# Can a cosmic ray carrot explain the ionization level in diffuse molecular clouds?

## TL;DR

This study evaluates the hypothesis that an unknown low-energy cosmic ray component, called a carrot, could explain the ionization rates in diffuse molecular clouds, and finds it energetically and physically implausible.

## Contribution

The paper critically assesses the viability of the cosmic ray carrot hypothesis as an ionization source in molecular clouds, providing energetic and magnetic turbulence constraints.

## Key findings

- The power required for a cosmic ray carrot exceeds the total cosmic ray energy budget.
- Magnetic turbulence levels needed for Fermi acceleration of a carrot are unrealistic.
- The cosmic ray carrot hypothesis is effectively ruled out as a significant ionization source.

## Abstract

Low energy cosmic rays are the major ionization agents of molecular clouds. However, it has been shown that, if the cosmic ray spectrum measured by Voyager 1 is representative of the whole Galaxy, the predicted ionization rate in diffuse clouds fails to reproduce data by 1-2 orders of magnitude, implying that an additional source of ionization must exist. One of the solutions proposed to explain this discrepancy is based on the existence of an unknown low energy (in the range 1 keV-1 MeV, not probed by Voyager) cosmic ray component, called carrot when first hypothesized by Reeves and collaborators in the seventies. Here we investigate the energetic required by such scenario. We show that the power needed to maintain such low energy component is comparable of even larger than that needed to explain the entire observed cosmic ray spectrum. Moreover, if the interstellar turbulent magnetic field has to sustain a carrot, through second-order Fermi acceleration, the required turbulence level would be definitely too large compared to the one expected at the scale resonant with such low energy particles. Our study basically rules out all the plausible sources of a cosmic ray carrot, thus making such hidden component unlikely to be an appealing and viable source of ionization in molecular clouds.