our sample show enhancement in heavy elements. As their evolutionary status does not support the observed enhanced abundances of heavy elements, the enhancement may be attributed to an invisible binary companion. In our sample, only HD 202020 is a confirmed binary (McClure 1997).
The abundance results presented here will add to the abundance data obtained from our previous studies in a homogeneous manner and compiled in Cristallo et al. (2016), that can be used to constrain the physics and the nucleosynthesis occuring in low-mass AGB stars. Abundance results of CEMP-r/s stars will provide observational constrains for theoretical studies of i-process, suggested in the recent years for the origin of CEMP-r/s stars.
10 ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
We thank the staff at IAO and at the remote control station at CREST, Hosakote, and the staff at VBO, Kavalur, for assisting during the observations. Funding from DST SERB project No. EMR/2016/005283 is gratefully acknowledged. We thank the anonymous referee for many constructive suggestions. We would like to acknowledge Abha K for performing some initial calculations on a few stars while at IIA during 2015. This work made use of the SIMBAD astronomical database, operated at CDS, Strasbourg, France, the NASA ADS, USA and data from the European Space Agency (ESA) mission Gaia (https://www.cosmos.esa.int/gaia), processed by the Gaia Data Processing and Analysis Consortium (DPAC, https://www.cosmos.esa.int/web/gaia/dpac/consortium). T.M. acknowledges support provided by the Spanish Ministry of Economy and Competitiveness (MINECO) under grant AYA-2017-88254-P. Based on data collected using VBT echelle, HESP, and FEROS.
The reference list from the paper itself. Each links out to its DOI / PubMed record.
- 1[1] Abate C., Pols O.R., Izzard R.G., Mohamed S.S., de Mink S. E. 2013, A&A, 552, A 26
- 2[2] Abate C., Pols O.R., Izzard R.G., Karakas A.I., 2015 a, A&A, 581, A 22
- 3[3] Abate C., Pols O.R., Karakas A.I., Izzard R.G., 2015 b, A&A, 576, A 118
- 4[4] Abate C., Stancliffe R.J., Liu Z-W., 2016, A&A, 587, 50
- 5[5] Allen D.M., Barbuy B., 2006 a, A&A, 454, 895
- 6[6] Allen D.M., Barbuy B., 2006 b, A&A, 454, 917
- 7[7] Alonso A., Arribas S., Martinez-Roger C., 1999, A&AS, 140, 261
- 8[8] Alonso A., Arribas S., Martinez-Roger C., 2001, A&A, 376, 1039
