Revisiting Kunitomo's Sunspot Drawings during 1835-1836 in Japan

TL;DR

This study revisits and analyzes Kunitomo Toubei's 1835-1836 sunspot drawings, providing revised sunspot group counts, correlations with spot areas, and improved positional data, enhancing historical solar activity records.

Contribution

It offers a detailed re-evaluation of Kunitomo's sunspot observations, including revised group counts, correlation analysis, and positional data, filling gaps in historical solar activity data.

Findings

Kunitomo's RGCs tend to be smaller than contemporaries.

A correlation of 0.71 between RGCs and spot areas was found.

Kunitomo captured the early growth of Solar Cycle 8.

Abstract

We revisit the sunspot drawings made by the Japanese astronomer Kunitomo Toubei during 1835-1836 and recount the sunspot group number for each image. There are two series of drawings, preliminary (P, containing 17 days with observations) and summary (S, covering 156 days with observations), all made using brush and ink. S is a compilation of drawings for the period from February 1835, to March 1836. Presently, the P drawings are available only for one month, September 1835; those of other periods have presumably been lost. Another drawing (I) lets us recover the raw group count (RGC) for 25 September 1836, on which the RGC has not been registered in the existing catalogs. We also revise the RGCs from P and S using the Zurich classification and determine that Kunitomo's results tend to yield smaller RGCs than those of other contemporary observers. In addition, we find that Kunitomo's RGCs and spot areas have a correlation (0.71) that is not very different from the contemporary observer Schwabe (0.82). Although Kunitomo's spot areas are much larger than those determined by Schwabe due to skill and instrument limitations, Kunitomo at least captured the growing trend of the spot activity in the early phase of the Solar Cycle 8. We also determine the solar rotation axis to estimate the accurate position (latitude and longitude) of the sunspot groups in Kunitomo's drawings.